Jason Mackey: All right, folks. I’m sitting in the dugout watching Chad Kuhl throw live BP at Pirate City. I can think of no better way to kick off this week’s Pirates chat. Let’s do this.
Dennis: Has any thought been given to moving Bell back to RF and Osuna to first if Polanco falters this season?
Bob from Mt. Lebanon: Bob Nutting spoke to the team this week. It mY recollection he usually follows that with a media session. D Did he do that this year? Did he do that this year? In not, why not?
Jason Mackey: No, they’re not going to move Bell to right field. He’s staying at first base. I think they have a few different routes they can go if Polanco struggles, but it won’t include Bell.
Jason Mackey: Because Nutting has spoken a lot this offseason, they’re pushing it to March. Makes no difference to us, honestly, as long as we get him.
Jeff: Good morning. Are the Bucs interested in signing any more available free agents, or are they done and this is the team for 2020?
Read More
Jason Mackey: I wouldn’t say it’s a hard no, but I would describe the chances of them doing that as unlikely.
Markr: Do the Pirates view Swaggerty as starting CenterfIelder or more of a 4th outfielder? If they dont see him as the future. Is there anybody in the system who could be the future?
Jason Mackey: I think it’s too early to tell, honestly. ... And early from the standpoint of what he’s shown. I think all parties can probably agree we should have seen more out of Swaggerty to this point. But let’s say this new regime gets more out of him. He could be a center fielder, absolutely; he just has to show more than he’s shown.
Markr: Would it be crazy to trade Oneil Cruz now? He would probably bring back a nice return to help in more places
Jason Mackey: For an organization that wants to stockpile young talent? Yeah, it would be crazy. Sorry, not trying to be rude. But I would absolutely not trade someone with that much upside.
NorCal Buc: I’m excited for this season. I look at our 2018 seson, before the injuries and rotten clubhouse of ‘19, and I see a good core group led by Williams, Archer and Musgrave, Bell, Reynolds and Polanco, plus a solid bullpen. Hoe’s this for optimism!
Jason Mackey: There ya go. Hey, it’s not my to tell you either way. If you wanna feel bad about the Pirates, go nuts. But there is a noticeably different vibe down here, and I think we need to take into account how bad things go last season.
Yark: Has the GM mentioned or seem inclined to look at extensions for any of the current players? Kela reynolds musgrove taillion maybe archer and bell? Others?
Jason Mackey: Based on the stuff he’s done thus far -- admittedly not a ton -- I feel like those are down-the-road concerns. Not saying they won’t happen, but I think they need to see how things shake out first, with a variety of things.
David: Looking down the road a bit, but in the wake of the Astros cheating scandal, will that roster be blackballed from the Hall of Fame by voters much in the way that the confirmed or presumed steroid users are currently?
Jason Mackey: That’s an interesting question. I think it depends on what else comes out. Were other teams cheating? Did those guys have Hall of Fame careers? But I would have to imagine that that sort of thing will stick with those guys, provided the scope of the cheating doesn’t change. Will probably be tough to shake, too.

Coach15: Am I crazy, but after watching Buccos from the past & the way they construct their roster, is there any reason I should SERIOUSLY think they can pull off more than 70 wins?
Jason Mackey: I think you can expect more than 70 wins, yeah. The Pirates in the past were woefully behind preparing pitchers and integrating analytics into their pitching program. That much has changed drastically. Things got really bad last year in terms of clubhouse culture and the manager losing the team. Derek Shelton has the exact opposite happening right now. Injuries also wiped out any major league players during the final month, thus making last season even worse. Expecting .500 ball this season isn’t nuts, in my opinion.
Jim: I admire you writers who somehow put a positive spin on this trainwreck! When Nutting throws his scraps out you guys vacuum them up. Irealize its your job but how do you do it?
Jason Mackey: Thank you for equating what I spend an inordinate amount of my life doing to vacuuming scraps. I’m also sure that my wife and kids -- who lose me for about six of eight weeks during this current stretch -- appreciate it, too.
