Hello and welcome to your weekly Pirates mailbag. Even with the current winning streak, I thought it would be a good time to address the state of the pitching staff and some pertinent questions there. So, without any further delay ...
Brian Heller (@GolfmanBrian): Have Clint Hurdle and Ray Searage lost their touch on pitching reclamation projects? Chris Archer is not like JA Happ, A.J. Burnett or Francisco Liriano with rediscovering success. Gerrit Cole, Charlie Morton and Tyler Glasnow have seemed to find more success after leaving. Is it time for a change?
Jason Mackey: I’m glad you asked this, Brian. It’s one of my favorite topics involving the Pirates, honestly. And, no, I’m not being sarcastic.
Is Searage to blame for the mess that is the Pirates pitching staff? These guys going elsewhere and flourishing surely must be his fault, right?
My take: I think Ray probably got a little too much credit when things were going well, and I think he’s getting too much blame now that they aren’t. I also think there’s some blame here in the bigger picture, with the Pirates on the whole unable or unwilling to keep up with the trends of the game, although I’m hardly placing that all on him.
First, though, let’s talk about the individual performances you mentioned.
Read More
Feel free to blame the Pirates on Cole, although I think we should temper that some. Cole was plenty young (ages 22-26) and was worth 4.6 WAR in 2015.
Here’s my favorite Cole stat: The latest estimate for how much one WAR is worth is around $10.5 million. Cole was worth 11.3 WAR during his five seasons in Pittsburgh, which would bring that price tag to around $53 million. The total yearly salary the Pirates paid Cole: $5,334,500.
How the Astros are allowing him to pitch is drastically different than what the Pirates did. He’s throwing way more spin, as he should, given the quality of those pitches, while the Pirates wanted too much what worked for them: two-seamers low in the zone, sinkers, etc. Pitches that are not Cole’s strength. The Astros are also the best in the league at what they do.
Cole wasn’t going to stay here, and the Pirates got plenty out of him when he was here.
But Morton? I have tough time blaming any of this on the Pirates. There were injuries, and baseball is hard. It took Morton more time and experience than most to figure some things out.
Glasnow was terrific early this season, but he’s also been a huge question mark. Believe he returns this week. If he rediscovers what he had and repeats it, OK, fine. But I also don’t think it was ever going to work here. Regardless of the sport, sometimes you just need a change of scenery.
The bigger picture here is what really intrigues me. A lot of people want to crush the Pirates over their pitch-to-contact philosophy — or the perception of it.
But it’s kind of a false narrative; the Pirates are averaging 9.02 strikeouts per nine innings. That’s the highest of the Clint Hurdle era, and it ranks 12th in all of baseball.
One issue I think the Pirates do have is their insistence on competing in a strikeout-heavy game right now — which I hate, by the way, but my opinion hardly matters — with guys who aren’t really strikeout pitchers. They’re trying to pound a square peg into a round hole. And for that, I suppose, they should be criticized.
But strikeouts also cost money. If they’re going to compete, it’s going to cost them actual dollars. If Searage was given a bunch of legitimate MLB arms and they still stunk, fine. Fire him. Banish him to Siberia. I don’t care.
Right now, however, you’re relying on Dario Agrazal — no offense, Dario — who probably couldn’t be less of a strikeout pitcher to get outs, when strikeouts across the league are more prevalent than they’ve ever been. That’s not a reclamation project gone sour. That’s a failure to operate within reality.
Also, with Archer, I suppose you could crush them for limiting how he pitched pre-July 12 … although he’s on record saying they did no such thing. He put the pressure on himself to conform.
To me, the Pirates’ pitching problems have more to do with a philosophy that runs counter to how the game is being played today and an insistence or maybe even an arrogance that they don’t need to change.
Shoot, manager Clint Hurdle a couple weeks ago, in one of his postgame press conference, dove (unprompted) into a diatribe about how he likes balls in play and whatnot. That’s great, but the best teams in the league right now don’t.
So while I think Searage will probably be the fall guy for a staff that has an ERA of 5.06 — 26th in baseball, bettered by only Kansas City, Detroit, Colorado and Baltimore — I’m not sure it’s fair.
Remember that the Pirates are allowing 1.50 home runs per nine, easily the worst mark of the Hurdle era (1.14 in 2017). I can’t imagine Searage is coaching that.
It’s a lack of execution by pitchers who haven’t performed well enough while also trying to do something outside of the larger trend in baseball … and trying to do it without the right equipment. Then having it blow up when it doesn’t work.
Searage should receive some of that blame. Just not all of it.
Now that I’m off my soapbox, we’ll move quickly through the rest …
Zack Henry (@zackoff39): Most and least positive things you’ve seen the past couple weeks for next season?
Jason Mackey: Most positive might be Kevin Newman, honestly. Josh Bell and Bryan Reynolds are easy, but the Pirates look to have a bonafide leadoff man for years to come, someone who also, I should note, loves hitting there. Least might be Kyle Crick and his continued struggles. If they’re to deal Felipe Vazquez this summer, which is still something I think they will seriously entertain, then they need Crick to be good. Either as a setup man, if Keone Kela closes, or as a potential closer.
Zach Szklenski (@ZachSzklenski): Do you think the Pirates will pick up a starting pitcher over the offseason to replace one of these guys or roll with Mitch Keller, Steven Brault, Trevor Williams, Agrazal and Archer?
Jason Mackey: I think they will pick up a starting pitcher over the offseason; however, I don’t think it will be to replace one of those guys. I could see a tweener: someone who may earn a rotation spot with an injury or two, or someone they could stash in the bullpen. Exciting stuff, I know.
Also, what happened to Joe Musgrove? Did you move him to the bullpen? I worry about doing that because of his array of pitches, six in all. I think he’s a better pitcher when he’s using them, and that’s impossible to do in the bullpen.
I do think a six-man rotation is an interesting concept, with Keller and Agrazal being young, Archer coming off another injury, plus Williams and Musgrove having experienced a few physical issues. I don’t think it’s likely, but I do think it’s interesting.
Mendy Rudolph (@mendyrudy): Do the Pirates bring back Chris Archer next year?
Jason Mackey: Yes, I think they’re going to pick up his option for next season.
Cindy42 (@CynthiaHinck): Look at these informed and intelligent questions! I just want to know if they will ever bring up Cole Tucker!
Jason Mackey: You will see him in the clubhouse today, Cindy, as part of September call-ups.
Cpawfun (@cpawfan): What’s your projection for the double play combo next season?
Jason Mackey: At this point, I would probably go with the safe choice, Newman and Adam Frazier. However, I’m not terribly confident in that pick.
I think Tucker could easily earn a spot — at short, bumping Newman to second base. Maybe that relegates Frazier to a bench spot. Maybe they look to move him. I don’t know. They could also just keep a heavy rotation, which would not be atypical for the Pirates.
But I think the Pirates need to see something out of Tucker in September for him to force their hand.
Ethan Hullihen (@EthanHullihen): Why do you love the DH so much? You [MLB commissioner Rob] Manfred loving, DH loving, DH lover?
Jason Mackey: I actually hate the DH. I spent my entire college baseball career as a pitcher who thought he could hit. (Last series of my career, they let me catch, and I hit a home run. It was the crowning athletic achievement of my life. I still have the ball, as a matter of fact.)
Seriously, though, I’m fine with pitchers hitting. In today’s game, though, I don’t see it continuing for much longer. Too much of an emphasis on offense, too many super short attention spans.
I’m sorry if I didn’t get to your question this week, folks. There were a lot of good ones. I will do my best to address them in future stories, as well.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.