We could spend hours bemoaning the many things the coronavirus has taken from us. There’s sanity, safety and the ability to go out to dinner. For those with young kids, daytime quiet has disappeared, driving up evening wine consumption. There are no more live sports, and even American icon John Prine is gone.
Another thing you can add to that list is a large chunk of the MLB draft, as the plan is likely to reduce it to five rounds in 2020, though it could include as many as 10. Thanks again, COVID-19.
The MLB draft has always been the largest in U.S. sports. Started in June 1965, for a long time it went until teams stopped selecting, the craziest example coming in 1996 when the draft lasted 100 rounds. (The Yankees were the last team standing.)
The draft was reduced to 50 rounds in 1998 and 40 in 2012.
Losing the later rounds of the draft stinks, though it’s tough to argue against what MLB and the MLB Players Association agreed to do. COVID-19 shortened or canceled high school and college seasons. It pulled scouts off the road. It made the entire process extremely difficult.
Still, a shortened draft means no late-round gems, which is what sent me down this rabbit hole in the first place, curious about the best sleeper picks in Pirates history.
Read More
It seemed logical to separate the Pirates’ own late-round selections from those of others. I also included at the bottom a look at how the Pirates’ group fares when it comes to late-round drafting.
Disclaimer I: We’re focusing here only on players who were drafted (not signed as free agents) between 1965 and now. So, please don’t blast me for excluding Roberto Clemente or Willie Stargell.
Also, we’re defining sleeper picks as anybody who was selected in the 11th round or later, matching the best-case scenario for 2020.
Pirates division
OF Dave Parker, 1970 (14th round, 332nd overall) — Drafted out of Cincinnati’s Courter Tech High, “The Cobra” made this an easy pick, producing an fWAR of 41.1 over 2,466 MLB games, 1,301 of them coming for the Pirates. Seven-time All-Star. Two-time National League batting champ. The 1978 NL MVP. Two-time World Series winner. Should-be Hall of Famer. No brainer.
P Zach Duke, 2001 (20-594) — Can you believe Zach Duke will turn 37 on April 19 and will have pitched for nine MLB teams? The one-time Pirates ace was an All-Star in 2009, though his 16 losses led the NL. Accumulated an fWAR of 12.2 during his time with the Pirates. Converted to a bullpen role in 2011 and has stuck around because of it.
OF Nate McLouth, 2000 (25-749) — Another high school pick, McLouth was committed to Michigan but signed with the Pirates for $500,000. Produced an fWAR of 6.8 over 515 games in Pittsburgh. Was an All-Star in 2008 after hitting .276 with 26 home runs, 94 RBIs, 23 stolen bases, 113 runs and an NL-best 46 doubles.
P Bob Moose, 1965 (18-348) — A sad story given Moose’s death in an auto accident at age 29, but the Pirates drafted the Export native at age 17 out of Franklin Area (now Franklin Regional). Went 14-3 in 1969 with a 2.91 ERA and no-hit the Mets on Sept. 20 of that season. Accumulated 21.5 fWAR from 1967-76.
P John Smiley, 1983 (12-300) — Won 20 games in 1991 and finished third in voting for the NL Cy Young Award. A two-time All-Star, Smiley’s Pittsburgh tenure came to an abrupt end when he was traded to the Twins in March 1992 for Denny Neagle and Midre Cummings.
P Bruce Kison, 1968 (14-309) — Bouncing between starting and relieving, Kison produced a 14.4 fWAR during his nine-year run with the Pirates, which included a pair of World Series titles. His 6⅓ innings of scoreless relief in Game 4 of the 1971 World Series turned the tide.
P Ian Snell, 2000 (26-779) — Snell showed so much promise. Looked like the little man with the big arm would defy skeptics, especially after a 2006 where he went 14-11 with a 4.74 ERA (good for the Pirates back then). Snell later battled depression and bounced around on a couple different teams.
