Jason Mackey: Hi folks. Welcome to my Pirates chat Volume II. Happy to have you here. We’ll get started at noon. Thanks so much.
Guest: Hi Jason, Since the Phillies need a centerfielder with AMAC’s injury and the Pirates need pitching would the Phillies part with Adonis Medina their 3rd best prospect to acquire Marte or would they feel that is too much?
Jason Mackey: I can’t really speak for how the Phillies feel on things, but here’s what I do know: Even though a prospect would be great to have, and the Pirates certainly need more of them, they very clearly need MLB help. ... If they’re willing to trade Marte -- and they should be, IMO -- they need to do it to get a major league pitcher or two to help out. What they’re doing right now isn’t anywhere near good enough, and there’s little signs of it getting better.
draft: what’s the word on our draft picks so far? think there’s any future stars in the group?
Jason Mackey: I like the Priester kid a lot. ... Some of the others are ... well, I don’t know if I’m going to call them future stars. Pitchers are such a crapshoot. ... I do like Matt Fraizer, the outfielder from Arizona. Seems like there’s a pretty good amount there. Some of the pitchers are undersized or underdeveloped, but again, you just don’t know. It’s so hard to read this stuff in baseball.
RIP: Jason, we lost two good ones last week - Roky Erickson and Leon Redbone. I associate both of those guys with the Dead in the sense that they both heavily influenced Garcia. Any thoughts on how their music impacted Jerry G?
Read More
Jason Mackey: I don’t, I’m sorry.
batting: Is the concern about Josh Bell chasing bad pitches overblown?
Jason Mackey: None. From me, them or Josh. ... I think he was trying to do a little too much. Got an extra off day yesterday. I can see why. Just to try and move past May. It was great, but I think he started to feel like he had to hit a home run every pitch. ... He got to a really good place with his plate discipline, and I think it will be pretty easy for him to get back.
OHIO412FAN: Jason, I am a huge fan of your writing and style. You will he dearly missed on the Penguins beat! Loved every minute of it. Anyways, what do you make of the current Pirates? Why are they struggling? How can they improve to get back on the right track?
Jason Mackey: Thank you for the kind words! To answer your question, not a lot, honestly, outside of seeking some external improvements. I think Mitch Keller needs to make the start Friday. That’s probably a given, but I don’t think that’s the answer. The bullpen is not good. They need to address both their rotation and bullpen and maybe give up an outfielder to do it, but I don’t know if I see that happening.
Guest: I thought Gator had the Pirates chat this week. When is his next one?
Jason Mackey: Gator had it last week. He did the mailbag this week. They alternate: https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/pirates/2019/05/29/Nubyjas-Wilborn...
Guest: Did you give Matt Vensel any advice before he took over your beat?
Jason Mackey: I didn’t sit him down and provide a step-by-step process on what to do, because I don’t think that sort of thing is necessary given he was on the beat for a year, but I did furnish him with every contact I have. ... Throughout the year Matt and I talked plenty. He covered the Vikings in Minnesota and the Ravens in Baltimore. He should be aware of how to handle things.
OHIO412FAN: What kind of direction do you think Neil Huntingon goes heading Into the halfway point and trade deadline? Any possible trade ideas?
Jason Mackey: I would trade an outfielder for a pitcher, but I don’t think that’s the route they’re going to go. Certainly seems like from everything we’ve heard that they’re going to ride it out with the group they have.
OHIO412FAN: Is Mitch Keller not ready yet to play in the big leagues? Outside of pitching, I feel they’ve had plenty of young guys take over starting roles on the team (Brian Reynolds, Cole Tucker). Just how much have injuries affected this team? Can you give injury updates on all who are disabled currently? Thanks.
Jason Mackey: I don’t think you can make that determination from one start, especially one as uneven as he had. What I learned from that start was that I want to see more. I think he was incredibly nervous or anxious during the first inning. It cost him. I wanna see him again without that sort of pressure.
OHIO412FAN: Is it possible Clint Hurdle is on the hot seat? What changes need to be made in order to get this team to be a true contender again?
