Pirates manager Clint Hurdle often speaks about the ability to adapt to adverse situations. Hurdle profusely preaches that the best way to overcome obstacles is by calmly addressing the concern, then working it out without panic.

Hurdle's approach has survived injuries this season to Corey Dickerson, Lonnie Chisenhall, Starling Marte, Nick Burdi, Gregory Polanco, Erik Gonzalez, Chris Archer, Keone Kela — and the list goes on.

Twenty total players saw a stint on the injured list for the Pirates through the first 47 games.

The Pirates were able to maintain a winning record headed into a three-game series against the Los Angeles Dodgers this weekend at PNC Park. Bryan Reynolds, Melky Cabrera, Cole Tucker and Jason Martin, among others, have stepped up to give the Pirates unexpected contributions. Reynolds, Tucker and Martin were each called up early because of injuries to Chishenhall, Dickerson, Marte and Gonzalez. Cabrera has seen more playing time than initially predicted because of those injuries. It also helps when Josh Bell has surpassed his home run total from last season and is on pace to top his rookie total of 26 homers.

Advertise with us

"I'm having a blast. The challenges are real. The opportunities are real. The relationships are real,” Hurdle said to reporters after Thursday's win against the Colorado Rockies. "... You have all these plans when you walk in the door and then the season starts and you've got to adapt, improvise and overcome. That's always exciting."

Perhaps nothing so far has been more exciting than the start to Jordan Lyles’ season. Coming out of spring training, it seemed as if Lyles barely won the three-way battle between him, Steven Brault and Nick Kingham for the fifth-starter role. Lyles has excelled, as the Pirates are 8-1 when he starts.

But the starting pitching staff that was supposed to be the team’s strength has taken its share of hits.

Brault and Kingham haven't taken advantage of their opportunities as starters after injuries to Trevor Williams and Jameson Taillon. The Pirates are cautiously optimistic that Williams will be back relatively quickly. Meanwhile, Taillon will be a lot further away. The Pirates’ path to success was contingent upon Williams, Taillon, Musgrove and Archer averaging somewhere between 180-200 innings each. From there, the game would be in the hands of Richard Rodriguez, Kela, Kyle Crick and Felipe Vazquez.

Injuries and poor performance have scrapped that program.

Advertise with us

Now the Pirates are hoping using an "opener" will get them through for a while, until at least Williams gets back. Remember all those off days in April? The Pirates had one on Monday and won't see another until June 3, and after that, the next will be on June 17.

The lack of off days means the Pirates will have to use the opener quite a bit in the next few weeks. Montana DuRapau was nearly perfect in the role last Saturday in San Diego. DuRapau got six outs on 36 pitches and worked through the top of the order. Typically, teams don't want the opener to throw as many pitches as DuRapau did, but he hadn't pitched since May 15 in Arizona.

The Pirates called up Geoff Hartlieb and Clay Holmes while sending down Rodriguez to keep the bullpen as fresh as possible. That combination made it work. Steven Brault's outing was rocky but sufficient for 3⅓ innings. Brault's role was what is called "bulk guy,” as he was expected to get the team to the high-leverage pitchers like Francisco Liriano, Crick and Vazquez. That day he got pretty close as Michael Feliz finished off the sixth inning and came within an out of the seventh. Crick ended the inning, facing one hitter — which was crucial because he threw 17 pitches the night before. And Liriano and Vazquez completed the game.

As well as it worked in San Diego was how poorly it went on Wednesday at PNC Park. DuRapau gave up a three-run homer in the first inning. In spite of Daniel Murphy's bomb off DuRapau, the Pirates were still in the game after scoring two runs in the second.

Kingham was the bulk guy this time, and it didn't go well. Kingham got blasted for six runs on nine hits and four walks. It's been a tough stretch to say the least for Kingham, who has an 8.76 ERA.

Advertise with us

The Pirates didn't name a starter for Friday after their 14-6 win against the Rockies on Thursday. The move was slightly unusual, even for a team using the opener. However, it shows how uncertain things are for the Pirates’ pitching staff. DuRapau wouldn't likely open because of his previous usage. Brault was the most likely candidate, but his 8.24 ERA wasn't exactly awe-inspiring. The Pirates chose to give Feliz his first shot.

It's too early to judge if the opener can work for the Pirates, who are 1-1 in such games.

Just as important as finding a consistent opener is finding a consistent bulk pitcher. Holmes, who threw 3⅓ shutout innings with four strikeouts, could be an option going forward, especially if Kingham’s struggles continue.

Or there's Mitch Keller. Fans were buzzing when Keller was pulled from his scheduled start in Class AAA Indianapolis last Sunday. The buzz quickly died as reports surfaced that the move was for load management. Keller had his best outing on Tuesday, giving up one run in seven innings with six strikeouts. Going by a five-day schedule, Keller would be expected to pitch on Sunday. The Indianapolis Indians would be in Columbus, Ohio. Keller is working on developing a slider, and the Pirates have said they would prefer him to do that work in the minors.

Musgrove and Archer are expected to pitch on Saturday and Sunday. The Pirates start a four-game set in Cincinnati with a doubleheader on Monday. Lyles would line up for one of the games on Monday, which leaves room for another opener in one of the games. Chris Stratton, Holmes or Kingham could be ready to go as bulk pitchers, depending on how the Dodgers series plays out.

Advertise with us

There are so many moving parts that have to go right for the opener to work. Archer and Musgrove would presumably need to go six innings to close the weekend. This would leave several options. If they don't, the pitching situation could get dicey.

Or the Pirates could call up Keller.

Columbus being a two-hour drive down Interstate 71 could make it easier for the Pirates to get Keller — assuming he skips his start, of course. But calling up Keller would still leave the Pirates down a starter.

Somehow, the Pirates will try to continue overcoming the odds.