With subpar offensive production out of their catchers, the Pirates would be crazy to not seek out some sort of upgrade there this offseason.

It’s also, as you know, not that simple.

One thing we can safely say about the Pirates is that they’re not going to spend like the Yankees, Dodgers or Red Sox. Or, honestly, anywhere near the league average.

Which is why analyzing the Pirates’ year-to-year spending can actually be an interesting exercise: It may tell you what they’re realistically able to do.

Advertise with us

On Wednesday, projected arbitration salaries for 2020 came out, courtesy of Matt Swartz at MLB Trade Rumors. These aren’t gospel, mind you, but they also tend to be at least somewhat accurate.

The biggest takeaway — aside from Josh Bell’s projected salary coming back at a reasonable $5.9 million — was that these numbers, crossed with the salaries of players no longer here, paint a pretty good picture for the Pirates.

Here’s how:

• The projections award roughly $17,316,500 in raises to 10 players, including Jameson Taillon, who will miss the 2020 season because of Tommy John surgery.

Add to that options the Pirates will likely pick up on Starling Marte and Chris Archer, plus Gregory Polanco’s year-over-year raise, and you get an additional $4,249,998 in salary, for a total increase of $21,566,498.

Advertise with us

• Obviously the remaining players aren’t going to make the same amounts in 2020 as they did in 2019.

To account for that increase, and the possibility of adding to the club, the Pirates should have plenty of money to pull from, because …

• Go back to last season, and Francisco Cervelli, Francisco Liriano, Melky Cabrera, Lonnie Chisenhall and Corey Dickerson began the year making a total of $25.7 million. None of the five figure to be on the 2020 opening day roster, at least not at those aforementioned numbers.

• The Pirates also have the ongoing Felipe Vazquez issue. He made $4.5 million in 2019 and was projected to earn $5.75 million in 2020, although it’s tough to see him collecting that sort of paycheck next season.

So, what do all of those numbers mean?

Advertise with us

If you compare the Pirates’ arbitration projections to the savings the club incurred during various points of 2019 — through trades and the expiration of contracts — they should still have enough to spend to address offseason needs and keep payroll roughly the same.

Whether or not they do that is another story.

The raises

Per the projections, Bell stood to benefit the most. He made $587,000 in 2019 but would receive a raise to $5.9 million, a Pirates-high increase of $5,313,000.

The second-biggest beneficiary is Joe Musgrove, who set career highs across the board and made 31 starts in 2019, pitching to an ERA of 4.44.

Advertise with us

Musgrove could see his salary go from $582,500 in 2019 to $3.4 million in 2020 for an increase of $2,817,500.

Adam Frazier led the Pirates in games played and actually became one of the better second basemen in the National League. He was expected to get $3.2 million, while Trevor Williams was projected to make $3 million in 2020.

Will any of that actually happen?

Potentially, but it is smart to expect some sort of deviation from those numbers, which are usually derived more from traditional statistics than analytics.

Year-to-year player salaries will also increase, although those won’t break the bank.

Advertise with us

One good example there would be Frazier, whose salary the past three seasons has gone from $549,500 (2017) to $571,000 (2018) to $584,000 (2019).

Projecting out

Just for fun, let’s try to dummy out a 26-man roster for opening day:

Starting lineup (8): Kevin Newman, Bryan Reynolds, Marte, Bell, Polanco, Frazier, Colin Moran and Jacob Stallings.

Bench (4): Jose Osuna, Elias Diaz, Pablo Reyes and Erik Gonzalez.

Advertise with us

Starting rotation (6): Archer, Musgrove, Williams, Mitch Keller, Steven Brault and Chad Kuhl.

Bullpen (8): Chris Stratton, Clay Holmes, Nick Burdi, Edgar Santana, Michael Feliz, Richard Rodriguez, Kyle Crick and Keone Kela.

Now, a couple notes:

• No,  I don’t think the Pirates will use a six-man rotation, but I do think Kuhl will make the opening day roster in some capacity. It’s October. So, let’s just go with it. That holds for all of this, actually.

• That group (plus Jameson Taillon) would make $62,369,000 if Newman, Reynolds, Moran, Stallings, Keller, Brault, Osuna, Reyes, Stratton, Holmes, Burdi, Santana, Rodriguez and Crick made the same year-over-year. Obviously they won’t. But if you went completely nuts and said those 14 would account for a collective raise of $5 million — they won’t come anywhere close — you’re still putting your opening day payroll at around $67.4 million.

Advertise with us

That would be a little more than a $5 million decrease from last season (per Spot Trac) and not terribly above the last-in-the-league Rays ($64.2 million) this past season.

Which means, yet again, that the Pirates should have the financial flexibility to do something. And it’ll be fascinating to see how much of something they do.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.