Jason Mackey: Hello, everyone. Welcome to my weekly Pirates chat. We'll get going at noon, but please feel free to fire away now. Thanks, as always, for participating.

Jason Mackey: And away we go ...

Guest: The Pirates are selling season tix for games to start 4 months from now. Do they know something that Dr. Fauci doesn’t?

Jason Mackey: I don't see that as anything unique. They need to continue functioning as a business. I think everyone can kinda see there should be an asterisk attached to any tickets purchased. At the same time, looking at other events, I can see why they'd be optimistic they could get at least some fans inside PNC Park.

Advertise with us

TP Ranger: Hi Jason. Thanks for your excellent work from Bradenton, giving us a heads up about many of the Pirates promising young players. Given that the team's best hope of reaching the playoffs is still 2-3 years down the road, what is the team's best approach for 2021? Should fans anticipate a .500 sort of season?

Jason Mackey: Appreciate that, TP. Yeah, I think best-case .500. I don't think they're as bad as 19-41, and I don't see them as a playoff team. Here's why: It's reasonable to think Bryan Reynolds, Kevin Newman and Josh Bell will perform better than they did in 2020. We get a full season of Ke'Bryan Hayes. I also think Anthony Alford can be pretty solid in center. The bullpen found some decent arms. I think the rotation can be good if it stays healthy, as evidenced by what happened over the final 15 games or so. Do they have enough power? No. Are they good enough in the field? TBD. Definitely not enough depth. Gregory Polanco is a wild card/mostly a disappointment for the money. But I do see them with some decent potential to improve.

TP Ranger: Jason, in view of the backlash from Game 7 of the World Series, do you see a point where analytics may slowly be de-emphasized and "eyeball" managing and scouting return to prominance?

Jason Mackey: It was Game 6, TP, but I get your point. And I don't think it will de-emphasize analytics as much as it might remind that eyes and feel are important, too. But that being said, I think the Rays feel like they have to play and run the game a certain way to be successful. And given baseball's financial climate, I'm not sure they're wrong.

TP Ranger: The Pirates most likely will need to fill in with a couple of free-agents? Anyone out there they have their eyes on that you are aware of?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: No. They're so far down the line with that stuff that it's a fool's errand to try and predict.

TP Ranger: Can MLB help teams who are suffering loss of income from no attendance by advancing them some of the national TV money slated for future years?

Jason Mackey: I'm not sure, TP. That's an interesting question. I think the issue would become "which teams?" I think, right or wrong, that a lot would say they're in trouble. And, also, I don't know how "advanceable" any of that is in a realistic sense. Like the Pirates have had to furlough or fire employees. Are we saying they can re-boost their business side because we've repurposed expected dollars from 2023? I'm just not sure how possible any of that is.

Guest: Think of moving Bell to American League.. DH to the true definition. What kind of prospects could we exspect in return ??? Do you feel there would be serious interest ??

Jason Mackey: Not right now, not based on his 2020 season and 2019 finish. Or, I should see, I don't think the interest is where it could be. I just don't see the urgency to make that move right now. If you're going to trade Bell -- I'd still like to see them keep him and send a message to fans -- the idea will be to do it right, not quickly. This would be the latter.

Advertise with us

Jeff: WHy would Shelton back Cash's decision? He has nothing to gain and only invites the question why? I get it was his first year so he gets a performance pass but why when most baseball people DONT agree with the move why even comment on it? Dodge the question

Jason Mackey: I can't really answer that for you, Jeff. Only Shelton can. I give him credit for speaking honestly, though. i don't agree with him, but also, my opinion and your opinion mean a heck of a lot less than his. ... I get the numbers thing. No issue. But my God, baseball needs to better utilize feel and sensibility.

Guest: Good morning. Given the spending history of Pirates ownership, what free agents do we realistically have a shot at signing? And would Nick Burdi be included in that group?