Jason Mackey: I don’t see it. He’s signed for a couple more years, and I don’t see this franchise being willing to pay two people to manage its team.
OHIO412FAN: Not sure if you feel the same as many Pirates fans/Yinzers feel, but these people feel Bob Nutting doesn’t spend the necessary amount of money to win. He doesn’t invest enough into the roster so it is capable of strength runs and wining with cushioned depth. Pirates, if I’m correct, have one of the lowest payrolls in the league. I’ve always believed being a small market team doesn’t matter. Take a look at the Brewers, Cardinals, Royals 2015, Twins, etc. Thoughts? What can the Pirates do or learn from the around the league?
Jason Mackey: You’re in more-questions-than-my-wife-has-asked-me-today territory ... Yes, I think Bob Nutting can spend more money. I don’t think that’s making a huge leap. But I also don’t think it’s impossible to win on the lower end of the pay curve. Look at what they’ve found in Melky Cabrera and Bryan Reynolds. Elias Diaz has been good. Jordan Lyles. There’s some definite value there. But when you keep trotting out Nick Kingham, I mean, c’mon. That’s not working, and you keep doing it. If you go Keller, I get it. If you get someone, I get it. You know what they say about doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results ...
OHIO412FAN: Which prospects of the Pirates do you feel have the most likely chance besides Keller to be called up?
Jason Mackey: Ke-Bryan Hayes is the next one I’d be watching.
OHIO412FAN: Is it me, or is it Clint Hurdle doesn’t play the absolute best lineup every game? Something I’ve picked up on more and more throughout the years.
Jason Mackey: They believe in a rest-and-recovery process that I think a lot of their fans -- who are more old school -- probably don’t believe in. There is a reason for all the rotation, and it’s similar around baseball these days. Trying to keep guys fresh.
lorddale: Do you think the pirates will try and add some pitching soon or do you think they have given up ? My wife & I are fans & live in IL. we are coming end of Sept for Steve Blass goodbye & to see the Steelers , Id like to think the trip wouldn’t just be for the Steelers !
Jason Mackey: Ha. I see what you’re saying. I think they need to, and they very well might, but I don’t see it being some super-sexy move. Put it this way: I don’t think they’re signing Dallas Keuchel or getting Madison Bumgarner.
GD fan 1991: Love the chats, Jason. You ever heard the DC 1991 Dead show? A classic set and I think in a lot of ways you can hear tones in the second half of the show that reflect what Archer has gone through this season. I don’t always think the Dead’s music relates well to baseball, but something about that set just really strikes a chord with Archer’s 2019 season. Thoughts on that or other favorite Dead sets that related to baseball, specifically Pirates ball?
Jason Mackey: Thank you! No thoughts on linking Grateful Dead setlists to baseball, but I will be sure to check out what you mentioned.
Guest: Is it time for Hurdle to fire Searage? Would Clint even have the courage to do it?
Jason Mackey: I can’t speak on the “courage” angle, but I’m not about to pin this on Searage. It’s not his fault Pirates pitchers consistently miss their spots. They’re also using guys -- without naming names here -- who should be in Class AAA in the major leagues. The fact that they get hit hard and sometimes struggle ... is that really Ray’s fault?
Guest: Why hasn’t Reggie Crawford been drafted this year yet? Great Lefty from right here in PA. Might the bucs draft him?
Jason Mackey: Signability? Not sure. It’s a little tough to figure out reasons for why/why not individual players are drafted or not drafted given the volume of this thing, especially guys who aren’t super local.
Guest: Did you get drafted for baseball out of high school? My cousin was saying you played college ball and thinks you got selected in a late round by the Tigers. Thanks.
Jason Mackey: Haha. Your cousin is very, very wrong. Heck no. ... I played in college (Westminster), but it wasn’t exactly Florida State. Sure as heck wasn’t drafted. Or even close to it.
Dave: Greg Brown mentioned on the broadcast that Rookie Davis would start Friday in Milwaukee, but then he pitched mop up duty in the 9th. What’s the deal – was Brownie mistaken, or might Brault/Kingham’s latest unravellings lead to a more permanent rotation change? Keller is on turn for Friday...