Jason Mackey: I’m trying to be fair, Jim. Trying to get people the benefit of the doubt. I don’t understand making up your mind that something will stink before it even happens.
Bob: Are Spanky and Bill Virdon in spring training?
Jason Mackey: I have not yet seen them.
Jimmie: I have lost my enthusiasm for the Pirates after the Dickerson salary dump last season. Are there any mitigating circumstances in the Dickerson trade?
Jason Mackey: What do you mean by mitigating circumstances?
Mark: Hi Jason. A previous heralded PG sportswriter once said that a new pitching coach will help one guy, hurt one guy, and have minimal affect on the rest. If that’s true, then we’re looking at another 5.00 staff ERA. They traded their most dynamic offensive player (for peanuts) from an already anemic offense. So are the Buccos looking at the wrong end of a 5-2 run differential this season? Thanks.
Jason Mackey: I’m not going to base my assessment of the Pirates’ new pitching plan on “a previous heralded PG sportswriter,” whatever that means. My guess is that pitcher did not cover much in this era, where we’re talking about Rapsodo, Trackman, etc. There’s a lot to know now. And the Pirates didn’t do as much with it as they should, which I’ve had numerous people who would absolutely know tell me.
Jeff: Previously at Pirate city the music would be cranked up during workouts. Fans could not hear ball hitting bat or smacking into glove. Has new managrment stopped this practice and turned the music off?
Jason Mackey: They still play music, but I think it’s a little lower. I happen to like it, honestly.
Too Tall: Thanks for all the great stuff you’ve been sharing with us from Bradenton, Jason. Love your writing.
Jason Mackey: Thanks, Too Tall. Appreciate the positivity.
Zack OWU: Jason what are some of the PNC Park changes that you think fans can expect to see? You mentioned in your article about concessions, entry and exit, merchandise, etc. What do you think we will see changed? Any ideas?
Jason Mackey: I’m not quite sure, to be honest with you. I was curious as well, and Travis did not want to go into much detail. We’ll have to wait and see.
Too Tall: So Colin Moran Has been working on his defense. That’s good. I hope someone points out to him that standing upright and flatfooted at third base as the pitch is delivered is not the best way to make sure you have the range to get shots at the hot corner. I watched him last year and it drove me nuts. Have you ever observed this? Once the games start down there i would be interested to know what you observe about how he readies himself pre-pitch.
Jason Mackey: I will absolutely be watching Colin Moran’s defense. And, yeah, I know what you’re talking about: His footwork needs work. We talked about that last week. He knows it. He needs to get better, too, if he’s going to fend off Ke’Bryan Hayes.
ALB: Do you believe Cole Tucker will be on the major league roster when the season starts?
Jason Mackey: As of now, no. It looks like he’s being cast with the minor league guys. Could change, obviously, but if you’re going to ask me now, I’m saying he’s in Indy.
Curious fan: How involved was Coonelly, really, in the team’s baseball operations? I assumed he just handled the business side of things, but the reports on Travis Williams make it sound like Coonelly was much more involved than I thought
Jason Mackey: He was extremely involved. Some would probably say too involved. He absolutely had input into baseball decisions. I think that was one of the things that hurt the former group, honestly. Nothing against Frank personally, but I think that job is hard to do if you have your hand in that many piles.
Sammy: With so many options (Kela, Feliz*, Kuhl, Rodriguez, Crick, Santana, Stratton*, Burdi**, Holmes*, Neverauskas*, plus NRI’s Holland and Erlin), how does the bullpen shake out? With ‘*’ out of options, and Burdi not able to be sent down to start the season, the team is going to lose someone they like, right?
Jason Mackey: My bullpen, right now, would look like this: Kela, Crick, Santana, Burdi, Rodriguez, Feliz, Stratton and (pick one) Erlin, Holland or Howard. I don’t think it’s terribly complicated. Forget Neverauskas.
Jason Mackey: With Clay Holmes as a possibility, too. Maybe he has a really good spring or someone gets hurt.
David: Do you have any insight into how season ticket sales have fared for the upcoming season as compared to last year?
