Perhaps this is one reason why the Pirates have taken combatting the coronavirus so seriously.
A conference call with owners Friday afternoon finalized an agreement between Major League Baseball and the MLB Players Association, and, well, things could definitely be better for the Pirates and similar small-market clubs.
While players are happy they’ll still accrue service time in the event the 2020 season is shortened or canceled, MLB will cut the draft down to five rounds and move it back a month, delay the international signing period potentially until January 2021 and limit how much teams can pay undrafted players — $20,000, down from $125,000 before.
But for the Pirates, the most dastardly effect of this new deal might come if there’s no 2020 season at all. In that case, players would accrue service time equal to what they received in 2019, meaning a variety of different things. Before we get into that, though, just look at the conditions for whether or not MLB will return to action in 2020.
According to ESPN’s Jeff Passan, the following conditions must be met in order to play games:
• There are no bans on mass gatherings that limit the ability to play in front of fans.
Read More
• There are no travel restrictions.
• Medical experts determine games will not pose a risk to the health of teams and fans.
Passan added that, for that first point, MLB could explore playing at neutral sites as well as "the feasibility in empty stadiums,” which sounds like another way of saying maybe they’d reconsider if it was a short-term thing.
Anybody else not terribly encouraged by that amount of qualifiers? Cross that with the continued spread of COVID-19, and a canceled 2020 season starts to look more and more likely, no? Which, again, would likely be very bad for the Pirates.
Why, you ask?
One piece involves the fact that Bryan Reynolds and Kevin Newman will accrue service time — counting toward arbitration and free agency, allowing them to reach both milestones sooner — without taking a single swing. Not playing baseball in 2020 will obviously stunt their development while simultaneously robbing the Pirates of prime (read: cheap) earning years for both.
It would be a similar sand-through-the-hourglass sort of thing for Josh Bell, who would then enter his second of three arbitration years and move one step closer to potentially leaving Pittsburgh for a big payday elsewhere.
A third casualty would be Keone Kela, the Pirates’ closer. In a normal season, assuming Kela enjoyed a strong first half, it would make all the sense in the world to trade him. Now, under this possible scenario, the Pirates would lose Kela, as he could accrue enough service time to become a free agent.
The same would be true for Jarrod Dyson and Derek Holland, who would’ve been working on one-year deals, although Kela almost assuredly would’ve commanded better return.
There are even smaller ripple effects, too. Nick Burdi has been solid this spring, routinely touching triple digits, but injuries have limited the right-hander to just 10 major league innings throughout his career.
Nevertheless, Burdi would accrue the necessary service time to become eligible for arbitration after this season, forcing the Pirates into a difficult financial decision.
Do they bet on the guy’s potential even though he’s never been healthy? Or do they cut bait, let Burdi walk and risk watching him dominate somewhere else?
A canceled season mixed with this newly approved deal would also force the Pirates to rethink their approach with Chris Archer, who’s slated to be their highest-paid player this season at $9 million.
Archer’s buyout last season was $1.75 million. The Pirates instead chose to pick up his option, although it’s a different decision next offseason; the 2021 option on Archer goes up to $11 million, while the buyout drops to $250,000, furthering the likelihood the Pirates could simply move on.
Like Kela, the best-case scenario here would’ve been for the Pirates to get a strong first half out of Archer, then think about flipping him for prospects at the deadline.
But even if they do play the 2020 season, the deal that has trickled out over the past day or so does zero favors to the Pirates, a team desperately in need of upping its talent quotient and one that, because of financial constraints, needs to do that through the draft and the international signing period.
The five-round draft features limited/adjusted compensation for those who are picked — $100,000 in 2020, followed by half the remaining amount in 2021 and 2022. It could also include more rounds, though don’t bet on it.
The current arrangement will undoubtedly make it more difficult for a team like the Pirates to move money around to pay above slot for a pick, and it also could force some good amateur players to stay in school, deceasing the amount of available talent.
How this has shaken out isn’t all bad for the Pirates, however. The financial piece the players received in exchange for service time, which they valued more than anything, could help owner Bob Nutting when it comes to lost revenue.
Owners agreed to a $170 million lump sum advance to players, spread out over the next two months. That money will be paid to four classes of players: those with guaranteed deals, and three levels of players with splits in their contracts between the majors and minors. The sums players receive will be $150,000, $60,000, $30,000 and $15,000.
Because of their payroll, the Pirates are naturally going to have more $15,000-$60,000 players than most teams, although this total should not — and better not — affect the Pirates’ business strategy in any way.
Another hard-to-overlook issue here traces back to international spending.
Over the next two years, teams will be prohibited from trading trade bonus pool allotments in the corresponding international signing periods, taking away something both former general manager Neal Huntington and current GM Ben Cherington have prioritized in moves over the past year.
When the Pirates signed 16-year-old outfielder Solomon Maguire out of Australia in early February, Cherington cited the $250,000 in international pool space they received in the Starling Marte deal as what made the move possible.
Now, like many things here, it’s part of what has suddenly become an uphill battle for the Pirates to fight.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.