Bill Brink: Good morning everyone and welcome to this week's Pirates chat. We'll get going at noon, but you can submit questions now. Thanks to those that already have.
Bill Brink: Alright. Here we go ...
Kol Diamond: When the Pirates get their starting outfield back and shortstop . Will they still be in the race
Bill Brink: If their starting pitching continues at this rate, they could be. Getting Marte and Dickerson back should really help a lineup that is struggling to score runs.
Hunter Muro: If Bryan Reynolds ends up being okay and Lonnie Chisenhall gets back, what do you think the corresponding roster move is with the outfield?
Bill Brink: It could be Jason Martin. They like Reynolds' ability to play center. But they also said Chisenhall will get the at-bats he needs to get, meaning they won't rush him back.
Read More
Larry G: Does Kang have minor league options available?
Bill Brink: He does, two of them. We went through this with the Pirates years before, when we asked about sending him down not because he was bad but just to get him at-bats, and their response was that they didn't think there was much that triple-A could help him with. He needed to adjust to the majors. That . could have changed (it's been a while).
Dan: Does JHK's interpreter have any other job with the team like Assistant GM Mike Gonzalez?
Bill Brink: Not to my knowledge.
PhillyJake: Any report on Kevin Newman in the outfield?
Bill Brink: He played center last night, but the clubhouse doesn't open until 3:15 so we won't know how he looked until later.
Chuck Tanner: Clint is a fine person, but a terrible game manager. His resistance to use his best reliever in non-save situations is ridiculous, not to mention his penchant for putting players in positions they've never played. it is painful to watch him 'manage'.
Bill Brink: Far be it from me to argue with Chuck Tanner, but: I generally think Hurdle is a better game manager than he gets credit for, but there have been two recent incidents -- not pinch-running for Kang because of concerns about Diaz/Pablo/Will Smith, and, like you said, having Vazquez available only for a save situation -- that were not good calls that backfired.
PhillyJake: What did you say to Nesbitt to make him jump ship?
Bill Brink: "John Beilein is overrated."
Rick in Orlando: Bucs should be thrilled about where they are despite the team not hitting at all. At what point do the starting pitchers get frustrated with the lack of offense and then they start going down hill because they think they have to be perfect every time out.
Bill Brink: The starting pitchers, so far, say they embrace the pressure and the onus put on them each night (I spoke to them for a piece I have coming out Sunday with more on this subject, so keep an eye out!) They know they need to bring it every night. Eventually that could wear them down if they continue not to get run support, but it hasn't yet.
Hank: How do the pirates start generating some offense? Do you think it will happen once Dickerson and Marte return?
Bill Brink: I definitely think Dickerson's return will help the lineup, though I know Melky has been hitting well, and Marte could help too if he is consistent.
Bake: Bill, will Tucker continue as starting SS when Newman returns?
Bill Brink: Well that's the question, right? It'd be one thing if it were flipped, if Newman won the job and got hurt; he probably would get his starting job back so the Pirates don't set the precedent of players losing jobs due to injuries. But Newman didn't win the job. So if Tucker is still performing well, he might just keep it.
Mikey: what happened to Osuna? why hasn't he been called-up with all of these injuries?
Mikey: are you sold on Chris Reynolds? looks like he can rake
Bill Brink: I believe you're referring to Bryan Reynolds, who raked last year and early this year in triple-A. I won't say I'm sold on a guy after less than a week, but he was a well-regarded prospect, so this performance does not appear to be out of nowhere.
Bill Brink: oops
Bill Brink: Osuna is rehabbing a neck injury with Class A Bradenton.
Mikey: agree with decision to PH for Tucker last nite?
Scott: Hi Bill, do you think Kang pinch hitting for Tucker in the 9th was a bad decision?
Bill Brink: I'm of two minds. As good as Tucker has been, he's still less than a week into his major league career, while Kang has more experience in the league and is more likely than Tucker to homer. But to justify it with Holland's splits (Tucker's a pinch-hitter) and Kang having seen him (it was forever ago) doesn't make as much sense.
Dale: Two big strikeouts for bell in run scoring opportunities last night. Did you see anything specific that worries you as opposed to what he has been doing lately that led him to success?
Honus: is Josh Bell back? where are the Bucs in terms of HR hit? must be near bottom of the MLB?
Bill Brink: Ah, the difference in perspective.
Bill Brink: He's not terrible after two strikeouts and he's not back after a month, but he is in a really good place with his swing and approach. His swing looks the same every time, which couldn't be said last season.
Rick in Orlando: Can the Bucs stay above 500 despite the injuries? Are Kang and Cervelli's below Mendoza line batting averages concerning?
Bill Brink: Definitely concerning, and more so for Kang than for Cervelli, who I think will be fine.
Bake: Who will be the 5 outfielders when all are healthy? Melky is swinging the bat well and Martin looks like a player.
Bill Brink: Dickerson, Marte, Polanco, Melky ... Shuck? Just because they can option the other two.
MjB: While I think everyone is too focused on the bullpen, which traditionally does not stablize into later in the season, the reality is that most folks do not realize that offensively, we are sending out a basic AAA lineup. Who in this lineup, beyond Bell, Cervelli, and Frazier are long-term legitimate MLB hitters?
Bill Brink: Polanco. Dickerson and Marte when they're back. Kang has been one before.
Rick in Orlando: Buster Olney said the other night that the Pirates can stay in the race because of their starting pitching. From what I've seen it may keep them in most games but the lack of any consistent hitting and below avrage defense will drag the Bucs below 500 again. Thoughts?