Jason Mackey: I do not at this point. That is something I would like to get into, though -- how the new regime and what feels like buzz, whether that has been good or bad for business. And, yes, I think there’s a side of this where the Pirates have struggled to keep fan interest because of dumb decisions and bad baseball. Maybe season tickets have gone down. I don’t know. But I will find out.

Danny: Is it just me ad an observer back in pittsburgh or does it seem Cherington, Shelton and everyone on the new staff have created a buzz amongst players and fans that I havent seen in a very long time? Its refreshing to see.
Jason Mackey: They’re doing things different, that’s for sure. Especially Shelton. I can’t convey enough how different players’ demeanors are playing for Shelton versus Hurdle. They love this guy. I’m not saying they’re going to be a 90-win team, but I don’t see them as a dumpster fire right now, either. Things got really bad at the end of the Hurdle Era. It wasn’t solely because the Pirates lacked talent.
Markr: Why not take Wil Myers from the Padres? We should be able to eat the contract and grab some pros from them.
Jason Mackey: I’d pass on that. I don’t see it being worth it or fitting what they’re trying to do.
Danny: Is Chad Kuhl a candiate for the 5th spot in the rotation or is he destined for a bullpen role to try and ease him back and potentially maximizing his anilities?
Jason Mackey: He’s definitely a candidate. That fifth starter job should be between Brault, Kuhl and Holland, with Brault probably the leader at this point based on what he did last season.
JimM: With 2 no 1 draft choices at SS, what is the hesitancy with telling Cruz that quicker route to the big leagues is outfield?
Jason Mackey: Fair point. I think, one, because he really wants to play shortstop, and they’re trying to be fair to him. Two, he hasn’t played poorly enough to where you say you HAVE to change his position. He’s simply been inconsistent.
Wayward: Which players are you most interested in seeing when the games start? At least one each from P and position players please.
Jason Mackey: Colin Moran is interesting; we talked about him earlier. Honestly, all of the pitchers, because I’m a dork. Burdi and Santana because we didn’t see any/much of them last year. ... I’m also interested in how the Pirates field and whether they can play fundamentally sound baseball.
Bill B: How is (did??) Chad Kuhl looking? What role do you think he will have:
Opening Day
July 4
September 1
Jason Mackey: Bill Brink, is this you? So far things have looked good, though it’s extremely early. I would say somewhere between Opening Day and July 4, depending on how well he pitches in spring.
Ryan: Yasiel puig signs with?
Jason Mackey: Not the Pirates.
Ryan: Who stands out as adding a lot of strength since last year
Jason Mackey: Moran has been driving the ball, though again, it’s really early. Adding strength might be tough. I wouldn’t say anyone looks terribly different body-wise. Will show more when we get into games.
Wayward: Which of the coaches have grabbed your attention, either by their personality, player gravitating toward, etc..
Jason Mackey: Don Kelly, one. He’s a future manager, no doubt. Guys love him. He has the right demeanor. But I think we knew that. Tarrik Brock has been a real pleasant surprise. Great personality. Chill dude. Has gained a lot of respect from guys. I think he’s going to be a good one.
Danny: Is Chad Kuhl still a candidate for the 5th starter or is he destined for the bullpen to ease him back and potentially maximize his ability?
Jason Mackey: No, he’s absolutely a candidate. Talked to Chad last week. He said they haven’t told him anything. But he’s gonna get built up with the starters, and they’ll see how things go. He’s looked fine, although it’s early.
Sammy: By all accounts, the data/tech/analytics boost from last season to today has been marked; was it really as bad as it kind of seems with all the new talk of this offseason, or is it simply the new FO that makes it seem that way? Your story on Marin really made it sound like Searage was far behind, as we all kinda knew already.
Jason Mackey: Yes, it’s different. It’s different in volume, how much they rely on it, how much they understand it, you name it. One concrete example: Last season Joe Musgrove would throw his bullpens/side sessions with little to no prep. Would fire 20 or so pitches, make sure everything felt good, then move on. This year, he has a video prep session. Marin picks one thing to drill down on, then he spends the entire session working on that one thing. Then they go over, again, that thing, how it went, etc. Do that enough times, and you’re going to see results. But Joe also told me they basically didn’t understand the equipment they had, and Ray never really explained it to them. Again, when you ask why I think the Pirates can improve, this is an area. Costs no mean. Just takes someone with a modern mind. Think what Rick Eckstein did for the hitters in 2019.