Jason Mackey: I believe Keller is on schedule to start Friday. I would be really surprised if they gave Rookie Davis the start and did not offer Keller another chance, especially after how Davis fared last night.
Guest: Were John W’s comments about that player’s granddad rolling over in his grave overblown or what or not?
Jason Mackey: I’m fine criticizing Derek Dietrich for how he plays the game. I don’t have a problem with it, but I can see why some do. Bringing his dead grandfather into the discussion? I think that’s taking it a little too far.
Guest: Wathching the braves, it struck me - is Matt Joyce’s production gonna have to pick up for the Braves to make the playoffs? Is he the missing piece there?
Jason Mackey: I think the Braves are gonna be just fine with/without Matt Joyce.
Steve S: Jason, likelihood of Marte being traded as opined by Joe Starkey? Actually makes a great deal of sense - lost track of the fact that he is 31. Thanks!
Jason Mackey: I don’t think it’s tremendously likely, but I agree with Joe, in that it’s an option they should be exploring. And if there’s no market for Marte -- there might not be -- I would be open to moving Polanco, Melky or Dickerson ... anyone to get a pitcher or two.
jt: I understand that you are a bit of a baseball historian and having read your chats I know that Jim Thorpe comes up a lot. A lot of folks bag on him cuz he only hit 7 home runs over the course of his roughly 10 year career, but wasn’t 7 kind of a high number for the 1910s? Thanks, Jason. Love the chats!!!
Jason Mackey: Enough with the Jim Thorpe stuff, please. It’s not gonna get pushed through next time; let’s just save everyone’s time here. Thanks.
rcc prof: Some call what Huntington says spinning; I call it lying, much like what a politician does. Huntington talks about how difficult it is to make trades at this time. Yet the Phillies and Braves seem to make trades while the Pirates sink lower and lower. Does the so-called BMTIB really want to win, actually know how to build a winner, or are these geeks simply jerking the baseball fans in Pgh. around?
Jason Mackey: I get what Huntington is saying. You need to look at in context of what he’s allowed to do. You can make trades this time of year, but you need to be OK overpaying a little bit. The Penguins have done it, and it’s OK because they need whatever they’re getting and understand that it may cost a little more. That’s not how the Pirates roll. So, I don’t think Neal is trying to pull a sell job; it’s just reality if you’re in his seat.
ratso: All you need to know about Huntington is that he turned down a chance with a real MLB team in San Francisco to stay with an owner who has no intention of winning--meaning Huntington has no intention of winning and no competitive spirit--he just doesn’t have what it takes to really compete!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Jason Mackey: Do you really think Neal looked in the mirror and said, “Gee, I can win, but losing is soooo much fun! Let’s do that.” ... C’mon.
Guest: Bucs announcers getting a bunch of national grief lately over comments about Dietrich and Acuna. What’s the deal with that?
Jason Mackey: I’m not quite sure. They do seem to be unfairly targeted, although I do think Wehner went a little far on his Dietrich comments.
Mark C.: In your opinion, what would it take for Nutting to open his wallet and start caring about the success of the Pirates?
Jason Mackey: I don’t know if such a thing exists. And I think he cares. He just doesn’t care probably as much as he needs to in the current climate, where you have to spend money because of baseball’s ridiculous salary system. If don’t wanna pay to play, I don’t understand why you wanna own a team. ... Say Mark Cuban somehow buys the Pirates. He’s gonna plunk down the necessary money. Probably Ron Burkle, too. ... Why you own a team -- when there are plenty of other people with a bunch of money who would buy -- but don’t wanna spend what it takes to compete with the best, I don’t don’t get it.
Jim: Why is it that all Pirate writers.announcers and studio hosts fail to attack BOB NUTTING for destroying the Pirates?He is very clearly the cause of this debacle we have. He and the rest of management are complicit in destroying baseball in Pittsburgh! I am tired of the BS! Can anything be done to change this. The Post~Gazette does not even daily publish attendance comparisons anymore. Are you instructed not to?
