Jason Mackey: Hi folks and welcome to my/our weekly Pirates chat. Lots to talk about this week, as the ballclub has bounced back in a big way. Leave your questions. I'll be back at noon at answer them. Thanks, Mackey.
team fan: What is Josh Bell's contract situation and does he stay in PGH longterm?
Jason Mackey: Bell signed to an absurd contract at the moment. Believe $587,000. He has three years of arbitration, meaning he'll definitely make more based on production, then he can become an unrestricted free agent, if he so chooses. Given the Pirates' financial situation, I have a difficult time seeing them keep anyone for the duration of his contract. However, I think they would be smart to sign Bell to something ASAP and be comfortable paying a large chunk of money. Looks at what he's doing. He's worth it, and it ain't gonna get any cheaper.
Guest: Will we see more innings from Chris Stratton after the All Star Break? Could he be a driving force in a potential win streak later this month?
Jason Mackey: I think you might be taking that one a little far, but Stratton did look good during two scoreless innings of relief on Monday. As the bullpen has seemingly settled, I think Stratton is definitely of benefit as a long man -- better than some of the other pieces they've tried to fit until this point.
Guest: Mr Mackey, I have been sober for 15 years and have no interest in reliving my time following the Dead around the country. However, I am wondering 2 things: 1. have you ever listened to their March 26, 1990 show in NY state? It is the best show they ever did if you ask me and I saw a lot of shows.
Read More
Jason Mackey: Congrats on your sobriety. ... I have. Dozin' at the Knick. Love it. I might take the Nassau run over it, but anything March '90 is incredible.
Guest: Is Josh Bell a viable choice to choose to win the HR Derby? I am considering wagering on him but don't want to lose. THanks for any insites you have.
Jason Mackey: I would have to think so. He's been hammering balls, and it looks like he's getting his left-handed power feel back. (These are actually his words; I question whether it ever left.) It would be on my short list, absolutely.
123: Dare I ask it...Can the Buccos make the Playoffs???
Jason Mackey: They're four back in the division. I think being realistic here is smart, but they're certainly in it and can. Credit to them.
sad news from MLB: Jason, terrible news from Anaheim about Tyler Skaggs. Can you say a few comments about Skaggs and his all too brief career? Terrible news.
Jason Mackey: It is terrible news. I have no personal connections. I did talk to Chris Stratton yesterday, who was friends with Skaggs. A lot of guys have been shaken up by it. The only thing I'll add is that it is a sobering dose of perspective, to better appreciate what we have and what's right in front of us because it won't always be there.
Guest: Jason, have you come across any scientologist players while covering baseball or hockey? I know a lot of actors are scientologists, but are baseball and hockey players that religion too?
Jason Mackey: I have not, no.
Fish Monger: How far away is Gonzalez from returning and what moves do you see accompanying his return? Is that the end of Jung Ho Kang?
Jason Mackey: It could be, to take the second part first. However, it doesn't look like it will be soon. So far on his rehab assignment, Gonzalez is 0 for 11 with three strikeouts. I don't think his return is gonna be fast, and he still has much to prove when he does get healthy. Best to just pump the brakes, IMO.
Swinging Bunt: Jason, do you think with Bell emerging at 1B, the Pirates will try to teach Will Craig an OF position? I'd hate for him to become trade bait based on one great first half from Josh (even though I'm happy for him!)
Jason Mackey: They've started tinkering with Craig in the outfield. However, if another team would value him at first, I would have to imagine the Pirates would listen. It's unfortunate, but you see it happen all the time. The spot just isn't open. Other teams see this, too, and I would imagine Neal is fielding offers for Craig. Just a matter of something making sense.
Ralph F: Jason, as you probably already know we lost Don Drysdale on this day in 1993. In your lifetime, is Drysdale the best pure pitcher you'e ever seen? I know that I don't think anyone has matched his stuff and style except maybe Bob Gibson. Thank you.
Jason Mackey: Umm ... in my lifetime I might say Nolan Ryan, honestly. Or maybe Randy Johnson. I loved watching Greg Maddux and would have to throw him into the conversation.
Guest: Jason, which Pirates pitcher would you name as best pitcher so far this season?
