CINCINNATI — The Pirates spent the better part of Monday night trying to play some reasonable facsimile of baseball, halt a lengthy losing streak and bounce back from what many thought was the low point of their season.
Instead, they did none of the three.
They played sloppy baseball, kept their losing streak alive, and the Pirates actually wound up breaking out the shovels and digging deeper into the (soon-to-be) scorched earth around them, somehow turning bad into worse.
The end result was an embarrassing, 11-6 loss to the Cincinnati Reds at Great American Ball Park, one made possible by the home team’s 10-run second inning, and it extended the Pirates’ losing streak to a season-long nine games.
“It’s hard right now,” manager Clint Hurdle said. “There’s no doubt about it.”
The Pirates (46-60) have now gone 2-15 since the All-Star break, when they were 2½ games out of first place in the National League’s Central Division. They’re 14 games under .500 for the first time since Sept. 29, 2017.
Read More
In that 17-game stretch, the Pirates have led after the fifth inning just three times and have been outscored, 103-60. Their last lead after six came on July 20. The problems have been widespread.
“We’ve been challenged across the board,” Hurdle said.
The look this team had before the break, one of hope and promise and even a little bit of swagger, is now a distant memory, the total opposite from whatever it was that showed up Monday in Cincinnati, the Pirates running into all kinds of issues.
Sloppiness was a big one, but simple logistics threw a curveball at the Pirates on Monday — and they whiffed.
With Jordan Lyles traded to Milwaukee earlier in the day, the Pirates needed a starting pitcher. So Hurdle told Alex McRae around 2:30 p.m. he’d be making his first MLB start.
After an OK first inning, McRae lost pretty much all of his command. At one point he walked in a run and routinely failed to make pitches the Pirates needed him to make.
“The command left him,” Hurdle said. “The balls he did get over the plate were elevated and stayed in the middle.”
Added McRae: “I felt ready. It was just a matter of not executing pitches when I needed to.”
Alex McRae
Scooter Gennett doubled in a run, then Tucker Barnhart made it 2-1 with his single through the right side. Joey Votto had a two-run single and Yasiel Puig walked with the bases loaded before Josh Bell gifted the Reds a run.
With Montana DuRapau on in relief, John VanMeter bounced a ball to the right side. Bell double-clutched and threw wide of home. It had the look of a mental error more than anything. Two batters later, Jose Iglesias hit a grand slam to push the Reds ahead, 10-1.
“We got the ground ball,” Hurdle said. “We didn’t get any outs. … That caused us some challenges as well.”
Perhaps most amazing, every Reds starter scored a run in the inning, the first time the Pirates have allowed 10 or more runs in an inning since April 11, 2010, at Arizona.
In addition to Bell’s error, the Pirates made a few more key mistakes that are indicative of a baseball team struggling to find its way. In the fifth inning, Jose Osuna ran through third-base coach Joey Cora’s stop sign and was thrown out at home.
“You don’t want to make an out there at home plate when you’re that many runs down,” Hurdle said.
The sloppiness kept coming, too.
While warming up before the fifth inning, Elias Diaz nearly took DuRapau’s head off with his throw down to second base. DuRapau saw the ball at the last second and moved. Chris Stratton’s wild pitch gave the Reds an 11th run.
The Pirates did do a few things to feel good about.
Starling Marte homered in the first inning, his 18th of the season. Bryan Reynolds went deep in the fifth inning before the Pirates put together an actual rally in the sixth.
They knocked Reds starter Sonny Gray out of the game and loaded the bases with two outs. This time, Colin Moran came through with a big hit. His home run — the third grand slam of his career — pulled the Pirates to within five at 11-6.
It came off a left-handed pitcher, too, which should be seen as an encouraging sign for a guy who has basically become their everyday third baseman.
“It means a lot,” Moran said. “I’ve always believed I can hit lefties. Just trying to go out there and put up a good at-bat.”
In addition to some late offense, the Pirates got a couple of solid performances out of their bullpen. Stratton, other than the wild pitch, continued to audition for more work with 1⅔ innings and no runs allowed. (The wild pitch allowed DuRapau’s run to score.)
Michael Feliz gave the Pirates a scoreless inning. He has been scored upon just three times since June 14. Richard Rodriguez also tossed a scoreless frame, as he has been scored upon just once in his past 24 games.
But mired in one of their worst funks in years, the Pirates are going to need something bigger than those small slivers of hope to change their fortunes. The problem is that, at least externally, that sort of jumpstart seems miles away.
“It’s baseball,” Reynolds said. “There’s ups and downs. We’re in one of the downs right now. It won’t last forever. It’s just one of those things where you’re going to have to work through some things.”
Colin Moran
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.