Jason Mackey: Jim, I think you may need to breathe. ... One, the guys you watch on AT&T SportsNet have a relationship with the team; they have to be positive. ... Which external writers -- meaning the P-G, Trib, Athletic and DK -- are not critical of the team? Gimme a break. We publish attendance every day in the box scores. Do you really need me to write it in the story, too? I don’t because it’s in the box score.
ReJtire21: Jung Ho hitting .400+ in Indy. Is he tradable or will he prompt a trade?
Jason Mackey: I don’t see how anyone else would want that. He might add some infield depth, which is great, but I think if they make a trade it has to involve an outfielder. Jung Ho really doesn’t affect that.
Ed: Joe Starkey brought up trading Marte. I agree. Your thoughts on who would be interested and what we may be able to get? A starting pitcher would definitely be welcome right now.
Jason Mackey: I could see the Phillies being interested, and it makes sense to get a starting pitcher back. ... Anyone who needs an outfielder should at least check. I can see not paying a ton, and maybe that kills a deal. But Marte, at minimum, is a legit major league outfielder who can hit and run ... even if sometimes he struggles to think.
MT Seats: Do the announced attendance figures have anything to do with reality? I see lots of empty seats watching the other teams players run around the bases...
Jason Mackey: None, in my opinion. And also atmosphere -- people actually giving a crap about what’s happening. There wasn’t a ton of that last night, although it was a weeknight game against the Braves.
Jeff: Thanks for the chats! good piece on trading Marte to Philly, any idea who we could get in return? doubt red hot team is willing to disrupt whats working
Jason Mackey: Fair point. And they might just not wanna deal with Marte’s propensity for making mistakes at key times.
DJ Spin: I’m sure there will be lots of questions about trades, but the Blue Jays seem willing to sell and could be a match for trading pitching for some upper level prospects. Could there be a match here, and would Huntington risk being even more aggressive than last year after the Archer trade has backfired so badly?
A blockbuster of Stroman + an RP (Biagini?) would be a dream for Pirates fans, but how steep do you think the cost would be? Could Craig be the centerpiece, or would we be talking Keller + Craig?
Jason Mackey: I don’t have the first idea what the Blue Jays would be looking for, but I’m starting to sense you guys want a trade, eh? Could see this on Pens. Everybody starts concocting scenarios, about .0001 percent of which actually play out. They need major league arms, not prospects, right now.
GSMP: Two part question. Will the Pirates look to give Josh Bell an extension so that would buyout arbitration years as well as a few free agent years? And would Bell be receptive?
Jason Mackey: I think they will try. If I’m Bell, there’s no way in hell I’m doing it. He should bet on himself, keep trying to produce and make all he can. He’s a Boras guy, too. I’m pretty confident that’s what he’ll do.
Jerry Garcia: Saw the Grateful Dead mention on the twittersphere and now I’m here
Jason Mackey: Hey Jerry. You’re my favorite.
Operation Shutdown: I think we should dangle Newman or the guy with the cool hair. No place for both of them. Concur?
Jason Mackey: Only if you inform other GMs if the guy available is the one “with the cool hair.” Then you see what sort of offers you get. Surely they would be incredible.
Jason in Slippery Rock: Will Mitch Keller be back this year? Also American Beauty or Workingman’s Dead?
Jason Mackey: Yes. And I think soon. ... American Beauty ... but not by much. More to the point: Anything live over any studio albums.
Todd: Two weeks ago I went to the AAA game here in Austin, Texas, which is the Astros’ affiliate. Four guys who played in that game were called up and helped Houston beat the A’s last Sunday. The Astros and its farm team are both loaded, so why were the Pirates fleeced in that Cole trade? Unacceptable to not get a legit bat from Houston and two players from the AAA team. Does Neil know how to negotiate?
Jason Mackey: I think they felt like they had to trade Gerrit and wound up getting ho-hum return. I do like Musgrove a lot, and I think Moran has gotten better. But, yeah, they could have gotten a lot more. I don’t think that’s a referendum on Neal’s negotiation skills, but they could’ve done better, for sure.