Bill Brink: They need to hope they stay afloat until Dickerson and Marte get back, because if they fall into too big of a hole, I'm not sure if they dig out of it the way their lineup is constructed and producing right now. The defense could continue to be a problem, although with Tucker, they might have their best defensive shortstop.
Moe Szyslak: will Gonzalez ever play SS for the Buccos again?
Bill Brink: I'm sure he will, but your point stands: When he's back, the job might not be his.
Rick in Orlando: I like Tucker at short as he has range and a bit of pop in his bat. I believe Newman and Gonzalez are in way over their heads with weak bats and gloves. I've been beating the drum for Kang to go to short but his Mendoza line BA has nixed that idea for now. Thoughts?
Bill Brink: I'd agree with most everything you just said: Like Tucker at short, Newman and Gonzalez did not play good defense and did not make up for it offensively, the way Kang is hitting does not merit trying to force him somewhere.
BobbyToledo: When is Reyes getting shipped back to AAA? Other than that awesome catch in left, he hasn't matched last year's sizzle.
Bill Brink: Right now he's the backup shortstop. Once that changes, he might be back in the minors.
Mike: Bill looking back at last year's trade do you think it was a mistake for Huntington to trade of Austin Meadows and Tyler Glasnow for Archer. I really think we could use Meadows' bat right now.
Bill Brink: I don't think it was a mistake mostly because of the Glasnow part of the trade. Meadows was always going to hurt to lose. They'd tried most everything with Glasnow and it wasn't clicking. They're happy that it has, but it just wasn't working in Pittsburgh.
Bill: Is Newman guaranteed to come back after rehab? I think he offers more on the bench than Reyes, if he can play OF somewhat decently.
Bill Brink: I don't see a scenario where Newman doesn't come back after rehab.
Larry G: With Diaz back. What do you think the catching splits will be. I assume Cervelli will also get some time at 1st against lefties.
Bill Brink: Cervelli will get the majority of the starts, but they'll feel better about resting him with Diaz on the roster.
James: I know evaluators believe Tucker overcame a bad shoulder injury enough to stay at short, but his throwing motion kind of looks funny; is this due to the past injury and surgery?
Bill Brink: Good question, and I don't know. I didn't see enough of him throwing pre-surgery to adequately compare the two. Could be.
Halo: Bill why couldn't Bob Nutting just allocate like $20 million more for some needed bats? Payroll would have still been very low(the way he likes it smh) but the offense would be better. Watching our pathetic bats do nothing most nights while our starting pitching is dominating is super frustrating!! Nutting failed this team agree Bill?
Bill Brink: There are legitimate criticisms to be made of Nutting's payrolls, but I won't fault him for 37 players getting hurt in the first month of the season. We knew Polanco was out; they got Chisenhall, which didn't cost them much but profiled as an adequate fill-in. The real issue was shortstop; they could have spent more/traded for a more experienced one.
Bill: If Steven Brault was right-handed, would he be in the majors? I know we don't have many LH options, but he is just not good enough out of the pen--IMO
Bill Brink: He wasn't going to be until Burdi got hurt, and look at his usage: Hurdle was trying to stay away from him.
James: Based purely on performance, Brault seemed like an odd choice to bring back; was this a matter of timing, or do they still prefer him over the likes of Feliz and Neverauskas, despite him not appearing in a game in a while?
Bill Brink: If they kept Brault down, they couldn't go get him unless someone else went on the IL, whereas they can go get those two whenever now.
James: Excited for Endgame?
Bill Brink: Very. Might go see it midnight Thursday in L.A.
Bill Brink: But I haven't seen Captain Marvel yet. I saw Us instead on the off day in Chicago. So I don't know.
Hank: With virtually every other MLB team signing players to extensions this off-season/season; do you think the bucs will extend anyone this season? Tallion, Williams, Musgrove, & Bell seem like they would be could candidates. Who do you think is most likely if any?
Bill Brink: Those are the ones that jump out. I don't think Taillon, who is the union rep and keyed in to the notion of raising the arbitration standards, will, nor will Bell, a Boras client. The other two could.
Captain Crunch: Hey Bill love the chats. Last season the Pirates were 26-17 and then the roof caved in. They have already lost 3 in a row and the offense looks inept. Is the roof caving in starting a little earlier this year? Heading to LA after these losses is asking for trouble in my opinion.
Bill Brink: Thanks, Captain! I won't say the roof is caving in just yet. They're still pitching really well, and Dickerson and Marte could be back soon, so there are brighter days ahead.
Bill Brink: Lightning round. Go.
Don Orris: 3 quickies for ya: Does Cervelli get traded before the deadline?Is Kang gonna still be playing every day by the end of the season? Does Reynolds stay up with the club the rest of the year? He's hitting well.
Bill Brink: No; yes?; no.
Cj: Do you believe they will get into the playoffs?
Bill Brink: I hate to discount a team so early, but if I had to make a call, I'd say no.
James: Is Tucker's service manipulated at some point this season? Needs about another month down to skirt Super 2.
Bill Brink: That's another excellent question and I think it depends on how well he plays. I used to think the Pirates were hard and fast on Super Two until they called up Meadows last year. So now there might be some wiggle room.
Bill Brink: That's it for today, thanks for all the questions! Nubyjas will do this with you next week from Arlington. Don't forget to send me mailbag questions for Monday, @BrinkPG on Twitter or bbrink@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.