Jason Mackey: Hmm ... that's a good one. ... Would probably go Felipe Vazquez, although lately Joe Musgrove has made a bid. Trevor Williams a lot, too. ... But tough not to go Vazquez there.
David M: I've read your chats many times, but have always been to shy to participate. I'm wondering a baseball question and also it is related to the Dead. Did the Dead ever play a concert at a baseball stadium, like Yankee Stadium or Dodger Stadium and if so did they include any baseball related material in those sets? I'm not a huge Dead fan but that would be pretty neat - a long riff on Take Me Out to the Ballgame or Put Me in Coach. Anyway, I enjoy reading your chats and it would be neat to get a published question. Thanks you.
Jason Mackey: The Dead are/is baseball fans, at least marginally. Sang the national anthem before a Giants game, I believe. Have never heard them noodling on baseball tunes, although who knows, maybe they did at some point.
Guest: Any plans for the 4th of July, Mackeey??
Jason Mackey: I usually attend Colony Bash, hosted by 93.7 The Fan's Jim Colony. But we also have a family party, and that's going to take precedence. Probably a local festival or parade in the morning.
Mark Z: Jason great job on the Pirates beat, you’re a welcome addition. Q: is a Polanco/Kang package enough to bring in a quality pitcher in a potential trade?
Jason Mackey: Thanks, Mark. Appreciate that. ... I have a tough time believing it is, honestly. Polanco has potential, but the shoulder issues would probably scare off a large amount of teams. The inconsistency at the plate, too. Kang ... with his off-the-field issues, problems striking out, I can't imagine another team wanting that. If he was gonna hit 40 homers, maybe. But he's not. And he's strikeout-prone.
Jason in Slippery Rock: Should we be concerned that Will Craig may not have a position in the bigs? Also, what is your opinion of Shakedown Street, aka "Disco Dead?"
Jason Mackey: If you're concern is that Josh Bell has blossomed into a superstar then, no, I don't think you should have a concern. That's a Will Craig problem, not a Pirates problem. ... He may be a trade chip, and that's OK. Not a bad thing. ... Not a big Shakedown guy. The best versions are fine, but it's typically not something I gravitate toward.
Guest: Is it true that the Pirates were in the running to get Pujols the season he signed with the Angels? The rumor my barber was telling me is that the Pirates had an offer on the table for $2M less than the Angels and that had they upped it by $3M Pujols was willing to sign in PGH because he respects Clemente so much. If so, can you imagine how that would have changed the culture in PGH? We might have a world series ring. But apparently Nutting was too cheap to bump up the offer. Is this the case? Did he need to buy some extra transition lenses or something?
Jason Mackey: I think you might wanna find a new barber.
D.J. Spin: Caveats about trades backfiring notwithstanding, do you think Keller has enough value to be a centerpiece for Marcus Stroman? I'm sure most fans would hate it, but from my perspective it seems more in line with committing to a window that is rapidly closing after next season, whether or not NH prefers to grant such things as competition windows. The division is more winnable than ever, and Keller might become a top of the rotation guy, but he might just as well be more of a Musgrove or Williams type. That's nothing to just give away, but Stroman gives us another guaranteed anchor now, and allows Lyles or Brault to potentially be a multi-inning weapon from the pen down the stretch, which is perhaps not insignificant given how postseason games tend to be managed.
Jason Mackey: I think it would be insane to punt on Keller at this point, for anyone. The kid has made three big league starts, and he's mostly stunk. So what? We saw flashes of the potential in Cincy. Cutting bait now is like an accelerated Tyler Glasnow thing; what happens when Keller goes somewhere else and dominates? No, I would wait it out, let Mitch work, then try it again later this summer. I think they're doing the right thing by backing off a little.
Guest: A lot of the folks in my bowling league like your writing so I decided to start picking up the Post Gazette once or twice a week to read you. I quit reading it after a delivery dispute with my paper delivery kid last summer. Anyway, I think your writing is ok. I will not subscribe but I will buy an issue here and there at the gas station. So, I guess my question is, has the Pirates bullpen got what it takes to preserve small leads down the stretch? Enough fresh arms?
