The Pirates finished in a three-way tie for the best batting average in the National League. Bryan Reynolds (.314) and Kevin Newman (.308) became the first pair of rookie teammates to hit .300 or better since Fred Lynn (.331) and Jim Rice (.309) with the 1975 Red Sox. Josh Bell and Starling Marte also enjoyed career-best years.

But the Pirates had their share of issues in other areas, too, with pitching and fielding the two biggest baseball-related problems. Off the field, they endured plenty of turbulence, with talk about needing to change the clubhouse culture becoming a legitimate thing over the past few weeks.

How does Sunday’s firing of Clint Hurdle as manager play into any of that?

The Pirates are hoping Hurdle’s firing becomes a fork in the road for the direction of the franchise, the type of thing that re-centers their collective thinking and steers them back to the postseason.

Advertise with us

“In order to get back on track and get back to being a playoff team, we do need something different,” Chris Archer said. “The past couple years haven’t been great as a whole. And, I mean, I can look myself in the mirror and say that I can be a lot better, too. So this isn’t a personal attack by any means. But a new person at the helm might be able to spark us going back in the right direction.”

Pinning the Pirates’ propensity to play sloppy baseball on their manager can be a tricky thing. He’s not the one swinging. He’s not the one pitching. And surely his instructions do not include throwing to the wrong bases or bungling rundowns.

But the manager should set a standard. He should create expectations and a culture, and his players should believe they’re better with him in charge.

It seems that might have slipped with Hurdle. Not that he suddenly forgot the knowledge that a lifetime in baseball helps one accumulate or that Hurdle suddenly lost his ability to communicate, but it’s that hard-to-quantify thing about human interaction, the reason why some people get along and others don’t.

In simple terms, every coach or manager has a shelf life, and Hurdle, given the Pirates’ struggles over the past four years, apparently reached his.

Advertise with us

“We felt like this was a time to have a new voice, to have new leadership in that clubhouse,” general manager Neal Huntington said.

As he said many times in his press conference explaining the move, Huntington said firing Hurdle wasn’t exclusively about the 62-year-old baseball lifer. The Pirates have fallen short in many areas, the GM’s work included, and it’s time for all of them to, as Archer said, take a look in the mirror.

“There is no one thing that led us to this decision,” Huntington said. “It’s easily summed in a new voice, new leadership, new direction in the clubhouse, but I’m not saying it’s his fault. I’m sitting here wearing it. We are wearing it as an organization, and we’re going to work our tails off to never be in this spot again.”

The voice of Archer here is important. Fans probably get frustrated reading his quotes because the results he’s produced haven’t been worth the price of Tyler Glasnow and Austin Meadows. That’s fair. But Archer is also one of the veteran leaders in the clubhouse. He talks to everyone, solicits opinions, knows what counts and what doesn’t, and he has the ability to properly convey those thoughts.

Pitching well has nothing to do with reading the room, so when Archer talks about a change being necessary, from a players’ standpoint, it’s probably wise to listen.

Advertise with us

“In any line of work, if you’re in one place for too long, some things get repetitive. Some things get redundant,” Archer said. “I think a new voice, a new message, might be welcome, especially with the drama that’s been going on this season.”

What the Pirates endured this season was not all Hurdle’s fault. Amid a losing skid the size of the one the Pirates experienced out of the All-Star break, people are naturally going to get mad.

But it’s also not normal to have so many things happen in such quick succession, for things to fester as long they did or for the culture that’s created to not snuff out lingering issues such as an ongoing feud between Kyle Crick and Felipe Vazquez.

The manager must know that’s happening, and he must do everything within his power to make it stop. For whatever reason, Hurdle was unable to stop the Pirates from stacking distractions on top of distractions.

“The number of players that have come through our system that talked about, ‘This is not what the Pirates do. This is not who we are.’ … I’m not going to sit here and say that it’s Clint Hurdle’s fault,” Huntington said. “It’s all of us in this.”

Advertise with us

“My job is to make everybody else’s job here easier,” Hurdle said shortly before he was fired. “I haven’t done that in some areas.”

Neal Huntington discusses firing of Clint Hurdle

So, where do the Pirates go from here? Not surprisingly, Archer had some ideas on this as well. He praised the job Francisco Liriano and Melky Cabrera did this season as veteran voices in the clubhouse, and he lobbied for the organization to bring in a couple more of those types of guys this offseason.

At the same time, as Archer pointed out, we’re talking about grown men who should not need a babysitter. To get this thing right, they also need to be more accountable.

“One person can’t control everybody,” Archer said. “We’re grown men, and you have to be accountable for a lot of your own actions, too. But yeah, I think a mixture of some established players is going to help as well as the new boys.”

This offseason Huntington will be charged with finding those pieces. He’ll also need to do it while addressing weaknesses at catcher and with the team’s pitching staff, which was ill-equipped for much of the season — issues Hurdle could only do so much to correct.

Advertise with us

The same as it’s incumbent on those playing the game, this should also be a spark to those above Hurdle in terms of acquiring talent and giving the new manager more of a legitimate shot.

“A couple pieces here or there could make a huge difference,” Archer said. “You look at what St. Louis did. Their key addition was Paul Goldschmidt. You see where they’re at. They finished in first place [in the division]. Not much of their team other than that has changed. We’re close. As long as we make the right moves, we’re close.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.