Jason Mackey: Good morning/afternoon. The Pirates do have interest in Burdi. As for others, honestly, no. I'm not looking at them to sign anyone even remotely splashy. They'll sign a few. Maybe they'll find a Jordan Lyles or Corey Dickerson in there. But nothing crazy. My read on their situation is that they're gonna build with prospects, grow those guys up into major leaguers, then supplement around them.

Jason Mackey: I do think that Bob Nutting will spend when it's time. I don't think Ben Cherington or Travis Williams would have come here if they didn't truly believe that. But I just think, whether you agree or not, there are some things that have to happen first.

Advertise with us

Wilbur Wood: Are there any "soft tossers," i.e, John Tudor like guys still in the game or is everyone a greater or lesser flame thrower. And do you think the knuckleball pitcher is extinct?

Jason Mackey: There are a few. Kyle Hendricks is my favorite. Someone who gets by on location and knowing how to pitch. I love the contract it offers to the obsession over velocity or spin rate. One of my favorite pitchers growing was always Greg Maddux for that reason. Jamie Moyer, too.

Jason Mackey: And, yeah, I honestly don't remember the last time I saw someone chucking knucks. Maybe Newman and Reynolds during batting practice.

Tameson Jaillon: Has Nutting shown any signs that he will allow Cherington and the front office to do more money wise? Do you think he ever will?

Jason Mackey: Tamo, good to hear from you. Cherington is on record saying he believes the Pirates will spend when it's time: https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/pirates/2020/02/16/ben-cherington-...

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I don't know what else I can give you. It's not like written in blood or anything around the ballpark.

Lad 9: Hi Jason. I very much enjoy your coverage - you truly are all over the beat. Thank you. My question is: Do you ever see a scenario where Nick Gonzales is shifted to first base? The reason I ask is the glut (hopefully) of talent in the middle infield. I can see Peguero at SS, I think that Cruz will end up in RF and I certainly believe that Gonzales could be the second baseman, but that leaves Bae out in the cold. Mason Martin is the hope at 1B, but there is a LOT of swing and miss in his game and that is concerning, even though he is young. I know that Gonzales really goesn't have the preferred size for 1B, but his bat is a much better fit. Just a thought for a few years down the road.

Jason Mackey: No, I don't, Lad. And thank you for the kind words on the coverage. Gonzales is too small, honestly. If they were going to move him anywhere, it would be the outfield. Actually talked to Nick about this a couple months ago. He grew up playing outfield. Caught some, too, but really did well in the outfield. I asked if he thought he could do it at the major league level. "Absolutely," he said. Plus, Martin is legit.

Lenny: Are you hearing any word on who the Pirates affiliates will be next year and if they would be any changes?

Jason Mackey: I have not, Lenny. There's a lot up in the air with minor league stuff, but I've gotten no indication there will be any major changes.

Advertise with us

Bob K: With minor league affiliations already changing, what do you think happens to black bears (morgantown), since NY-Penn league is effectively gone? I assume Indianapolis, Altoona are ok, since they are "close enough" to Pgh. But what about Greenville? Maybe Morgantown goes into High A in the new "Mid-Atlantic" League??

Jason Mackey: Yeah, Bob, to build off of what Lenny asked: I don't think there will be any changes with Indy or Altoona. There might be some shuffling at the lower levels, and I can't profess to have enough of a feel on Greenville. I can tell you that I've never heard anything about the Pirates potentially losing it.

Jeff: Good afternoon. Given the history of spending by Pirates ownership, what free agents do we realistically have a shot at signing? And is Nick Burdi in that group?

Jason Mackey: Hi, Jeff. I think I got this one earlier. If there's something you're wondering that I didn't address, please ask again.

wvpirate: Do you think this winter we are probably going to see the Pirates trade established players for prospects. And sign stop gap free agents who might be traded at the deadline?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: I think we'll see some of that, yeah. I'm expecting Adam Frazier to be traded and, to a lesser degree, Joe Musgrove, which would probably depend on return. Both deals would net prospects. I also think they will sign some free agents -- again, nothing huge -- on short-term deals that they could potentially flip.

Dick: Who will be our comeback player of the year? We have several candidates.

