Joe Musgrove talks about his ejection from the game in Atlanta

The Pirates want answers.

And maybe a rule change, too.

The morning after Joe Musgrove was ejected in the first inning of an eventual 13-7 loss to the Braves at SunTrust Park, the Pirates placed three separate phone calls to Joe Torre, MLB’s chief baseball officer.

One was from manager Clint Hurdle, who was also ejected. Another came from general manager Neal Huntington, and a third came courtesy of team President Frank Coonelly.

Advertise with us

All three wanted a better explanation for why Musgrove was ejected after an incident that started with Braves third baseman Josh Donaldson walking toward the mound, and they also wanted to voice their displeasure with how things were handled.

“This is not right,” Coonelly told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette on Tuesday. “A man has to be able to defend himself when he’s getting bull-rushed by someone who started a staring contest, didn’t like the fact that the pitcher stared back at him in response to his staring, then tosses aside teammates to get to him.

“You’ve got to be able to defend yourself, and that can’t be deemed as an aggressive act, in my judgment.”

Coonelly said the Pirates had not yet heard back from Torre or anyone in his office. They did, however, take note of umpire Brian Gorman’s comments where he said that Musgrove removing his hat and glove qualified him as an "aggressor."

"After Donaldson was walking to first base, he started popping off," Gorman said Monday night. "The pitcher started barking back at him, he threw his glove down and wanted to fight. We got aggressors of the fight, and they got ejected."

Advertise with us

Donaldson was ejected, along with Hurdle, but the Pirates' primary issue was Musgrove getting tossed. MLB announced a one-game suspension for Donaldson on Tuesday evening and said Donaldson will appeal.

Now, a few of them have explained, there are real win-loss implications with a stressed bullpen, and the pitchers being counted upon to fill those innings will be making less money when they’re inevitably sent to the minor leagues.

For Coonelly, the problem is much bigger than one game or a loss to the Braves. He thinks Major League Baseball needs to take a closer look at these types of incidents and how they're adjudicated.

"Where I come from that, that’s not being the aggressor, that’s properly defending yourself," Coonelly said. "I don’t understand how Brian could have reached the conclusion that Joe — who was clearly being attacked by Donaldson … and this isn’t the first time this type of stuff has gone on with Donaldson — by preparing to defend himself, is deemed an aggressor and is thrown out of the game.

"Obviously this put us in a terrible position, not only for [Monday] night’s game but for the remainder of the series. For the game of baseball, I don’t understand the decision-making. I need to have further explanation from Joe Torre and his team."

Advertise with us

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @JMackeyPG.