Jason Mackey: Thanks for the ... words. Or whatever you wanna call that. ... I think the bullpen has shown recently that it's just fine. Have the best ERA in baseball since June 11. They have a terrific closer plus solid setup guys in Crick and Liriano, maybe soon Kela. Holmes is figuring it out. Rodriguez was tremendous in June; looks like he's back. Stratton can be a good long man. Bullpen may actually be taking some pretty decent shape.
Guest: Will the Cardinals series in early august be the defining series for this team if we want to make the postseason?
Jason Mackey: I have a hunch that might be placing too much emphasis on one series.
CowsAreLove: What are we going to do with Stallings when Cervelli comes back as he's out of options? Does he get a phantom injury? Do we immediately trade Cervelli? I can't see the Bucs risking Staliings getting away. I think he would not clear waivers.
Jason Mackey: Yeah, I can't see Stallings clearing waivers at this point. And I don't see how they could bench either Diaz or Stallings for a guy who was hitting under .200 when he was healthy. I think Cervelli may have played his last game as a Pirate.
GSMP: This is a bit far fetched but would the Pirates consider trying Will Craig at catcher? He's obviously blocked at 1B by Josh Bell and the depth at catcher in the organization is thin. I also realize learning to play catcher at this stage of a career would a challenge.
Jason Mackey: Yeah, I think it's a little late for that. I think the best option, if they determine that the outfield is out, is for the Pirates to trade Craig.
Chaz: Predictions for Arch tonight?
Jason Mackey: Goes six. Allows two runs, no homers. Walks three and earns the win.
Ty: I’ve heard Andrew Filaponi say Will Craig is untouchable as a trade piece, but with josh bell signed for 3 more years and will Craig on the doorstep, what do you do with a guy like this? You also have mason Martin who’s having a great year so there may be some leeway in terms of trading one of the two in a deal to bring back a pitcher.
Jason Mackey: I would absolutely be looking to trade Will Craig for a pitcher. If there's nothing there, then I wouldn't force it. But untouchable? Absolutely not.
Hurdled: Maybe this is common knowledge, but why does Hurdle move Moran to second when Frazier gets a night off and Kang plays? Wouldn’t it make more sense to move Kang to second as he’s been a middle infielder most of his life?
Jason Mackey: I don't think they view Kang as a legitimate option to play second. Also, at least this season, it's been way more important to keep Moran's bat in the lineup than it has been for Kang.
KB: How is Kuhl’s Rehab progressing? Will he be ready for spring training?
Jason Mackey: Very well, actually. Caught up with him when he was here. Need to write that but have been buried with too much other stuff. He's on schedule to be ready then, yes.
Dan Mucy: Hi buddy! This team is really screwing up Nutting's "dream" of a fire sale! Come July 31st...does this team "add" by NOT trading its current players? By the way, we've seen hot streaks right before the break before--then collapses AFTER! Thanks! Dan
Jason Mackey: I think they'll wait and see. At this point, yes, I think it would be smart to stand pat. But who knows what the next few weeks could bring.
Chaz: Hey Jason, Rays are def getting more out of the Archer trade, but honest question, would Meadows be a better option over any of our current outfielders currently? He’s fallen off a cliff since his hot start.
Jason Mackey: Yeah, I don't get the uproar with that trade, honestly. I mean, I understand wanting Archer to be better. Archer wants Archer to be better, trust me. ... But Glasnow is hurt, and it's not like they have an outfield need. If anything, they should probably think about moving someone whenever they feel comfortable that Polanco is coming back, probably Melky who has cooled some.
rambler66: Many talk of the need for a salary cap or a minimum base as a must to fix baseball inequities. But we have watched the Pirates trade Austin Meadows & Tyler Glasnow away for a disappointing Chris Archer. The big money teams can afford to buy their way out of a mistake like that. Whatever one may think of Bob Nutting, the Pirates cannot afford to make mistakes like that. So, it seems to me that the only real fix for baseball is to put all teams on an equal footing for revenue by having total revenue sharing like the NFL does. Only then does a minimum salary make sense. Do you have an opinion on this?
Jason Mackey: I think baseball should have a salary cap. And a salary floor. I think that's the first step, and it should be the most important step. I actually loved how hockey structured things. Put that on a larger scale, and I think MLB would be better for it.
