BRADENTON, Fla. — Barring something crazy, Pirates manager Derek Shelton should have his eight starting position players pretty much set. Bryan Reynolds, Jarrod Dyson and Gregory Polanco left to right in the outfield. Colin Moran, Kevin Newman, Adam Frazier and Josh Bell around the infield. Jacob Stallings behind the plate.

Again, assuming no one is seriously injured or traded, and Ke’Bryan Hayes doesn’t start suddenly hitting 600-foot homers, it’s fairly standard stuff, at least to start.

Who comprises what will likely wind up as five bench spots is much more interesting, at least for hardcore Pirates fans. Figure that Luke Maile, who was excellent Sunday, has the inside track on becoming Pittsburgh’s backup catcher. The Pirates signed Guillermo Heredia as a fourth outfielder who can hit left-handed pitching.

Beyond that? Let’s take a look.

Advertise with us

The new guy

JT Riddle has looked slick during infield drills, the quickness of his hands noticeable. Signed to an $850,000 major league deal on Jan. 31, Riddle will more than likely earn one of the three remaining spots because of his glove and versatility.

A shortstop by trade, Riddle will soon start working in the outfield, where he played with the Marlins last season.

In 223 career games with Miami, Riddle, 28, has slashed .229/.269/.368, meaning fans probably shouldn’t expect a ton of offense. However, against right-handed pitching, Riddle does have an OPS of .650 — still below average, which is around .700, but not horrendous provided he’s an above-average defender.

"I take pride in my defense and being able to play multiple positions," said Riddle, who collected a pair of hits and had a couple strong at-bats while starting at second base on Sunday. "If I can play shortstop, I feel like I can play anywhere. I’m going to work as hard as I can to get better at that position and do my best there."

Advertise with us

In a pinch

Jose Osuna and Erik Gonzalez are the two to focus on here.

Osuna, 27, has a .719 OPS in 250 career games, with a slash line of .246/.285/.435. He’s played first base, third base, the corner outfield spots and has even pitched. Pretty well, too.

Osuna’s value isn’t so much as a fill-in — although he does offer a late-inning defensive upgrade over Josh Bell at first, provided Bell’s spot in the order won’t come up again — as he is a quality pinch-hitter.

Nobody has more pinch-hit home runs than Osuna (6) since the start of the 2018 season, and last year he slugged .875 in that role.

Advertise with us

“You have to do your job,” Osuna said. “You have to work hard. I’m trying to make the team. I’m trying to be the same guy I’ve been the last couple of years.”

The Cole question

Erik Gonzalez had a horrible start to 2019, broke his collarbone, then caught fire in September, cobbling together an 11-game hitting streak and hitting .322 with a .756 OPS in 20 games, including 16 starts.

While Riddle has been better against righties and Osuna’s splits are fairly even, Gonzalez provides a pretty good depth option against left-handed pitching. The 28-year-old had a batting average of .333 and an OPS of .735 against southpaws in 2019.

Gonzalez has also played everywhere except pitcher and catcher, but the issue becomes what to do with Cole Tucker? The 2014 first-round pick is obviously part of the Pirates’ future but may find himself a victim of circumstance in 2020.

Advertise with us

If the Pirates trade Frazier, that would open up an everyday spot for Tucker — either with him at second base or having Newman sliding over.

But until then, it’s probably not wise to stash a 23-year-old on your bench. It makes more sense to allow Tucker to play every day, as he would with Class AAA Indianapolis, even though it might be a tough pill to swallow for someone who’s close development-wise.

The long shots

A big spring could change the calculus at the corners, though it’s not terribly likely.

Will Craig (first base) and Hayes are certainly close, but it’s hard to imagine them earning a big-league role out of spring training — Craig because of Bell and needing to refine his bat, and Hayes needing to show that he can provide consistent offense.

Advertise with us

It’s far-fetched, but perhaps a crazy good spring by either could accelerate the Pirates’ plans. Just don’t bet on it. It’ll also be interesting to see what happens with Kevin Kramer. He’s hit at Triple-A and would give the Pirates a left-handed bat off the bench, but Kramer also has a career slash line of .152/.222/.165 at the major league level.

The best bet is probably those three starting at Triple-A while the more veteran guys fill out the major league roster for Opening Day.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.