Josh Bell

Is it even worth bringing up what the Pirates looked like before the All-Star break? It’s like describing a 300-seat coffee shop where the Beatles once played. Or football without helmets.

The Pirates these days look like a shell of their former selves, the group that teased its fans by winning 12 of 17 before deciding to try the ol’ hidden baseball team trick.

The question that’s probably more appropriate to ask after Thursday afternoon’s 6-3 loss to the St. Louis Cardinals at PNC Park is not whether they’ll trade guys (they will) or when (soon), but how in the world can they stop the bleeding?

“When you’re down and things aren’t going the right way, you have to continue to fight the same way you would as if you were on a winning streak and you were playing really well,” Joe Musgrove said. “One game could be the turning point in a season.

Advertise with us

“We’re going to continue fighting. I don’t think anyone is hanging their heads in here. It doesn’t feel good getting swept at home, but we have a lot of baseball left. We can’t dwell on this. We have to move on and look forward to what’s next.”

Give Musgrove credit for a strong, intelligent answer, and he’s right.

Be mad about the Pirates’ mess if you want. It is exactly that, too, with losses in 11 of 13 out of the break and nearly double-digit games out of first place.

Recommend trading Felipe Vazquez or firing Clint Hurdle, maybe changing up some other personnel, but it’s not like you can make a couple fixes here and call it good. There’s more at play. The games also are going to keep coming, and the Pirates need to figure out a way to win more than two out of every 13.

The first easiest way to start doing that was something Musgrove said, although it sounded like he was making a point to take blame more than anything.

Advertise with us

“Me being the starter, allowing that much damage early in the game and putting us in that big of a hole, it makes it hard for us to stay in games,” Musgrove said.

Musgrove lasted just five innings and gave up six runs, five earned. The Cardinals hit three home runs against him and had 12 in the series. The Pirates have 12 since the Fourth of July.

But Musgrove simply can’t fail to execute a changeup the way he did to Paul Goldschmidt in the fourth inning, with the Cardinals first baseman blasting the ball out of the park. Goldschmidt now has a home run in each of his past five games against the Pirates.

Before Musgrove it was Jordan Lyles failing to execute. Chris Archer allowed four runs the night before that, and Lyles, Trevor Williams and Musgrove allowed a combined 20 runs in their first three starts out of the All-Star break.

The Pirates also have gotten some good outings from guys, but it hasn’t been as consistent as anyone inside the clubhouse would like.

Advertise with us

“I think our pitching has let the games get a little too far out of control,” Musgrove said. “That late surge from our offense could be propelling us into winning games as opposed to trying to catch up, battle and fight and claw back into games.

“We have to clean it up on the pitching side of things and keep ourselves in the game a little longer.”

The Pirates also need to rediscover some of the pop they had before the break, when they averaged 6.6 runs per game during that 12-5 stretch. Over their past 13, the Pirates have averaged just 3.1 per game while pitching to a 5.24 ERA. That’s not going to work.

As a team, the Pirates are averaging fewer than three extra-base hits per game (35 in 13 games) since the All-Star break.

Starling Marte has 7 doubles, 5 home runs and 15 RBIs in that span; Corey Dickerson is hitting .394 (13 for 33); and Colin Moran entered Thursday’s game with an .864 OPS in July. However, the Pirates haven’t gotten enough offense lately from other sources.

Advertise with us

“We’re just trying to hunt the good,” Josh Bell said. “If you focus on the bad, you focus on what’s going on, you end up bad. You end up not where you want to be.

“We’re just trying to ride the wave of Marte and Dickerson. Moran is having an awesome month. If me, [Bryan] Reynolds and [Adam] Frazier get back where we were in the past, I think we’re going to accelerate to the finish. Hopefully it starts [Friday].”

The Pirates never led Thursday, as the Cardinals picked up two first-inning runs. Tommy Edman doubled and scored on a single from Jose Martinez. Paul DeJong’s sacrifice fly gave the Cardinals a 2-0 lead.

Reynolds’ sacrifice fly made it 2-1 in the third before Goldschmidt and Kolten Wong homered in the fifth. Dexter Fowler added a two-run shot in the sixth, and the Pirates picked up two more in the bottom half on Marte’s double and Moran’s groundout.

With less than a week to go before the MLB trade deadline, Musgrove acknowledged that the ship has sailed on adding to this club. He’s simply hoping Pirates management lets this group stay together long enough to solve these current problems.

Advertise with us

“I think we put ourselves in a little bit of a hole here,” Musgrove said. “We’ve made it a little tougher decision for them to add to this team. I think we’ve been hanging in there. We’ve been fighting all year, coming back late in games and making it competitive.

“We have a lot of baseball left. I’ve seen a lot of crazy things happen in this game. Last year we went on an 11-game win streak. We get hot at the right time, other teams fall off, we’re definitely not out of this thing yet.”

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.