Mr. Crabs: Has Moran’s solid first half changed the course for a Ke’Bryan Hayes call up this season?
Jason Mackey: Yeah, I think so. And I would think that Hayes' finger injury changed that, too. Right now I would imagine he's gonna have to wait. No need to rush it at this point.
Mr. Crabs: i Know Bell is a Boris client, and his clients tend to play out their rookie contracts, but any chance the Pirates look to lick him up before his arbitration years start?
Jason Mackey: Would imagine/hope you mean lock him up, because I'm not comfortable commenting on the other stuff. ... Yeah, I would imagine they try. Might be tough, though; with the way this season is going for Bell, there's no way in hell I would sign anything right now. Let the star keep getting brighter.
Bobby: Will Diaz remain the starter when Cervelli returns?
Jason Mackey: If he keeps hitting, yes. Although he has cooled some. Regardless, I think we're still a little bit away from that being a realistic possibility.
Bobby: Any chance the Pirates sell low on Polanco and use rhe money to resign Dickerson?
Jason Mackey: I can't imagine Corey would want to re-sign here. Outfield is too crowded, he'll have other offers that are better for him. ... If they can get something on Polanco, I think it would make sense to try, but I don't know if they can.
Mr. Crabs: Is the Cole trade evening out a bit?
Jason Mackey: A little bit. Moran's emergence has helped. Musgrove is a horse. Cole is a bonafide ace, sure, but I certainly don't think it looks terrible.
SalemPirate: Two hour rain delays shouldn't be waited out. An hour is plenty of time. If the game can't be resumed due to weather either suspend it and finish it later at 7 innings or call it a tie.same with extra innings. If it's tied after 9 play one more inning. If it's still tied, call it a tie.
Jason Mackey: As much as I would like your option, I have no problem with what they did last night. Happens all the time. The downside of playing a sport outside in the summer, one where rain can really cause problems. I like shortened games and ties much less.
D. J. Spin: Sorry Jason, I don't at all mean punt on Keller, but rather more like you have to give to get, with Stroman being maybe the top pitcher available if Boyd isn't traded. We're not going to improve the team by trading guys who fans with recency bias want to see moved (like Polanco).
I do get the conservative approach to waiting things out, especially with all the question marks and ups and downs this year, and it's possible that Keller himself could be the late season boost for a playoff run, a la Walker Buehler with the Dodgers last year.
My "homer" fan ideal trade would be Craig as the centerpiece for Stroman, but I don't think it's quite enough. Maybe squinting, Craig, Cal Mitchell, and a third solid piece, but I think it's probably homerism. Anyways, I am being verbose here, but I guess my main question is if you think Stroman's trade value would demand Keller, or if he might be had for something not as valuable.
Jason Mackey: If you could get Stroman without giving up Mitch Keller, I'd be all for it. My issue would be letting Keller go. It's too early for that.
Mr. Crabs: What would the dodgers have to offer up to get Felipe. I’m starting at Bellinger. Kidding of course. Or am I?
Jason Mackey: Right now, if they keep winning, I agree with you. But if the bottom falls out, I would absolutely consider it. They're obviously not going to get Bellinger, but if they got max return -- while giving up their closer when these guys are fungible and the Pirates are, in this hypothetical scenario, going nowhere -- I would have to at least listen.
Bobby: What pitcher do you think would start in the wild card game if they were to make it
Jason Mackey: Ha. I wanna ask Clint this question just to see his head pop off. At this point, I would imagine Musgrove, but, umm, I think we might be a little far away from that.
Guest: In addition to being ineffective, its seems Archer can't be counted on healthwise (maybe those are related). They can't trade him, so I'm thinking the only thing to do is put him in long relief and hope for the best. They need a reliable starter in that spot, either by trade or perhaps Agrazal. What say you?
Jason Mackey: Absolutely not. You don't take a guy like Archer and make him something he's not. They've done enough of that already. What they need to do with Archer is let him pitch how he wants to pitch. They're starting that with the lack of two-seamers. I feel like they've tried to make him too much of a Pirates Pitcher, and he's gotten away from what made him effective other places.
Mr. Anderson: What are chances they try to trade Dickerson since the won't likely sign with Pirates?