Jason Mackey: I think it has to be Jameson Taillon if he's able to make a bunch of starts and do really well.

MjB: This is it. This is the time to instill a salary cap, both ceiling and floor. That's how you stabilize the economics of the sport in these times. Please tell me why that's not possible under these circumstances? I know that there are teams with super high payroll. Fine, take that team and make it the top. Then, raise the bottom to 20% above the lowest team. It needs to occur.

Jason Mackey: I agree with you. I wish there was a cap, believe me. But it's because the MLBPA will never, ever agree to it. Maybe baseball comes back in its next CBA with a cap. But nobody is gonna agree to that now. Does need to happen, though, absolutely. I think baseball is losing -- and has lost fans -- because of the competitive imbalance that exists. It's a shame because it's a great sport. Also needs to speed up games.

Advertise with us

Drew VonScio: Jason, has anything been established by the league about how many rounds there will be for the 2021 Draft? I'm hoping that it will be more than five so that the Pirates can continue to build up their farm system.

Jason Mackey: Nothing has been established. Believe it will be more than five, but there's nothing more substantive than that, to my knowledge.

wvpirate: How do you feel about the expanded playoffs? I felt it was too long. I wasn't interested until the last 4 teams played. In a 162 game schedule. I only want to see the best teams play.

Jason Mackey: I don't love it. I can also see why limiting it to four per league isn't going to have for competitive and financial reasons. I'm not a huge fan of one- or three-game matchups; maybe it's the hockey writer in me, but I wish everything was seven. ... I could see top four in each league make it and they play seven. ... Or maybe I'd have to be OK with less than seven if they expanded. Just not to 16 again. Too watered down.

Scott: I didn't think Burdi had enough active days to shed his Rule 5 designation, so why wasn't he offered back to the Twins after clearing waivers?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: He did have enough active days to shed his Rule 5 designation.

Ricky: Any word if the pirates are showing interest in Yasiel puig? He would be a massive upgrade in the outfield. Also he would be a guy good for the clubhouse and would bring some fans to the games

Jason Mackey: No doubt. That sort of signing is long overdue. Maybe once they erect the statue of him outside PNC Park, they can finalize the contract.

Ricky: is Archer getting any interest from teams at the moment?

Jason Mackey: Have not heard of any. Doesn't mean it hasn't happen, but nothing has trickled out publicly.

Advertise with us

Pirates fan: who do you see closing next year? Any chance Kela is back? How do you feel about Cederlind?

Jason Mackey: I actually think the Pirates are going to use more of a committee next year. Asked Shelton this when we talked. I don't think Kela will be back. I like Cederlind a lot, but I think they worry whether it might be too much, too soon for the young man. Maybe his performance changes that, but right now, I expect them to rotate the job.

Scott: It's quite simple, the fact that Snell was "dealing" has no effect on his future performance--studies and data show that. The future is uncertain, so the only logical path is doing what the data suggests, even if the outcome is 50.1/49.9. No such thing as a crystal ball, so make a rationale decision based on data, not "gut". Cash has said in the past if he's making a decision based no his gut, he isn't prepared, and he's 100% correct. I'd rather someone have a reason for their decision than just saying "my gut said so". Can't back up that decision, thus it's a bad one.

Jason Mackey: Thanks, Scott. I appreciate your thoughts on it. I disagree with your premise -- future is uncertain, etc. Yes, the future is always uncertain. With anything. It's a measure of predictors, right? With the stuff Snell had, the success that he had with it, it was a greater predictor of success than if it would have lacked break or control and he would have been hit hard. So, while that doesn't guarantee future success, it does increase the probability of it. Enough where I would have been comfortable leaving him in. I don't think it's a "bad" decision by Cash. But when I say using eyes and feel, it's more taking into account how your stuff feels that day. To my knowledge, there's no way of quantifying someone feeling comfortable or in a groove. Thus, I'm uneasy on making decisions solely based on that or numbers. Mix 'em.

Danny: Could Musgrove realistically land an Alek Manoah or Gabriel Moreno plus another top 10-15 prospect in a potential Blue Jays trade?

