The San Francisco Giants won three World Series titles between 2010 and 2014. Neal Huntington has never done anything close to that as Pirates general manager, but the Giants’ interest in giving him a promotion to team president this offseason is only a mystery if you’re unfamiliar with baseball’s simmering labor strife.

During that time, the Giants weren’t making much money for a team experiencing a borderline dynastic run in a large market. Forbes estimates their operating income was $23.5 million in 2010, $9 million in 2012 and $53.3 million in 2014. Those were the World Series years.

By comparison, Forbes pegs the small-market Pirates’ income in $15.6, $16.1 and $21.8 million in those campaigns, the last of which ended with a loss to the Giants in the National League wild-card game at PNC Park.

The relatively small difference in those figures is a reason Huntington is revered around baseball. So are comments like this one given to the Post-Gazette on Monday.

Advertise with us

“We have the ninth-best record in baseball over the last six years,” Huntington said. “We are one a few teams that have made the postseason three times in the last seven years.” 

The fan and the humble sportswriter alike say “big whoop.” Owners and executives look at the Pirates’ modest payrolls and say “Wow. This guy can be competitive and make money.” They want to replicate that model. Not San Francisco’s.

The problem with the Giants’ success, in the eyes of a bean counter, is that it had a lot of contractual albatrosses hanging around its neck. The 2010 team alone paid pitcher Barry Zito $18.5 million to post a mediocre 4.25 ERA. It paid outfielder Aaron Rowand $13.6 million to perform basically at replacement level. It paid infielder Edgar Renteria $10 million to post a crummy .706 OPS.

That basically dead money might be worth a championship if you’re a fan or a sportswriter who’s not signing the checks. It’s a deferred yacht purchase for the guy who is, which is why quotes like this from Huntington about his no-name shortstop candidates Kevin Newman and Erik Gonzalez are so appealing to baseball’s ruling class.

“We recognize they don’t have the backs of the baseball cards that some of the available free agents do. But they each bring skills and tools and attributes that give us confidence they can each be a quality big-league shortstop.

Advertise with us

The fan asks whether they are the best available players to bolster a team’s playoff hopes. (Of course they’re not.) An owner asks whether they’ll do enough, and when you look at those Giants, it’s hard to argue that they won’t. Truly, it wouldn’t be hard for either Pirates option to outperform Renteria for a fraction of the cost.

This logic is warping the entire MLB labor market right now. This winter, like last, top free agents with good-looking baseball cards are sitting unsigned or signing for less money than they might have even five years ago. The reason is that more owners are listening to people like Huntington. Sports economics writer Neil deMause put it well in a post on the topic over at Deadspin earlier this week.

“In short, owners around the league are no doubt looking right now at the Machados and the Harpers—and the Keuchels and the Moustakases—and thinking, Yeah, this guy’s great, but how am I going to make my money back on him? And if they have anyone like [researcher] Graham Tyler on staff, they’re going to be told, You can’t, because the way baseball’s finances are set up, the marginal revenue product of even the best players — the amount of extra value they are likely to put in an owner’s pocket, compared to if that owner put a cut-rate option on the field — isn’t anywhere near what they’re looking to be paid.”

Your eyes glassed over at “marginal revenue product,” didn’t they? That’s fine. Everyday sports fans shouldn’t have to worry much about that, but they do in baseball because that number is much lower than contract values you’re used to seeing in the news this time of year. Elsewhere in his post, deMause cites research by Tyler, now the director of player operations for Tampa Bay, that says even perennial All-Stars like free agent infielder Manny Machado will never be worth any more than $6.75 million to a team in pure dollar terms.

The reason is that most teams’ revenue is guaranteed through sources like media rights fees and revenue sharing and thus divorced from the impact any player or players might have on a win-loss record. You should read deMause’s post if you want to get into the big-picture stuff more deeply.

Advertise with us

The important thing to know if you’re a Pirates fan is that Huntington’s tone-deaf statements this week and, frankly, the last several years are the views that have led the entire sport to its present tone-deaf state of affairs, where purportedly competitive entities are content to get by with less talent than they could have because of price. Owners see Huntington as a visionary. They see Giants architect Brian Sabean as he is — unemployed from baseball operations in any meaningful capacity.

With that in mind, the question Huntington faces moving forward shouldn’t be “Is Kevin Newman good enough?” The question is whether it’s good for the long-term health of the game if the answer for most teams is always yes, even if they can afford to pay for clear upgrades like, say, Machado.

That answer, for now, also appears to be “yes.” The Pirates’ attendance has plummeted as the team has fallen back from playoff contention in recent years, but the TV viewership has been steady. People are watching whether the Pirates are trying their best to compete or not. Because media accounts for much more of the pie than attendance does, Huntington and the Pirates can get away with paring their payroll to a projected $71.3 million for 2019 from about $100 million two years ago.

Until baseball's economics change, that won’t just be true here. It will be increasingly true everywhere else, too. Ask the proud Giants fans who almost had Huntington’s “back of the baseball card” shtick in their team president’s office.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.