Neal Huntington was fired as Pirates general manager in large part because his baseball operations department failed to get the most out of the team’s young talent. Owner Bob Nutting hammered that point on the day he let Huntington go.
“Watching the challenges on the field, on and off the field, in the clubhouse, and, frankly, watching some of our players that we have drafted and developed perform so well for other teams, there’s a certain point that our fans became tired. I became tired,” he said Oct. 28. “It was crystal clear that we needed to move in a different direction.”
He’s in good company in feeling that way. Plenty of folks outside the club’s Federal Street offices have made the same argument for years. The 2019 team didn’t simply underperform on the front end of the age curve, though. It also failed to get almost any production on the back end, putting it out of step with those that ended up having the most success.
Data highlighted by Fangraphs’ Tony Wolfe this week show that the Pirates got just 2.19 wins above replacement from players aged 30 and older by June 30 of this season. That mark put them 24th in baseball and miles behind the top five of Houston (25.66), Washington (25.02), New York Yankees (24.97), Los Angeles Dodgers (21.48) and Milwaukee (17.41).
Interestingly, all five of those teams made the playoffs. Two faced off in the World Series. And all 10 playoff participants ranked in the top 14. In many cases, age was beauty, and the Pirates struggled to keep up for two reasons: quantity and quality.
Quantity is mostly a money thing for what should be obvious reasons. Older players usually cost more because they’re more proven commodities, and Huntington for years decried overvaluing the “back of the baseball card.” His roster construction reflected that philosophy.
Read More
Just two position players who appeared in at least 100 games with the Pirates — outfielders Starling Marte and Melky Cabrera — were aged 30 or older. Three more — infielder Jung Ho Kang, catcher Francisco Cervelli and outfielder Corey Dickerson — were signed to significant contracts but failed to reach regular status through some combination of injury and underperformance.
On the pitching side, the numbers were even more stark. Chris Archer was the only regular starter and Francisco Liriano was the only regular reliever aged 30 or older. In a group that small, they all likely would have had to perform like All-Stars to keep up with the leaders. Of course, they did not, which brings us to quality.
Of that group, only Marte at 3.0 was worth more than a single win. Kang, by contrast, chopped nearly a full win off the total. Older bit players including Jake Elmore, JB Shuck, Tyler Lyons and Corban Joseph cost them about another full win combined.
That group plus Cervelli — whom Baseball Reference values at -0.2 WAR in the 34 games he played for the Pirates — actually gave them more negative WAR contributors than positive ones in their age group.
You can certainly blame injuries for a fair amount of that lacking production. Huntington reasonably expected more out of Cervelli — part of 2018’s productive catching duo alongside Elias Diaz — and Dickerson, a 2018 Gold Glover. He didn’t bet on young players as heavily as those numbers suggest. Still, even tacking their 2018 numbers onto the 2019 WAR total doesn’t do much. It would get the Pirates only to 8.2 WAR, which would have put them at 18th in MLB.
Some of that is a natural function of baseball’s economic system. Big name pitching aces such as Max Scherzer and Stephen Strasburg are always going to gravitate toward markets such as Washington because they have the most money to spend. You can’t fault the Pirates for not having premium players like them.
Not everyone fits in that category, though. Consider Howie Kendrick, the 36-year-old postseason hero who put up 2.9 WAR this year playing on a two-year, $7 million contract for the Nationals. Or Kurt Suzuki, the 35-year-old backup catcher who hit the go-ahead homer in Game 7 of the World Series playing on the first year of a two-year, $10 million deal. Or Yasmani Grandal, the catcher who put up 5.2 WAR for the small-market Brewers on a two-year, $32 million contract.
Reasonably priced players like them are available each winter. That’s been especially true as the labor market has cooled over the last couple of years, with clubs including the Pirates showing reluctance to spend on that middle tier of players and opting instead to roll with younger, cheaper players.
The Pirates weren’t exactly burned for that. Rookie infielders Bryan Reynolds and Kevin Newman had breakout seasons in part because there weren’t any old fogies on the roster blocking them. It is, however, hard to look at Wolfe’s numbers and not wonder whether more balance could do the Pirates some good, particularly on the pitching staff, which relied on a lot of minor-league arms to cover a lot of innings, and poorly.
If the bargains are there in another slow market, taking them could probably buy Huntington’s successor some good will — and reward him with some production, too.
Maybe not Nationals-level production. But enough to help the Archer trade for keeping fans down, at least for a minute or two.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.