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Depends on how bad the Blue Jays feel like they might need or want Musgrove. Middle-of-next-season if they have injuries? Yeah, I could see it. Now? Seems like a bit of a stretch.

Pirates fan: Pirates should sign Jonathan Villar and trade Frazier

Jason Mackey: I don't have anything against the concept. Was a 3.9 bWAR player in 2019. Only issue for me would be the contract. He made $8.2 million last season. Is he going to accept something the Pirates are willing to pay? I'm not sure those lines intersect.

Wilbur Wood: Jamie Moyer! I could not think of his last name. Okay, to another well discussed topic mostly related to Josh Bell and Gregory Polanco. As both of them came through the system we heard about how good they were going to be once they got settled into the majors. But so far, aside from some flashes of brilliance, and in Bell's case a really brilliant flash, neither of them has lived up to their billing and neither are exactly new to the majors. I'd bet that if either one had not gotten a big bonus and in Polanco's case a big contract, both would be gone or almost gone. So generally how does a team decide that a star prospect is a washout and in the Pirates' case will that prospect always play rather than moving on and eating salary?

Jason Mackey: I don't think there's a hard-and-fast rule here. Obviously contract is one thing, but not the only input. Also, how much is left untapped? Has it come close to coming out? What's the character like? I think if neither Bell nor Polanco had shown signs they were no longer financially invested -- meaning not re-signing them would be, essentially, free -- then they'd cut ties. That's not this. They have shown signs, and the Pirates are on the hook to pay Polanco, at least for another year.

Advertise with us

The Eman: You mentioned recently one of your regrets was not being around for baseball in the 50’s and 60’s. The best sports story were close pennant races with an 8 team National and American leagues. As a lifetime Pittsburgher, my greatest sports thrill was the 1960 World Series - as a younger dude, what’s yours?

Jason Mackey: Probably the 2013 NL Wild Card game. Have just, honestly, never seen anything like that. Close second would be watching Game 7 of the 2009 Stanley Cup final with my dad and stepmom at a Glory Days in Centreville, Va.

Patricia: Hi, Jason--any new word on Oneil Cruz's legal situation? I know he's currently playing in the Dominican fall league (and doing well).

Jason Mackey: Not a ton, honestly. Pirates have no evidence of alcohol being involved. We're awaiting trial. Here's some background that I gave in this space last week: He will have a hearing, and to my knowledge, we don't know when that is. It might be quick, too. It's weird. When that first broke, a press release came out from the Dominican government saying alcohol was involved. However, there was no subsequent documentation of a breathalyzer, nothing mentioned when he was arraigned, and the Attorney General's office basically backpedaled on the whole thing. It's a heck of an accusation to make from a government entity without any sort of proof or substantiation. But anyway, yeah, he's playing winter ball. And seems like, unless something magical as it relates to alcohol suddenly pops up, Cruz should be in spring training 2021.

Jason: Baseball America reported the draft should be between 20 and 30 rounds:

Advertise with us

Jason: https://www.baseballamerica.com/stories/sources-2021-mlb-draft-to-be-h...

Jason Mackey: Thanks, Jason. They're the best with this stuff. Actually just subscribed (print + digital) and could not be happier. They do a great job.

Scott: He needed 34, and was only active for 13 before hitting the IL.

Jason Mackey: Need a little more time and don't wanna hold up the train. Shoot me an email at jmackey@post-gazette.com. We'll go over it together.

Cole T: Jason, do you ever envision me hitting enough to be an every day player? The accumulating evidence would seem to say unlikely.

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: Fair, fair, Cole, but don't lose faith. I actually think you will be able to do that. I don't see you as a 30-homer guy, but I do think you can be an every-day player. I think we might see that in 2021, provided you get the right opportunity.

Josh B: Jason, it’s time to pull the plug on my defense, no? Sad to say, but it’s just not going to happen. But I could give ILB a shot with that other team in town....

Jason Mackey: The tough thing with Bell is, yeah, the defense has been an issue, but so has his offense while DH'ing. I think I'd rather live with the defensive limitations and hopefully have him produce at the plate.

