LAS VEGAS — Clint Hurdle was a hitting coach for a long time, and those instincts are still strong in the Pirates manager. So when discussing the notion of banning defensive shifts, he puts the onus on the batter.

“What the shifts are telling hitters, is here’s what you do, and here's the way we’re going to play you, Hurdle said. “And it's now that point of competition where a punch has been thrown, a defense has been laid out, where is your counter-punch? Where is your answer?”

Jayson Stark of the Athletic reported last week that baseball’s competition committee recommended to commissioner Rob Manfred that baseball somehow restrict defensive players’ abilities to roam around the field based on where a particular batter puts balls in play most frequently. Manfred has mentioned the idea in the past. It’s not Hurdle’s favorite.

“If there ever gets a day where they ask me what I think, and there may be, I don't have it in my DNA to say no, we can't have the shifts,” he said.

Advertise with us

Clint Hurdle on using an 'opener'

Previously, Hurdle said, some teams leveraged batted-ball data to position their fielders while others did not, creating a competitive advantage. Now, everyone uses the data.

“My first initial reaction is like, these hitters need to figure some things out and attack it from that standpoint,” he said. “We talk about our guys how it's real. And they're doing it for a reason. It's just like they pitch you for a reason. They feel you've got some weak spots and they want to isolate that and you want to work to your strong spots. Let's work to the strong spots to try to get the third infielder on the right side of the infield, get him back over to short stop and open up some ground.”

Chisenhall has an “edge”

In addition to providing, when healthy, a potent left-handed bat, Lonnie Chisenhall could bring something extra to the Pirates, Hurdle said.

“He's at a time in his career where he also feels an edge, and a want-to is probably maybe a little bit -- there's more traction to it than before, because he's been off the field some,” Hurdle said.

Advertise with us

Chisenhall missed significant time in the past two years because of injuries to both calves. But in the past two seasons, he had a .368 on-base percentage, a .503 slugging percentage and a .297 average.

The Pirates signed Chisenhall to play right field until Gregory Polanco returns from shoulder surgery and Chisenhall could serve as a fourth outfielder after that.

“When this man has been on the field, the bat has played,” Hurdle said. “The versatile defender has played. There's experience and there's playoff experience, there's good team experience, being a teammate. So he brings a lot of intangibles as well as skill sets to the game that can compliment our club.”

Hitting coach tandem

Hurdle has some experience with his new tandem of hitting coaches, Rick Eckstein and Jacob Cruz. Eckstein worked with Davey Johnson, who managed Hurdle with the New York Mets in the 1980s and whom Hurdle knows well, in Washington. Hurdle coached Cruz while in the Colorado Rockies organization.

Advertise with us

“He was very impressive in the early interview we had,” Hurdle said of Cruz. “Following up, talking to some other people, that he had some common history with, that I had common history with, found out that he had really worked hard at research, himself.”

Eckstein replaced Jeff Branson as hitting coach and Cruz replaced Jeff Livesey as assistant hitting coach.

“To find out Rick's background in a more meaningful way, the different roles, the different responsibilities, the different ideas that he's had, the update, the awareness of the new technology out and available and how it applies and having the language that can simplify it, I think he's a really good find for us,” Hurdle said.

Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrinkPG.