Four players — Roy Halladay, Edgar Martinez, Mike Mussina and Mariano Rivera — were elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame by the Baseball Writers Association of America on Tuesday night. None of them are former Pirates, and the club hasn’t had any modern alumni elected to the Hall in the eight years since Bert Blyleven’s induction in 2011.

Here’s a look at the five most likely candidates to break the streak and a forecast of their odds for induction as their resumes stand today:

Barry Bonds — The outfielder’s numbers are an open-and-shut case. He’s the all-time home run king, a seven-time MVP, an eight-time Gold Glove winner, a two-time batting champion and a 12-time Silver Slugger selection. He has no equal in his era and arguably in the history of the game. He should be in. It’s his checkered history with performance-enhancing drugs that has kept him below the 75 percent support threshold needed for induction. He’s trending in the right direction and got by far the most votes of any former Pirate on the writers’ ballot this year, with support from 59.1 percent of the voters. It’s not a layup that he’ll ever ultimately get in, but he has the strongest case of anyone on this list. Forecast: Good. 

Andrew McCutchen — If he retired today, he’d already rank ahead of Pirates Hall of Famers Bill Mazeroski and Pie Traynor in career wins above replacement at 42.0, according to Baseball Reference. He’s also finished in the top five of MVP voting four times, winning the award in 2013. That’s a stretch of consistent excellence that few active players have produced. If you were going to knock his candidacy before it’s fully formed, you’d probably point to a low home run total of 223 and an apparently quick fall from his prime. His production since age 29 has been a fraction of what it was, and writers tend to favor players who put up big counting stats over long periods of time. Still, his career slash line of .287/.378/.481 holds up well, and his signature speed has given him a good reputation as a fielder and a baserunner. He’s a complete player without Bonds’ baggage, and if he has a couple of big seasons left in him, it could be enough to put him over the top. Forecast: Fair.

Advertise with us

Dave Parker — He fell off the writers’ ballot in 2011, and his candidacy failed in the Modern Baseball Committee two years ago, so those aren’t great signs. His numbers do, however, compare favorably with those of Harold Baines, who earned election via the Today’s Game committee last year. Parker’s career slash line was .290/.339/.471 while Baines’ was .289/.356/.465. Baines has more hits and homers, but only slightly despite three extra seasons to accumulate counting stats. He also didn’t have nearly the defensive reputation of Parker, who has a 3-0 edge in career Gold Gloves. If there’s a case to be made for Baines, there’s still one for Parker. We’ll see if the Modern Baseball committee considers it when it meets again this fall. Forecast: Fair. 

Jose Bautista — Unlike the first three names on this list, he didn’t do much with the Pirates. He has been one of the greatest Toronto Blue Jays ever, though. The two-time A.L. home run champ ranks fourth on that franchise’s all-time WAR list, according to Baseball Reference, and he hit a ton of homers in a short timespan — 227 over a six-year span from 2010 to ‘15. That’s slightly more blasts than McCutchen has in his whole career, so it’s hard to argue he’s anything other than one of the most feared power hitters of this decade. Unlike McCutchen, he doesn’t have much of a defensive reputation. He also strikes out a ton and brings a paltry .247 career batting average to the table. His will be an interesting test case for the Three True Outcome-style players who’ve defined this decade of baseball and figure to dominate the most polarizing Hall of Fame debates in the one to come. Forecast: Fair.

Kenny Lofton — He only played one half of one year with the Pirates in 2003, but it counts. And, boy, was he fun to watch then, even at age 36. He is 15th all-time in steals with 622. Nine of the 14 players ahead of him on the list are in the Hall, which feels like it should count for something. He wasn’t a one-trick pony either. His triple-slash line of .299/.372/.423 is in league with that of Ricky Henderson, the defining speedster of modern times. As FiveThirtyEight’s Neil Paine wrote, there’s an even better comparison to be made to Tim Raines, the outfielder whose controversial case finally ended with induction by the writers two years ago. Lofton dropped off the writers’ ballot after getting just 3.2 percent of the vote in 2013, but if the Today’s Game committee ever wants to re-examine players in Raines’ trailblazing mold, then Lofton should be at the top of the list. Forecast: Poor. 

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24