Jason Mackey: Right now, with Dickerson hitting and the Pirates on the upswing, not very good. They might think they can re-sign him, and I hope they do. ... Melky would be a better candidate at this point, honestly.
Chad D: Hi Jason.What is the current status of Jameson Taillon? I am hoping he can avoid surgery. In his place do you see Hurdle continuing with Steven Brault or Dario Agrazal
Jason Mackey: I would imagine Brault takes precedence over Agrazal, first off. Taillon isn't throwing. They're waiting for symptoms to disappear and that hasn't happened. It's getting kind of scary. We're going to get an update from the Pirates' director of sports medicine, Todd Tomczyk, a little later today. Keep an eye out for that.
Wayward: People talk about a "2 year window" when they are proposing a go forward mode. While it is nice to see the Bucs compete to me the more exciting to that a future core is really starting to come together with Bell, Newman, Diaz, Moran, Reynolds, etc... Whats your take?
Jason Mackey: I like both. Why do we have to pick one? The only thing -- again, putting my fan hat on here -- that would make me mad is if they trade a bunch of key pieces. This group has done a heck of a job battling to stay in this thing, and I think the least management can do is let them see if through.
SalemPirate: Taillon potentially out for the rest of this season and possibly even longer would influence Pirate trade plans by how much, if any?
Jason Mackey: I think they should be looking for a starter, although they could manage if Taillon came back. Signing someone wouldn't give them too many, and they shouldn't just assume Taillon is out for the year, if that makes sense. Just need to insulate better against more potential injuries. They haven't done a good enough job of that this season.
Ke'Bryan Mays Hayes: Clay Holmes is good now, which is cool. Any indication of a change in approach that's led to better command?
Jason Mackey: Last night he talked about a lack of nibbling, basically. Attacking hitters more and not being as cautious. I also think confidence has been a factor. Getting comfortable. Believing he belongs. Knowing a bad outing won't screw his career.
Bill: Jason- You've done a great job on the beat, enjoy reading your writing. Re: Holmes and Feliz, both have been solid lately, not out of the question that if these guys figure it out and with their stuff, that they could really change the dynamic of this bullpen.. Agree?
Jason Mackey: Thanks, Bill. I appreciate the kind words. I've enjoyed it. ... Completely agree on the bullpen, and it's not just the guys you mentioned. Several have been better. They have the best bullpen in baseball since June 11. It's actually become a big strength. Richard Rodriguez has been a huge part of that, too.
Kevin?: Have the pirates soured on Kevin Kramer? Or is it just a case of him being blocked. I’d hate for vets like Kang and Gonzalez, who may not be around long, block him when he could be another potential helpful rookie
Jason Mackey: They haven't soured on him, I can tell you that. But he's hitting .268 and has an OPS of .754 this season at Class AAA. Playing behind Newman and Moran, he's going to have to wait his turn, for sure.
Pete: If the pirates are “buyers” at the deadline. Who could you see them making a move for
Jason Mackey: I think that's way down the road, honestly. If they add someone, it will be minor. The biggest addition might just be not subtracting too much.
Guest: Clay Holmes seems to have figured it out. Any chance he could be stretched out to be a starter or is he best suited for relief?
Jason Mackey: I think he's best suited for relief. If he can help them as a long ball/sixth inning guy, that would be huge. They've needed someone to be better there.
SalemPirate: Not long ago there was talk of you doing a second chat. Still possible?
Jason Mackey: We're still thinking about it and what makes the most sense.
PENSFANINBVA: Are the Bucs Interested in anyone???
Jason Mackey: They signed a right-handed pitcher out of the Dominican yesterday, Cristopher Cruz, so I would imagine they're interested in him.
Winslow: What’s with the Marte hate in this city? I know he disappointed a lot of fans with the suspension, but that aside, why isn’t he more appreciated? I feel like people expected him to be the second coming of Cutch, which is a pretty unrealistic expectation
Jason Mackey: Agree there. And I don't sense that sort of frustration. I think people might think Marte makes some sporadic, stupid mistakes, and he does. But the guy's a heck of a ballplayer. If you have Josh Bell, to me, Marte is a great fit at No. 3.