Jeff: When Houston’s cheating scandal came out, the manager and GM were fired immediately. What would a fair punishment be for the players who participated? I think if I were one of those players, I’d be putting on every piece of protective equipment I could find when I go up to bat. It may get ugly (just my 2 cents there).
Jason Mackey: I don’t know about the beanballs. I think players need to move on at some point, and as Jameson Taillon said this morning, what do we think that’s gonna do? It’s going to get old. ... I would suspend all of them for a year. If you were judged to have participated, then you get a year.
xxxxx: Can you explain the obsession from some fans about management using the “rebuild” word? I don’t know about you, but I’ll wait and let this regime’s actions do the talking.
Jason Mackey: I don’t get it, either. Rebuild what? Rebuild says something was up in the first place. They’re not rebuilding from 2015. That ship has sailed. They’re basically building a house on a vacant plot of land. There were 69 wins here before. That’s building, not rebuilding. I think it’s somewhat semantics, but I don’t understand why we’re trying to trade Bell, Archer, Frazier, Kela, etc. without first seeing how this group performs together.
xxxxx: Do you think Cherington could’ve framed his comments the other day about payroll going up eventually a different way? It sounded exactly like something NH would say and is the last thing, even if it’s true, fans want to hear right now.
Jason Mackey: I think Ben was being honest. I like that he was being honest. I’m not going to crush that. Do I think that way of thinking is fair? No, I don’t. I think they should have a larger payroll than they currently do. But I also understand Nutting’s way of looking at this, which is basically for them to get this stuff figured out, then they’re gonna add.
Jason Mackey: Also, I think this group can win more than 69 games as currently constituted. If Cherington and Shelton do that, then Nutting damn well better spend more to support them.
Sammy: Building on Coonelly, after all that came out, it wouldn’t surprise me if he had a big hand in Archer trade; fair or not?
Jason Mackey: It would not surprise me, either. Bob Nutting seemed to refer to the Archer trade as having “an artificial sense of urgency” in this interview I did with him: https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/pirates/2020/01/25/Pirates-Bob-Nut...
Jason Mackey: My take would be that sense was coming from Frank, Neal or both.
John: Can you tell us who they received as the PTBNL in the Dickerson trade?
Jason Mackey: They wound up receiving cash. No player.
Tim: It’s got to be tough on you to be on assignment, away from home, for so long every year. Is this something that writers kind of don’t look forward to doing?
Jason Mackey: It is tough, but I’m incredibly lucky to have this job, believe me. I miss my wife and kids every day. They’re the greatest. And yeah, it’s all hard. We’ve gotten used to this just being dad’s work and how our family functions. Spring training is a little more difficult, but my wife is a saint. I could not do any of this without her.
wvpirate: Its early but who might be the surprise of training camp?
Jason Mackey: Yeah, it’s too early. Ask me that one next week after games have started. At this point I might say Shelton, honestly, for the environment he’s created.
Curious fan: To build off what Markr said, why not trade for someone like Yasmany Tomas? The Diamondbacks would likely trade prospects to dump his salary, and the Pirates have plenty of payroll space
Jason Mackey: I don’t understand why all of a sudden we’re looking at the Pirates as a fertile dumping ground for salary. Didn’t they not spend money, like ... an hour ago?
JBdouble_nickel: Regarding the 26th man, are the Pirates still looking to carry 3 catchers on the roster?
Jason Mackey: Still? I’m not expecting them to carry three catchers, at least not at this point.
Sammy: For Dickerson, that was cash instead of a player, plus the bonus space, correct? So basically a PTBNL turned into considerations?
Jason Mackey: That is correct.
Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That does it for this week. Have to head in for post-practice availability. Thanks, as always, for participating. Let’s do this again next week.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.