PhillyJake: I was listening to an Oakland ‘87 show on Spotify last week or week before!
Jason Mackey: Awesome stuff, eh?
Ty: Is it time we start looking forward to the 2020 season when everyone is *hopefully* healthy? This season with the pitching struggles seems to be a wash and a waste of a great season for Josh Bell so far.
Jason Mackey: I don’t think we’re there yet, honestly. I know things aren’t great, but there’s still plenty of time. My issue is more with how we can reasonably expect things to turn. Like, is Nick Kingham going to suddenly start pitching like a Cy Young Award winner? Probably not. Same goes for a lot of their current arms, and that’s just not gonna lead to good things.
PhillyJake: I never figured Kingham for a top of the rotation guy. But I never pegged him of the 8+ ERA extreme either. What’s happening with him? Personally I’d love to see CH make Stallings his personal catcher and see if they can recapture some of what happened last year in Indy?
Jason Mackey: He’s leaving way to many balls up and pitching behind in counts. I don’t care if Johnny Bench was his catcher. He’s going to get blasted. And it’s weird. It’s like he doesn’t want to acknowledge there’s a problem. Until that happens, I don’t know what you do except maybe relegate him to long-relief status while working on control. I would not start him.
Jeff: The Bucs pitching staff has been decimated with injuries, and it shows with the elevated ERA and run differential. Is it best to wait it out, let the pitchers heal, and carry on when they return? Or would it be best to make a trade or two? I hear Marte is becoming a trade candidate. I’d hate to see the Bucs get worse like they did at last year’s trade deadline.
Jason Mackey: I don’t think you can sit around and wait and expect things to change. Past precedent tells us they won’t. I think they need to be active, whether that involves Marte or someone else.
John : Clint Hurdle said in his pregame chat yesterday with joe block that rookie davis would start Friday in Milwaukee
Jason Mackey: Thank you for that. I did not hear that. So, assuming Hurdle still feels that way after last night, we should pump the brakes on Keller.
MF: What’s the chances of Polanco getting traded
Jason Mackey: Not very good, I would imagine. Can’t see the return being much. Doesn’t make sense to sell off an asset at one of its lowest points.
Kramer: I don’t see me mentioned much anymore. Am I still considered the possible second baseman of the future? Turns out that batting title talk for AF was a bit premature...
Jason Mackey: Batting title talk might be a bit much, but I can see Frazier being the everyday 2B. I also think Newman has earned his playing time, and Cole Tucker has been a lot better. It’s an interesting infield rotation right now, especially when you factor in Colin Moran, Newman’s ability to play third and the possibility that Jung Ho Kang comes back soon.
DJ Spin: Sorry Jason, I think I wasn’t clear enough. the Blue Jays are 20 or so games out of first, and reportedly willing to engage on moving Stroman or Sanchez well prior to the deadline to maximize their return. I’m suggesting that Huntington be willing to move his upper level minors prospects in order for the Blue Jays to add them to their core with Vlad Jr., Biggio, etc., not that the Pirates seek to acquire prospects.
I know we fans do dream up scenarios like we’re playing a video game, but this seems like the most promising option right now. The Giants will probably wait until closer to the deadline to move MadBum. Stroman is controllable for another year, ground-ball pitcher, dependable. Paying the cost to get him next week could stop the bleeding. Will Craig’s stock is shooting through the roof but is probably blocked. The Jays could install him at 1B or DH.
Jason Mackey: Ah, OK. That makes a bunch more sense. ... I like the Stroman trade from a baseball perspective. Usually the type of pitcher who thrives here. But I question a couple things. Would he want to be a part of this or maybe go somewhere with a legit shot at winning a World Series? And if they traded prospects -- I still might keep Will Craig -- they’ve be putting salary on the books. Would they do that?
Too Tall: As far as possible call ups, what about Kevin Kramer? He has been hitting well and if Frazier doesn’t find his bat, i’d be inclined to give Kramer a shot. Thoughts?