Wayward: Would the bucs trade both Cabrera and Dickerson?
Jason Mackey: I would imagine it would be either or. That would really think their outfield depth.
John: Jason, with the offense clicking on all cylinders, do you see the Pirates adding to the starting rotation to solidify that or was last year's trade of Archer in the back of the mind of NH? In addition, I think its prudent to resign/extend Dickerson.
Jason Mackey: I agree, but I think the Dickerson move might be tough. I think Neal is gonna approach adding the same way he did with Archer: If he can get someone with multiple years of club control, then I think he will consider it. If not, I don't think there's going to be a rental bought.
Andrew Vogel: This is a very good, young team. Even if we don't do much this year, if we keep this core together, do you see a deep playoff run in the next couple years?
Jason Mackey: I see a playoff run, yeah, if they keep everyone together and add around it. That's the shame here for people who are down on the Pirates. This is a really good, young core. If they spend just a little more money, it can be really exciting for the few years. I also understand that's not the first time any of you have heard that.
SalemPirate: FWIW, my opinion of Marte has risen this season. He's not a Hall of Famer but it would be hard to replace him.
Jason Mackey: He definitely doesn't get enough credit for his defense. Turns some balls into circuses, but also gets to many that others would not sniff.
John: Marte is an enigma and has made some bad decisions. I don't see Polanco being the answer as well.
Jason Mackey: I'm still starting Marte as many days as I can.
D. J. Spin: Maybe Cleveland is the right fit for a Kang trade? Cheap contract, Cleveland probably doesn't want to move big pieces, but needs offense so takes a gamble. Probably not worth much more than a B or C prospect, but at least it's something. Osuna's a more well-rounded option off the bench, and Gonzalez can be a backup IF unless Tucker forces the issue of a promotion again.
Jason Mackey: If you were an opposing GM, would you want to inherit those problems for minimal return? No thanks, if I'm making those decisions.
Wayward: Untouchables in the farm system, Keller and Hayes about it?
Jason Mackey: I'm sure there are more, but that's a pretty good starting point.
Rick in Orlando: Worried that when Polanco is healthy, he will take ab's from Dickerson and Reynolds. Can he be sent down to figure out his issues or do the Bucs continue with the 5 outfielder rotation? I say shut he and Cervelli down for the season to get them both totally healthy and then see what you have for next year.
Jason Mackey: My guess would be an outfielder is traded; however, I don't think they're going to rush Polanco. I think they want to drag this out a little and roll with what they have. Maybe he doesn't have a spot to come back to. Depends on how this goes.
Sko: Bob nutting said that they could one day sign a player for 100 million. Would Bell be that person?
Jason Mackey: He better be if Nutting doesn't want to be universally hated by everyone in this city.
Calgon: Purely hypothetical: is there any realistic way Pirates’ fans could bring about a change in ownership? Which areas of revenue benefit the owner the most - attendance, concessions, merchandise, tv ratings...?
Jason Mackey: You could stop watching, going and buying, but even that doesn't ensure a change in ownership. My suggestion would be to support those playing and make it as publicly known as you want to what your feelings are about the situation. But don't punish guys like Josh Bell and Bryan Reynolds. They're good ballplayers, and they're doing everything they can.
Chuck: Watching the various Pirates catchers' faces and body language when Vazquez does his punching bag routine on them after a save, I get the feeling they don't much care for it. Ever hear any scuttlebutt about that?
Jason Mackey: If it means a win, I'm pretty sure Pirates catchers would actually let Vazquez punch them in the face.
Mike: Jason: what are your thoughts on trading Marte for an equally comparable (talent wise) starting pitcher? We have plenty of outfielders even though Marte is the best one defensively.
Jason Mackey: It depends on the guy, but I'm not against it. They need another starter. You have to give to get, and they should be dealing from a strength to address a need.
Mike: Given that team Nutting did not add in the playoff years to strengthen the team, why should we assume they might do so now?
Jason Mackey: You shouldn't. They very well might not. I hope they do. I think they should. But I'm not telling you they're going to add. I don't know that. I have questions, too.
Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That does it. Thanks for participating. This was some fun baseball talk, the most participation we ever got in one of these. Let's do it again soon, OK?






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.