Receiving criticism of his performance isn’t something Jameson Taillon has much experience with in the past year or so. His rotation mates have reacquainted him with the feeling.

“It’s been funny, I feel like I’ve thrown the ball pretty well and I’m getting people tweeting at me — I think they’re serious — ‘Trade him. Drop him to the bullpen,’” Taillon said. “I have a three flat [ERA, now 4.06 after a substandard outing Thursday] right now and I’m getting chirped at all the time because that’s how good these guys have been.”

This is what happens when you’re the opening-day starter in the best rotation in the league.

Taillon, Trevor Williams, Jordan Lyles, Joe Musgrove and Chris Archer compiled a 2.69 ERA heading into the weekend series against the Los Angeles Dodgers, the best in the National League. Only the Tampa Bay Rays rotation, which includes former Pirates Tyler Glasnow and Charlie Morton, has a better ERA in baseball. A Pirates lineup that for portions of April lacked Gregory Polanco, Starling Marte, Corey Dickerson, Lonnie Chisenhall and Elias Diaz provides no margin for error. The starters thrive off it.

Advertise with us
Jameson Taillon has led the Pirates' pitching staff to a strong start. (Matt Freed / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

“We know,” Archer said. “In order for this team to go, we’ve got to be on our A game. We’ve got to give at worst a quality start, at worst, because that’s how we’re going to go. We embrace it. We want that. Every dude, all five of us, we want that.”

Let’s look at how each of them are doing it.

Williams

Smart people with math skills have devised a way to measure how effective each of a pitcher’s pitches are. Each ball-strike count has a certain run expectancy — how many runs score, on average, after that count — and by adding up the small changes in run expectancy and correlating them with the pitch thrown, sabermetricians derive a value for each pitch, measured in runs.

You would expect the fastball pitch value leaderboard to favor the hard throwers, the Noah Syndergaards and Gerrit Coles of the world. But Williams and his average fastball velocity of 91.6 mph top the chart, at 9.4 runs above average.

Advertise with us

“He’s got the heart and the mind and the soul of a warrior out there,” pitching coach Ray Searage said. “He just keeps coming after you. He’s one of those guys, you go back at the end of the game and you’re 0 for 4 and you’re like, ‘How did that happen?’ His stuff is not something that blows you out of the water, but his command is. Four corners with the fastball, and able to throw behind-in-the-count breaking balls.”

The results: A 2.59 ERA in 31⅓ innings, 21 strikeouts, six walks, 0.96 WHIP

Archer

During one game, April 7 against the Cincinnati Reds, Archer reverted to the fastball-slider pitcher he used to be. He threw 36 four-seamers and 35 sliders out of his 100 pitches because, Searage said, a slow arm impacted his fastball command and decreased the effectiveness of the change-up.

“Had a real good conversation with him,” Searage said. “All the work that you did during spring training, you became a four-pitch pitcher, and now all of a sudden in this game you wanted to do this or you didn’t have fastball command.”

Advertise with us

After working on getting the ball out of his glove on time in his next bullpen session, Archer allowed one run in seven innings and struck out nine in his next outing. He again credited catcher Francisco Cervelli for helping him learn how to use his now-more-prevalent four-pitch mix. But he also pointed to his health.

“Last year people thought, because I used to throw and spin all the way out [during his delivery, after throwing a pitch] and people thought that I was like, I don’t know, being eccentric,” said Archer, who had offseason core surgery. “But I had to get out because I was feeling so much tension on my left side, I had to spin out of it because I couldn’t put my foot in the ground and launch.

“But now I feel very rooted, so my foot hits the ground and then I can launch, as opposed to being a little tentative. More than anything, it helps with throwing the pitch where you want to throw it.”

There’s a reason Archer used to throw his slider so much (and still relies upon it): Remember those pitch values? Archer’s slider is the fourth-best in baseball.