Jason Mackey: Can he pitch? I don’t see them needing infield help. Or the outfield. They’re fine. They need pitching help.
Chuck: Jason, I read the article about trading Marte and agree that may be the most prudent thing to do but only if the prospects are decent to sign Dickerson. Do you think there is any possibility he would consider signing an extension?
Jason Mackey: Do you mean Marte or Dickerson?
Alan: Knowing what payroll was to start the season, do Pirate fans really believe this organization will make a trade(s) to obtain additional pitching of any relevance? What do they even have to offer of any significance to obtain a talented pitcher? Adding a Joe Beimel or Josh Fogg type player will make no difference. Seems the best course of action is to wait for everyone to get healthy and hope they resume pitching above their pay-grades/talent.
Jason Mackey: I see what you’re saying, Alan, and you make some fine points. The only thing I would worry about is this: Will it be too late by the time everyone gets healthy? Jameson Taillon isn’t throwing. Trevor Williams has plenty of buildup work. Probably at least a couple weeks until he’s back, Taillon more. What sort of damage could be done by then? The season might be lost.
Chad: Any update on JT Brubaker? Also, any chance at all of Dario Agrazial getting a call up soon either to start or even bullpen?
Jason Mackey: We should hear more about him today when Todd Tomczyk talks. ... Can’t say anything specific about Agrazal either way, but given what they’ve had lately in the bullpen -- 48 earned runs allowed over the past 51.1 innings pitches -- why the heck not?
Lee Foo: We need bullpen help? I hear Kimbrel is available, lol. If only.....
Jason Mackey: Can you imagine the Pirates adding him? I can’t.
DJ Spin: I don’t think Stroman has any NTC, and he was vocal about being disappointed with management not offering him an extension. He’s also very close friends with Archer. 7.4 million this year and arbitration next year. Sanchez is cheaper but not as good. Neither breaks the bank even by Pirates standards.
I could see us getting burned with moving Craig, since Bell is only under control for three more years, but you have to give to get, and we have another 1B power prospect breaking out in the lower minors. It just seems like a decent fit all things considered. Between now and the ASB looks like a bloodbath on the schedule, but if we could get Stroman and Williams comes back healthy soon, maybe we survive.
If Taillon returns late-July and everybody is still healthy, then the worst pitcher can go into the bullpen. Maybe even have Keller get MLB bullpen experience later in the season. All things that are very un-Pirates like. But something’s gotta give, 2/5 turns of the rotation are automatic losses right now.
Jason Mackey: You’re absolutely right. I agree with a lot of what you’re saying, although in no way, shape or form would I monkey around with Keller in the bullpen. The kid needs to remain a starter.
PghParty: Jason I think we all know what needs to happen. Put out the spotlight for Batman.. we need AJ Burnett back in black.
Jason Mackey: Ha. That’s gonna be a thing forever, isn’t it? I’m fine with it. I just think it’s funny.
Chuck: I meant Dickerson. I believe he is only under contract through next season. If Marte is dealt, they still have Dickerson, Reynolds, Melky and Polonco. I just have a feeling Dickerson would be reluctant to sign an extension
Jason Mackey: I think that’s way down the road, honestly. You found Melky and Reynolds. You have Polanco and probably can’t do anything else with him. Dickerson isn’t movable. That means, to me, that Marte is the most transferrable asset here. Worry about Dickerson down the road.
Rudy: Are the pirates within 5 games of the wildcard by Sep 1?
Jason Mackey: Not at this rate, no.
theresa 44: i get really tired of the constant whining over hurdle’s handling of the bullpen. he would love to bring in pitchers with talent. not his fault they all pitch somewhere else. how do you feel?
Jason Mackey: Exactly like you do. It’s like saying Huntington doesn’t make moves because he’s cheap or something like that. You think Huntington wouldn’t love to be allowed to spend and do things like Kevin Colbert or Jim Rutherford?
Jason Mackey: OK, folks. That does it for this week. Thanks so much for participating. Yinz are the best. Until next time ...






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.