General manager Ben Cherington sounded a little like a Rolling Stones song while describing the Pirates’ pursuit of a catcher last week at Major League Baseball’s Winter Meetings.

“I don’t think experience is necessarily the criteria, but we want someone who either has been or shows potential to be a contributor defensively and part of our game-planning and pitching process," Cherington said. "It helps if they can contribute offensively, too, but we can’t get everything we want.”

No, but sometimes you get what you need. And the Pirates absolutely need catching.

The Pirates got the first part of that description taken care of Monday when they signed free agent catcher Luke Maile to a one-year contract for an undetermined amount of money.

Advertise with us

In doing so, the Pirates grabbed someone who might need a little work at the plate but has shown ability on the defensive side and also can handle a pitching staff.

Just last season, according to Baseball Prospectus, Maile was 16th among all MLB catchers in adjusted fielding runs above average. In 2018, Maile was 13th and the year before that he was 25th.

In terms of runners caught stealing, Maile has thrown out 33.7% (28 of 83) over the past two seasons. The Pirates during that time have thrown out 31.3% (65 of 208).

Maile also profiles well when it comes to two former Pirates catchers — Francisco Cervelli and Russell Martin.

Since 2018, according to FanGraphs, Maile has accumulated a mark of 7.0 Defensive Runs Saved (DRS), which is the exact same as Martin. Cervelli accounted for a total of 4.0 Defensive Runs Saved from 2015-19.

Advertise with us

Although Maile hit just .151 in 44 games in 2019, the Pirates clearly like his defense enough to count on him to add catching depth, something they’ve lacked since non-tendering Elias Diaz.

Maile has plenty of familiarity with Cherington and manager Derek Shelton. He has been with the Blue Jays for the past three seasons, the same as the Pirates’ general manager. Maile was in Tampa Bay before that, when Shelton was the Rays’ hitting coach.

It's likely they have a read on his personality and how he would handle Pirates pitchers, who had a 5.18 ERA in 2019.

The best offensive season for Maile came in 2018, when he slashed .248/.333/.366 and posted an OPS of .700. Maile also played a career-high 68 games and was worth 2.1 WAR.

Contract-wise, Maile is arbitration-eligible for the first time this season. He’s a Kentucky native and was drafted by the Boston Red Sox in the 43rd round in 2009, which serves as another link to Cherington.

Advertise with us

The only other catcher on the Pirates’ 40-man roster is Jacob Stallings, who more than likely would be considered the starter over Maile. At minimum, those two would split time.

It’s also possible the Pirates aren’t done and could still add another catcher into the mix.