INDIANAPOLIS — These are not happy times for the Pirates. They’ve lost seven straight and sit a season-worst eight games under .500 (30-38), the result of consecutive sweeps on this road trip by the Brewers and Braves.
They’ve won exactly one series in the past month, while their general manager has publicly blamed his own decision-making for their troubles, specifically as it relates to the pitching staff.
So, with roughly six weeks until the MLB trade deadline, where and what are the Pirates? To figure that out, here are five questions they should be asking:
1. How did we get here?
This one could go a variety of directions, but it’s probably best to start with the injured list — because, if this year is any indication, it’s probably where things will end up.
The Pirates have placed an MLB-high 23 players on the IL, 12 of them pitchers.
Read More
Beat writers shouldn’t be doctors, and doctors probably shouldn’t be beat writers, but that many injuries in just 68 games isn’t a small or insignificant number.
A comprehensive review, if it hasn’t already happened, should take place. Maybe everything checks out, and it’s just a bunch of freak things. Fine. But when director of sports medicine Todd Tomczyk needs a teleprompter to give his weekly address, maybe a second look might not be the worst thing in the world.
2. Is anything salvageable at this point?
Do the math, and it doesn’t paint a pretty picture.
In 2018, the worst National League playoff team record-wise was the Colorado Rockies at 91-72 (.558). Can the Pirates get there by the deadline on July 31?
The chances aren’t promising.
The Pirates will have played 108 games by that point, and winning 60 of them would spit out a winning percentage of .556 — close enough.
There are 40 games left before the deadline, meaning the Pirates would have to win 30 of them to reach where the Rockies were at the end of last season.
Good luck with that.
3. Where did things go so wrong with the pitching staff?
Entering Thursday’s games, the Pirates had the worst ERA (7.07) in baseball since May 21, a 24-game stretch of misery where they’ve gone 6-18 to create this mess. The best team in that time period — Tampa Bay — was basically twice as good (3.19).
Pirates pitchers had combined for a minus-2.3 WAR since May 21, worst in MLB. The second worst was Toronto at minus-0.9. Lastly, Pittsburgh was 29th in walks (4.61) and home runs (2.20) per nine innings and had allowed an MLB-worst batting average on balls in play (.338).
The most distressing thing might be the struggles exhibited by Chris Archer (7.61 ERA in last seven starts) and Joe Musgrove, who has allowed five or more earned runs in five of his past nine. With Jordan Lyles hurt (again), they’re the only two members of the opening day rotation left standing.
Bullpen-wise, the Pirates (5.50 ERA) are better than only the Orioles (5.64) and Nationals (6.33) this season, which isn’t exactly a low bar to clear. Since May 21, only the Mets (7.29) have fared worse than the Pirates (6.79).
You could ask how this happened, but general manager Neal Huntington already took care of that; he said he didn’t do enough in the offseason to help the Pirates.
The bigger question is how to fix it.
If the Pirates aren’t going to seek outside help, they’re going to need their starters to give them more than averaging 13 outs per start since May 21. That should theoretically allow relievers to slot back into normal roles and workloads.
4. What if this season is deemed irreparable?
Link this back to No. 2, and it’s an entirely plausible idea.
The Pirates currently have five outfielders for three spots. Three of them — Corey Dickerson, Starling Marte and Melky Cabrera — could be trade candidates. Cabrera and Dickerson will be unrestricted free agents after the season.
Not getting anything for those guys and letting them leave for nothing would be a wasted opportunity to build for the future.
Meanwhile, it stands to reason that Felipe Vazquez would fetch a pretty decent return given his success as the Pirates’ closer.
He’s under club control through 2023, but the Pirates could (logically) determine that having a premier closer is an unnecessary luxury for a team in rebuilding mode.
Again, it goes back to having some serious conversations about who you are, where you can reasonably go and what’s the most prudent thing to do in the meantime.
5. The last question isn’t meant to be a killjoy, but it is worth asking: Was May merely a mirage for Josh Bell?
Sure, Bell hit .390 in May, but he began the day Thursday batting just .231 in June. He has just one home run this month compared to 12 in May.
A few of Bell’s numbers have painted an unflattering picture, too.
His slugging percentage has dipped from .797 to .436 month-to-month. His strikeout rate has spiked, going from 16.3 to 26.1 percent. Meanwhile, Bell’s walk rate has gone from 8.5 percent in May to 13.0 in June, an indication he’s getting pitched to less. In terms of weighted runs created (wRC), which aims to express a player’s total value in runs, Bell had a wRC of 36 in May compared to just six in June. Bell’s making more soft contact (8.3 to 14.3 percent) and less hard contact (55.7 to 46.4).
The numbers can tell us one thing, but here’s the takeaway from all of that: Pitchers aren’t giving Bell much to hit, and some normalcy was bound to set in.
The interesting part will be when the water finds its level.
For Bell and the Pirates.
Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.