Eastside: Jason, What was the Pirates payroll the last three years? Has it tracked downward from 2018 to 2020? Is it because they are trying to make up for still having to pay Hurdle and Huntington?

Jason Mackey: They were supposed to be at around $54.3 million before COVID. In 2019, they were around $54.6 million, way down from $87.9 million. So, yes, a definitive downward trend. And, no, it's not because they're having to account for those contracts, although they are. It's more because of where they're at. I think they're trying to build from the ground up and view one or two free agents as pieces that aren't necessarily going to move the needle enough to get them into the playoffs or something like that.

Neal H: Hey Jason, hope all is well in the ‘burgh. Just wanted to remind your chatters that yours truly drafted that Mason kid. That’s all I had to say. Thanks.

Jason Mackey: You also drafted Walker Buehler, Neal. You did a lot of good things. But I don't think anyone who watched the Pirates coming out of 2015 could argue that a change at the top wasn't needed. But, yeah, I don't think you get enough credit for what you did before that.

Drew VonScio: You mentioned that the Pirates might trade Joe Musgrove this offseason. How do you see the other spots in the rotation being split up? Taillon and Keller are guarantees, but then you also have Williams, Brault, Brubaker, Kuhl, Ponce, and possibly free agents that could be signed.

Jason Mackey: Yeah, I wrote today that I think they might entertain going with more than five because of year-over-year innings jumps. I think you'll see Brault, Brubaker and Kuhl in there. They're sign 1-2. Ponce maybe later in the year, after he shows something in the minors. Might be a stretch to have him in the opening day rotation. Not sure I see them giving a spot to Williams based on how things have gone.

Feature man: I know ownership has a say in this, but I can’t help but notice the pirates may be building something special here very similar to what the Cubs did. Putting guys in the right position to better the franchise all around. The farm system seems to be getting better and better. So tell me, do you think fans should be buying into this future and really trust this management team?

Jason Mackey: I would do both if I was a fan. I would look at Cherington and what he's done and say, "Cool, OK. I'll follow some." Pay attention to the prospects. See how they develop. Watch it come together. If you feel compelled, spend money. I do think in a couple years they could be pretty good. I also think in a couple years, when necessary, they'll spend. And if Nutting doesn't support that, by all means, lose your minds. I get that. I also get being mad now. But ownership's spending habits aren't Ben's fault. He's made a bunch of pretty smart moves and hires since he's arrived here. We also knew this would take time. This is that process taking time.

Eastside: Jason, is there any chance the Pirates can move into the NLEast? I'd like to see the old Pirates-Mets matchups more, Pirates-Phillies, Pirates-Nats to follow up on the Baltimore rivalry. The teams they play in the NL Central are, excuse me, kind of boring, Milwaukee, Chicago, etc. and pretty distant geographically speaking. Thanks

Jason Mackey: I would love that, personally. Those are some of my favorite cities, aside from Miami. But I don't get the sense that anything on that front is imminent, no.

Kumar: Jason, could you see me in the 2022 rotation?

Jason Mackey: A little too soon, I think. Maybe 2023.

nivek morris: You have again stated, "I do think that Bob Nutting will spend when it's time." Can you explain the reasoning behind this belief, as it flies in the face of his history?

Jason Mackey: It comes from Cherington saying it. It comes from the idea that I don't think Cherington or Travis Williams -- who've been places where they've spent and had really good business models -- would suddenly gamble with their professional futures by coming here if they didn't truly believe Nutting would spend. Also, they're not idiots. Can we agree on that? I think they know a plan to do something legit versus BS. Lastly, I've talked with Bob -- one-on-one at PiratesFest -- about his desire to do things differently next time around, how he wasn't happy with what happened post-2013-15, how he blamed himself and how they learned how to better build on all of that stuff. But they do think -- and they might not be wrong -- that involves starting again at square one.

Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That's gonna do it for this week. Have a conference call coming up at 1:30. Thanks so much for stopping by. Look forward to doing this again soon!