BRADENTON, Fla. — The Pirates have one more day at Pirate City on Friday before the team transitions over to LECOM for the Grapefruit League games that start on Saturday.

Even with manager Derek Shelton and general manager Ben Cherington taking a slow approach on decisions facing the team, we’ve learned quite a bit before the Pirates take on the Minnesota Twins on Saturday.

Certain things were a bit of a given. Barring injury, Josh Bell will play first base. Kevin Newman and Adam Frazier will be at shortstop and second base. Bryan Reynolds will man left field.

If he’s healthy, Gregory Polanco should see a lot of time at right field. The Pirates signed Jarrod Dyson during the first week of camp, and he will see plenty of time in center field.

Advertise with us

Chris Archer, Joe Musgrove, Trevor Williams and Mitch Keller are the likely candidates for the first four spots in the rotation. Shelton said that he expects Keone Kela to close games.

After an offseason that provided a lot of uncertainty, the Pirates are starting to embrace the new normal. But there are still several positions and situations that remain to be determined:

Who’s the fifth starter?

Maybe the Pirates go with incumbent Steven Brault. The lefty showed promise in 2019, and several people around the ballclub are saying he has had a productive camp. If it’s not Brault, then perhaps the Pirates will look to lefty Derek Holland. The veteran hurler struggled last season but has connoted new confidence working with Pirates pitching coach Oscar Marin.

Chad Kuhl will also be in the mix as he returns from Tommy John surgery.

Advertise with us

Who gets the ball to Kela?

The most competitive spots on the team are probably in the bullpen.

“We have some hungry dogs that are ready to eat,” Kela said. “We have a lot of guys with live arms who want to be great. If you get a regular spot in our pen, you will have earned it. Then you gotta fight even harder to keep it.”

There’s a long laundry list of guys battling to be the main setup reliever.

Kyle Crick, Richard Rodriguez, Michael Feliz and Chris Stratton all pitched prominent innings last season and would be the favorites to maintain high-leverage roles. If Nick Burdi is healthy, he’ll grab a spot. Same for Edgar Santana, who is coming off Tommy John surgery.

Advertise with us

This equation could be tough for guys like Geoff Hartlieb and Montana DuRapau, who still have options left. The team could decide to send them down to Class AAA Indianapolis instead of a vet. Also, if Holland or Kuhl don’t win the fifth starter spot, they could move to the bullpen.

Third base

Colin Moran is the incumbent and should win the starting gig. Erik Gonzalez will provide competition, and so will Jose Osuna. But that isn’t the real question. Everyone wants to know how long Moran will hold off the surging Ke’Bryan Hayes. It’s highly unlikely that Hayes will go north with the Pirates no matter what he does in spring.

Hayes is an elite defensive player, and his bat is still coming along. It seems all but inevitable that he’ll be the future at third base at PNC Park.

Stay or go?

Advertise with us

Gonzalez and Osuna can make the team as utility players, since both men can play in several positions (Osuna even pitched a little bit).

Their versatility makes them assets to the Pirates, and the recently signed Guillermo Heredia provides depth in the outfield.

At this point, spots are getting thin.

The last spot or two on the roster brings a philosophical question for the Pirates. People in the organization believe that Cole Tucker is capable of being a star at shortstop. However, Newman hit .308 last season and was solid defensively at that spot. There’s no reason to move him.

If Frazier doesn’t get traded, there’s no incentive to keep him from playing second base. In short, there’s not much room for Tucker, barring injury.

Advertise with us

So, do you put Tucker on the big league roster knowing that he won’t play much? Or do you send him to Indianapolis where he’ll get playing time? Will Tucker be able to accept what might appear to be a demotion?

Jason Martin, Socrates Brito, and Jared Olvia are also working to find a place on the opening day roster in the outfield.

Catcher

Jacob Stallings had solid 2019. He hit .262 and has gained respect for his game prep with pitchers. Stallings kept battling and will likely get the majority of starts behind the plate in 2020.

“He’s a guy that grinds. He works hard and pays attention to what’s important,” Shelton said. “He’s an elite framer and that’s extremely important in how we value catching and how we valued the pitcher/catcher relationship. I think it’s a testament not only as a player as a person.” There are two questions here.

Advertise with us

First, will Shelton carry three catchers? Does he value depth behind the plate more than an extra utility player?

Andrew Susac, John Ryan Murphy, and Luke Maile will fight for the backup roles.

Nubyjas Wilborn: nwilborn@post-gazette.com and Twitter @nwilborn19