P Randy Tomlin, 1988 (18-460) — The only college player on this list, the Pirates grabbed Tomlin out of Liberty University. He’d pitch from 1990-94, accounting for 8.8 fWAR. Tomlin went 14-9 with a 3.41 ERA in 1992, but he’s probably best known for his playoff start the year before, when he allowed two earned runs over six innings in Game 4 of the NLCS against the Braves (a 3-2 Pirates win).
Non-Pirates division
OF Brian Giles, 1989 (18-460, Indians) — What a player Giles was for the Pirates. Clobbered 35-plus home runs in four consecutive seasons, hitting .300 or better in three of those. Two-time All-Star after he was acquired from the Indians for Ricardo Rincon. Became the first Pirate ever to hit .300 with 30-plus home runs and 100 or more RBIs in back-to-back seasons.
OF Jason Bay, 2000 (22-645, Expos) — Moving from one to the other, Giles was traded to the Padres on Aug. 26, 2003 for Bay, Oliver Perez and Corey Stewart. Bay, who was drafted out of Gonzaga University, won the NL Rookie of the Year Award in 2004, when he hit .282 in 120 games with 26 home runs and 82 RBIs. Had a monster May 2006 with 12 homers and 35 RBIs. Three-time All-Star was shipped to Boston on July 31, 2008. Bay would hit 36 home runs for the Sox in 2009, then a combined 37 over the next four seasons.
INF Johnny Ray, 1979 (12-294, Astros) — Probably easy to overlook but accounted for 19.1 fWAR during his Pirates tenure. Was named the 1982 Rookie of the Year by The Sporting News and would lead the league in doubles the next two years. Hit .312 in 1984, finishing fifth in the batting race.
INF Freddy Sanchez, 2002 (11-332, Red Sox) — Three-time All-Star is best known for winning the NL batting title in 2006, with his .344 average, the first for the Pirates since Bill Madlock (.323) in 1983. Also led the NL in doubles that year with 53. Sanchez would hit .304 with 11 home runs and 81 RBIs in 2007. Was traded to the Giants on July 29, 2009.
P Doug Drabek, 1983 (11-279, White Sox) — The pitcher most identified with the Pirates’ success in the early 1990s, Drabek accounted for an fWAR of 20.4 and won the NL Cy Young Award in 1990, going 22-6 with a 2.76 ERA and leading the league in wins. Went 92-62 in six years with the Pirates, pitching to a 3.02 ERA with 36 complete games.
OF Mike Easler, 1969 (14-314, Astros) — After functioning as mostly a bench player from 1973-79, Easler exploded in 1980, hitting .338 with 21 home runs and 74 RBIs. Would become an All-Star the next season and hit .307 in 1983 before the Pirates traded him to Boston.
Current Pirates division
OF Jarrod Dyson, 2006 (50-1,475, Royals) — Perhaps the most hilarious, late-round pick on this list, as the round no longer exists. Dyson has stolen 30 or more bases five times and hit a career-high seven homers last season.
P Derek Holland, 2006 (25-748, Rangers) — The Pirates will be Holland’s fifth team, as he earned the No. 5 starter job after a combination of Steven Brault’s injury and a strong performance during spring training. Played at Wallace State Community College in the National Junior College Athletic Association.
P Keone Kela, 2012 (12-396, Rangers) — Played center field and pitched at Everett Community College for a year before the Rangers grabbed him. Became their closer in 2018 and had 24 saves. Poised to reprise those duties with the Pirates in 2020, assuming the season starts.
P Steven Brault, 2013 (11-339, Orioles) — Regis University product has toggled between starting and relieving and enjoyed a strong 2019 season — one of the Pirates’ few bright spots. Also a talented all-around athlete who has shown the ability to hit (and sing).
INF JT Riddle (13-382, Marlins) — Played college ball at Kentucky. Worked his way through the minors and made his MLB debut in April 2017. Signed by the Pirates in January for depth and had an excellent spring, nailing down a bench role. Not a terribly dangerous hitter but sound defensively.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.