The Boston Red Sox finished last in three of Ben Cherington’s four seasons as general manager despite an Opening Day payroll that was never lower than fourth in Major League Baseball.

He spent $95 million on Pablo Sandoval, who hit just 14 home runs and produced minus-2.0 WAR before Boston bought him out in July 2017.

There was also the $72.5 million given to Rusney Castillo, making him the highest-paid Cuban defector ever. Castillo has seven home runs in the majors and spent 2019 with Triple-A Pawtucket.

A trade of John Lackey netted Allen Craig and Joe Kelly. Two years prior, in 2012, Cherington let Kevin Youkilis go for Brent Lillibridge and Zach Stewart.

Advertise with us

There were certainly mistakes made during Cherington’s time in Boston, but a closer look revealed more good than bad, especially as it pertains to the Pirates’ needs.

The headliner will be transforming a 69-win team into a World Series winner overnight, but Cherington also helped the Red Sox build a deep farm system through some terrific drafting and development.

If you’re a Pirates fan, you might be turned off by Cherington, some of the big-market mistakes the Red Sox made while he was there and the connection he has to Neal Huntington.

However, a chronological look at Cherington’s tenure actually paints the picture of someone who might be uniquely qualified for the job. And to get there, let’s start at the beginning.

Cherington, 45, took over in October 2011, inheriting a Red Sox team that led the American League East on Sept. 1 and proceeded to blow a nine-game lead over the Rays in a span of just 25 days.

Advertise with us

That collapse happened, at least in part, because of a clubhouse culture that was so bad that it wound up turning the Red Sox into a punchline.

According to a Boston Globe story at the time, pitchers Josh Beckett, Jon Lester and John Lackey would eat fried chicken, drink beer and play video games in the clubhouse while their teammates took the field.

Read on if you think these two things — a sudden, ugly collapse and crazy stories coming out of the clubhouse — sound familiar.

The next season, Cherington started to dig in, trading high-priced stars Carl Crawford, Adrian Gonzalez and Beckett to the Dodgers in a salary dump. Ironically, it was said the move gave Boston financial flexibility. The 2012 Red Sox finished 69-93, the same as the Pirates this past season.

That offseason, Cherington brought in a bunch of veterans who, on short-term deals, changed how the Red Sox handled themselves on and off the field. David Ross, Shane Victorino, Koji Uehara, Mike Napoli, Ryan Dempster, Jonny Gomes and Stephen Drew were part of a group that won 97 games in the regular season and beat the St. Louis Cardinals in six behind a first-year manager in John Farrell.

Advertise with us

Incredible postseasons from David Ortiz and Jacoby Ellsbury obviously helped. Ditto for Cherington’s big in-season move of acquiring pitcher Jake Peavy. But in extremely short order, Cherington took the Red Sox from laughingstock to World Series champs.

Then there are the young guys.

In Toronto, where Cherington has worked as vice president of baseball operations since 2016, the Blue Jays’ farm system went from 19th after the 2016 season to third entering 2019, its ranking dropping only after several prospects graduated to the majors.

A good starting point with the Red Sox would probably be Mookie Betts, a fifth-rounder in 2011. Betts has been worth 42.0 WAR at the major league level since 2014. The Pirates’ WAR leaders during that stretch have combined for just 28.0. Pittsburgh’s last fifth-round pick to play a game at PNC Park was some pitcher named Tyler Glasnow.

Cherington signed a 16-year-old Rafael Devers out of the Dominican Republic; he was worth 5.3 WAR in 2019. Although he’s now with the White Sox, Yoan Moncada was another player the Red Sox grabbed on the international market during Cherington’s tenure. Moncada, who’s still just 24, had a breakout 2019, in which he was worth 2.7 WAR, hit 25 home runs and posted a .915 OPS.

Advertise with us

Andrew Benintendi (8.7 WAR since 2016) was a Cherington first-rounder. Cherington was also part of the group that helped develop Xander Bogaerts, who hit 33 home runs and had 117 RBIs in 2019.

In July 2014, Cherington traded two months of Andrew Miller for Venezuelan left-hander Eduardo Rodriguez, who went 19-6 this past season with a 3.81 ERA and 213 strikeouts.

You should get the point by now.

The track record would tell you that Cherington knows his way around a farm system — Boston had the best in baseball when they forced him out — and the Pirates are in dire need of restocking the cupboard.

The Pirates have also been non-factors when it comes to acquiring elite international talent, and they’ve certainly been fleeced on trades.

Advertise with us

So, while it’s natural to have some questions about Cherington and the fact that he’s never worked in a small market before, it’s also fair to say there’s more to his Red Sox tenure than meets the eye.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.