Few professional sports teams are run as well, top to bottom, as the Penguins. They win. They spend. They do things in the community. People go to their games, buy their merchandise and want to know more about their players and coaches, whether that’s via content produced by the team or external media.

The Pirates find themselves in a bit of a different situation. They’ve had four winning seasons since 1993. The Penguins have missed the playoffs four times during that span. The Pirates involve themselves in the community, but they’ve finished no higher than 25th in attendance over the past three seasons.

Although people do still care about the Pirates, they’re mad. They don’t want to hear about 10,000 simulations. They want owner Bob Nutting to spend more, they want the team to stop bleeding talent, and they want to feel like the Pirates offer a sense of civic pride, not embarrassment.

The good news for Pirates fans is that new president Travis Williams seems to get it.

Advertise with us

“Our fans, at the end of the day, spend their time and money coming to the games,” Williams said on Monday. “More importantly, they spend with their hearts. They care. If they didn’t care, we wouldn’t be seeing what we saw in the media, we wouldn’t see what we saw on social media. That’s important. That shows they care. It shows that they want this to be turned around.

“They want to know that we understand they care. They want to know that we’re going to treat them like family. Those are the important pieces. It’s a page exactly out of what we did at the Penguins. It was very successful.”

So, with that in mind, here are six things the Pirates can learn from the Penguins.

Star power

The Penguins have Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin and Kris Letang. Even Phil Kessel (before he was traded), Jake Guentzel and Matt Murray. They’re really good at acquiring star talent and promoting it, in a league — the NHL — that’s seemingly allergic to such things.

Advertise with us

Guess what: For all the Pirates’ faults, they have this, too. Josh Bell, Kevin Newman and Bryan Reynolds are among the National League’s best at their positions. Chris Archer and Jameson Taillon have been at that level before. Starling Marte, too.

Market these guys. Sell their personalities — no, smack you over the head with them. Give fans a reason to invest, and a tried-and-true route to that stuff is with players who are genuinely likable. These guys are.

A perfect example is the Penguins’ “In the Room” series or the behind-the-scenes content they produce on social media. Of course, you also need to win.

“Winning certainly helps,” Williams said. “I was told that very early on in my pro sports career, and I would be foolish to think otherwise.”

Admit mistakes

Advertise with us

Blast Penguins general manager Jim Rutherford all you want for some of the moves he’s made that haven’t worked out, even leaving the club with five defensemen late in the 2014-15 season because a roster gamble backfired.

But Rutherford, to his credit, has routinely admitted his mistakes, either through his actions or his (sometimes strikingly candid) words. Often times fans just want to hear you own mistakes, not act like things are great when they really aren’t.

It’s also OK, if not flat-out necessary, to reverse course if something doesn’t work. Some credit for the Pirates here, as Nutting will now pay $10 million because his GM/manager combo was failing to produce results.

Give fans a taste

This is similar, but let fans in on the process a little bit. General manager Neal Huntington talked every week, but it was often in complicated terms that would make your head hurt. Other times he’d mention how the Pirates were “technically speaking” still in the playoff race.

Advertise with us

Don’t insult your fans’ intelligence. They’re not dumb.

Take a page out of Rutherford’s book. Describe what you’re doing. Describe why you’re doing it. You could also use the media to work those around baseball or drum up interest among your fans.

“When you tell it the way it is, you don’t forget what your last story was,” Rutherford told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette in June 2018. “I can’t come out and say everything and tell the fans what’s going on totally, but I like to come as close to what we’re doing as I can.”

Go for it

No sane person expects to wake up one day and see Nutting throwing around money like the Cubs or Yankees, or even Penguins co-owner Ron Burkle, but when the Pirates are in the hunt, fans want to see an honest effort made.

Advertise with us

Not selling the farm for a mediocre rental just to say you did it. Also not looking ahead to next season in June or July of the current one.

But when you’re close, identify a key piece, one that’s reasonable, describe to fans (hint: via the media) why you need it, then go out and get it. Rutherford does that all the time with the Penguins. Seems to have worked out OK.

Embrace the process

Nobody is following the Pirates because they think they’re one key move from their first World Series berth since 1979.

They’re following the Pirates because they love baseball. The most optimistic crowd might think the club is close to something. But mostly fans follow the Pirates because it’s what their parents or grandparents did and they want to see a civic institution succeed.

Advertise with us

Here’s the good news with that: You’re inheriting a different grading scale than that of the Penguins, who pretty much consider their season a failure if they don’t win the Stanley Cup.

Williams should want the Pirates to be realistic about where they’re at. He and the team should sell this to fans as a grow-with-us sort of journey and allow them to embrace the process, something that’s already innate to the sport.

Stay out

Williams will not and should not have as much day-to-day input as his predecessor, Frank Coonelly. That’s good because Williams hardly fashions himself as a baseball expert.

A good blueprint for this would be David Morehouse, the president/CEO of the Penguins. Morehouse watched hockey and understands it, but he’s not about to start asking Rutherford nuanced hockey questions or press coach Mike Sullivan on his line combinations.

Advertise with us

Morehouse watches from a distance and focuses more on the entire process and trends.

“David ultimately is responsible both for hockey and business there,” Williams said. “David’s not a hockey guy. I wasn’t a hockey guy. But we went through searches, we went through driving the business and working very closely with the hockey side. At the end of the day, you need to have one person accountable for the entire organization.

“I’m going to bring in great baseball minds. We’re going to build on the great infrastructure that’s already in place, and we’re going to let baseball people make day-to-day baseball decisions. But much like what we did at the Penguins, they’re going to have the benefit of my non-baseball-specific knowledge and more business/professional sports knowledge providing some oversight and some checks and balances.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.