BRADENTON, Fla. — Greetings from a rainy Tuesday at LECOM Park. As Steven Brault takes the mound against the Tigers, let’s get into this week’s mailbag. Newsy two days in Pirates camp: We had starters named at shortstop and third base on Monday, and MLBPA executive director Tony Clark visited camp Tuesday.
Please continue to send us mailbag questions at bbrink@post-gazette.com or nwilborn@post-gazette.com, or on Twitter @BrinkPG and @nwilborn19.
Is it realistic to assume it would be any different with payroll and such if there were other owners (ala Mark Cuban)?
— Daniel, Pittsburgh bred and Atlanta fed
This question reminds me of a quote from Neal Huntington at PiratesFest in 2017. Shortly after Sean Rodriguez called out Bob Nutting, Huntington defended him during an Ask Pirates Management session.
“Sport owners don’t get to be sport owners by losing huge sums of money in their businesses year in and year out,” Huntington said. “Most every other owner that you wish would come into Pittsburgh would operate the way that we are operating now.”
Read More
In a sense, he’s right. Consistently spending more than you make and putting the team in debt, or saddling the roster with large contracts that age poorly without a massive TV deal to bail you out, is a bad way to run a team. And Nutting’s — and the front office’s — choice to invest in more sustainable endeavors, like the draft (before the bonus pools), the development system and the Dominican Republic, isn’t the problem.
The problem comes when fan apathy is rampant (can apathy be rampant? Would it be more correct to say fan apathy is lethargic? Anyway, fan frustration is rampant), attendance is down and the response is to reduce payroll, which only fuels the fan apathy/frustration feedback loop. It’s a chicken-and-egg argument. Do you spend a little more, even with declining local revenue, and hope the fans respond, or wait until attendance increases and then spend? But by hoping attendance increases without increasing payroll, you’re giving Huntington, Clint Hurdle and the players a tiny margin for error.
Anyway. If you had an owner with a large personal fortune who didn’t spend within the traditional confines of running a business, sure, you could assume things would be different.
Is Elias Diaz still out for the start of the season? Any update on his illness? Earlier reports were of a virus of "an undisclosed nature." Will the Pirates keep all three catchers on their roster when he's healthy again?
— @CiaoFarfallah
Diaz is still out to start the season, considering he has not played in a spring training game. During one of our weekly briefings with director of sports medicine Todd Tomczyk, I asked him if there was any update on exactly what kind of virus it was, and he did not elaborate.
The bench gets real tricky when we start thinking about three catchers. I can’t help but think they would want to keep all three because their depth is so thin, although Steven Baron has some major league time, and I don’t think they can sneak Jacob Stallings, who’s out of minor league options, through waivers. But if you’re talking about a bench of Moran, Newman, Stallings and Diaz, that leaves only one spot for Pablo Reyes, Melky Cabrera, JB Shuck or Pat Kivlehan. If Newman makes the team, he’ll be the backup shortstop, but they’ll still need someone who can play center field, such as Reyes or Shuck.
The more I think about it, Stallings is 29 and out of options, so maybe he gets through waivers.
Any chance Will Craig takes Josh Bell’s job in the not too distant future?
— @BarCar565
It’s more possible than I had previously thought, though I previously had very low odds on it. Bell has not improved defensively at first base, despite countless hours of work there. This will be a big year for him offensively. If he can continue the work he put in during the offseason with Joe DeMarco on retaining the approach that worked last September, and if Rick Eckstein has helped, he could combine the higher average and OBP year he had last year with the power he had the year before. Having a durable switch-hitter play 159 games every year is also a nice advantage.
But Craig had a nice offensive year last season, and if he performs well at Class AAA Indianapolis this season, he could reach the majors this year, and next spring this could — could — be a thing.
We’re not supposed to immediately judge trades. So how does the Cole trade look now? They traded for a third baseman because they were moving on from Kang. Well now he’s back and starting at third instead of Moran. I have to say the Astros won, wouldn’t you?
— @1012rbc
Between Cole’s performance last year, the fact that Michael Feliz has been a nonentity and now Moran losing the starting third-base job, I think that’s a fair evaluation. I do think better things are ahead for Musgrove, and Jason Martin looks like a talented player, especially if he can play center.
Besides Keller, who are the starting pitching prospects that have a chance to be called up in 2019?
— @RyanSuchheralli
JT Brubaker and Brandon Waddell are the two that come to mind. Brubaker had a 3.10 ERA in 22 starts with Class AAA Indianapolis last season. Waddell had a bit of a tougher time after his promotion to Indy — 4.19 ERA and 4.0 walks per nine innings — but he keeps the ball in the park and pitched well in Class AA Altoona before his promotion. Rookie Davis would be another possibility.
Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrinkPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.