The results: A 2.74 ERA in 23 innings, 26 strikeouts, nine walks, 1.13 WHIP

Advertise with us

Musgrove

Joe Musgrove delivers to the plate during a game against the Cubs in Chicago on April 11, 2019. (Associated Press)

Musgrove keeps the ball in play. Among qualified starters, only four have allowed fewer home runs per nine innings than Musgrove’s 0.34 mark. His rate of 3.8 percent of fly balls that leave the yard is lower than all but three pitchers.

Musgrove has shown no signs that offseason core surgery affected him. He changed his between-starts mobility work to allow his muscles more time to recover.

“We knew exactly what we were up against coming into the season,” Musgrove said earlier this year. “… We have higher expectations of ourselves than anybody ever will.”

Musgrove not only throws a lot of strikes (only six walks in 28⅓ innings), he throws quality strikes, and balls that look like strikes. Batters swing at 38.1 percent of his pitches outside the strike zone, the second-highest mark in baseball (Williams is first at 38.3).

Advertise with us

The results: A 1.59 ERA in 28⅓ innings, 26 strikeouts, six walks, 0.85 WHIP

Lyles

When describing the way Lyles has pitched this season, general manager Neal Huntington referred to Lyles’ comments to reporters in published reports.

“You see him talk about what he used to do,” Huntington said. “He wanted to just get through the lineup with his fastball and he wanted to establish his fastball. Now he’s taking that reliever approach. ‘I’ve got to go get three outs as quickly as I can, and I’ll do it for one inning.’”

Lyles brought the plan he succeeded with in Milwaukee’s bullpen last season to the Pirates’ rotation: Fastball up in the zone, curveball off of that.

Advertise with us

“I can’t say enough about Cervelli, what he does,” Lyles said. “How he’s able to read swings and go through lineups as well as he does. He calls high fastballs with the best of them, for me. That’s what we wanted to do this year, so he loves calling it and I love giving it to him.”

Like Musgrove, Lyles keeps the ball in play, and he does it with his fastball-curveball combo. He uses his slider, which he threw 23.2 percent of the time three years ago, only 5.4 percent of the time. He throws his four-seamer 41.3 percent of the time, his curve a career-high 29 percent.

“He’s got four pitches, fastball at the top of the zone plays real well,” Searage said. “It’s at the top of the strike zone, so you just can’t take it, but he’s able to get the ball down, he’s able to utilize his change-up, and also use the tunneling with the curveball after the fastball up and also the same thing with the change-up.”

The results: A 2.05 ERA in 22 innings, 21 strikeouts and five walks, 1.05 WHIP

Taillon

Advertise with us

Years ago, Taillon played catch with Michael Wacha, another tall Texas righty who now pitches for the St. Louis Cardinals and has one of the game’s best change-ups.

“He threw me a change-up and I said, ‘Hey, how about you show me that change-up?’” Taillon said. “He’s like, ‘Only if you show me your curveball.’ Then we talked about it, and we were both like, ‘That’s going nowhere.’”

Taillon has no feel for a change-up. He does have a feel for breaking pitches, so when he added a slider last season, it clicked. He now throws it 33.7 percent of the time, the most of any pitch.

“I think it still has room to be way more effective than it is right now,” he said. “We’re still experimenting with things and kind of changing the tilt and spin on it every once in a while.”

The slider tunnels well with the fastball, meaning it comes from a similar release point and takes a similar path to the plate until it gets to the plate. But if Taillon isn’t locating his fastball, he said, “They’re both useless.” The good news is, no starter in baseball has a lower average exit velocity against fastballs than Taillon’s 77.1 mph.

Advertise with us

“It’s fun to go out there and have those expectations amongst each other,” Taillon said. “What Trevor did [Tuesday] night, that’s the standard for him. I expect that from him every time he’s out there. Not to put pressure on him, but that’s how good he can be. And when I go out there, I expect to have those standards, too.”

The results: A 4.06 ERA in 31 innings, 25 strikeouts, six walks, a 1.13 WHIP

Cervelli

Multiple starters credited the catcher. He studies them; they rarely shake him. But he demurred.

“That’s them,” he said with a dismissive wave. “I’m just there, with the fingers, and that’s it.”

Advertise with us

Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrinkPG.