Frank Coonelly’s explanation for the Pirates’ low payroll is simple enough.

“This year's 25-man roster will likely have more than half of it be players not yet arbitration-eligible,” the club’s president said at PiratesFest last weekend. “Therefore the payroll will reflect that. That same roster will be more expensive the following year as the following players become arbitration-eligible. There will be room for the payroll to grow.”

He’s half-right. Players who reach arbitration eligibility in their third or usually fourth seasons tend to get raises over the league minimum that they’re bound to for their first few years under MLB’s collective-bargaining agreement.

Left unsaid is how much, exactly, those raises will actually cost versus the roughly $30 million the club has pared from its payroll in the past couple of years and money set to come off the books through expiring contracts. Unless multiple young players take star turns in the next couple of years, it’s probably close to a wash.

Advertise with us

The current value of a win above replacement on the free-agent market is estimated by Fangraphs to be about $8 million. It’s hard to tell exactly how well that estimate is holding up in MLB’s chilly labor environment of the last couple of winters, but it’s a good baseline to use in placing a dollar value on the production of the Pirates’ pre-arbitration eligible players.

We also know that players rarely receive their full value in the arbitration process. One of the best working estimates of the percentage of value players take in is 25 percent in the first year of eligibility, 37 percent in the second and 54 percent in the third.

With those baselines established, it just takes some back-of-the-envelope math to project what the Pirates will owe to their young players once they reach arbitration.

The first wave of players to reach it will hit next offseason. The group includes Jameson Taillon, Elias Diaz, Chad Kuhl, Adam Frazier, Josh Bell, Joe Musgrove, Trevor Williams and Erik Gonzalez. Combined, Fangraphs valued their 2018 production at 13.7 WAR.

At $8 million per WAR, that means they’d be worth roughly $109.6 million on the open market. Apply the above percentages and this translates to combined projected arbitration obligations of $27.4 million in 2020, $40.6 million in 2021 and $59.2 million in 2022.

Advertise with us

The next wave to reach arbitration eligibility in 2021 includes Colin Moran, Steven Brault, Kyle Crick and Edgar Santana. Those guys were worth 1.8 WAR in 2018, which translates to projected combined arbitration obligations of $3.6 million in 2021, $5.3 million in 2022 and $7.8 million in 2023.

Add those numbers up and they amount to meaningful raises that, simply tacked on to the Pirates’ current payroll, could easily put the team over the $120 million mark within three years.

It’s not that simple, though, as the Pirates also have substantial money set to come off the books in the years to come. Next year alone, contracts paying Francisco Cervelli $11.5 million, Corey Dickerson $8.5 million, Jung Ho Kang $3 million, Lonnie Chisenhall $2.75 million and Jordan Lyles $2.05 million will expire. That adds up to $27.8 million in money freed up, more than enough to pay for the projected arbitration raises for next season.

In subsequent years, the Pirates will have contract options on veterans Starling Marte, Gregory Polanco and Chris Archer that, if declined, could free up even more money. And let’s not forget that the Pirates have, in the past year and change, shed big obligations to Gerrit Cole, Andrew McCutchen, Francisco Liriano and Ivan Nova before their contracts expired.

This is what churn looks like. There will always be players coming and going, which means that raises for some players won’t necessarily result in added overall costs for the team.

Advertise with us

For this reason, Coonelly is probably exaggerating the true costs of these raises. Unless multiple players significantly overperform and drive their arbitration hauls higher than projections, the payroll will not simply go up automatically. It will only go up if the Pirates commit to breaking the churn cycle of replacing departing, expensive veterans with just another wave of cheap labor.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.