Ivan Nova paused, gaze steady. This was not so much a rhetorical question; he was waiting for an answer.

“You see Tampa Bay, they’re going to finish the season over .500,” Nova said. “What’s the difference between Tampa Bay and us?”

Yeah, Nova said, they have some young players. Yeah, they have some veterans. Nova would argue the Pirates have the better pitching staff. But the Rays were 85-66 on Thursday, the Pirates 77-74.

“But there is something that they have that probably we don’t have,” Nova said. “I don’t know what it is.”

Advertise with us

That’s the trick. That’s what the clubhouse, coaching staff and front office must unlock this winter as they attempt to put a contender on the field in 2019. The 2018 Pirates showed potential. They were in first place May 17 with a 26-17 record. They’ve gone 51-57 since entering the weekend series against Milwaukee. What went wrong? Or is this about what we should have expected?

Entering the weekend, the Pirates had scored 649 runs. They had allowed 649 runs. Put the calculators down, we’ll do this one for you: That’s a run differential of zero, meaning the 77-74 record is about right, a relatively accurate depiction of the team’s talent and capabilities.

“As difficult and challenging [as] the two major trade decisions we made a year ago, the intent was to see if we could surprise in ’18, because we believed we were going to be a better team than most people on the outside did,” general manager Neal Huntington said. “We believed we were going to be a better team than external projection models, so how do we get back to that? The core is in place.”

Those two major trade decisions involved dealing Andrew McCutchen and Gerrit Cole. They traded for Corey Dickerson to fill the void in the outfield. While they got Joe Musgrove back in the Cole trade, and Musgrove has pitched well this season, he isn’t Cole. So go figure that the rotation would be a strength of the team.

“I know personally that we have starting pitching, especially — because the bullpen has been tremendous the whole year round — but as a starting pitcher we were able to put up a good run that maybe a lot of people outside can say, that could be a playoff run,” Nova said.

Advertise with us

The rotation was below average through the All-Star break. Trevor Williams and Jameson Taillon fueled a second-half run that produced a 3.38 ERA for the unit, tied for third in the National League during that time period. They have walked the fewest batters per nine innings in that span. Taillon has a 3.24 ERA in 178 innings, Williams a 3.16 mark in 159⅔ innings. Since coming off the disabled list in June, Nova has a 3.46 ERA.

“They’re all really fun to play behind because they work quick,” Colin Moran said. “Trevor for sure gets a lot of ground balls, so you’ve got to stay ready. They’ve had great years.”

The Pirates’ bullpen also ranks third in the league in ERA in the second half, middle of the pack for the season due to a rough start. So was the hole too deep to dig out of in the first half?

Let’s see … the Pirates went 16-12 in April (pretty good start), 12-15 in May (not great, not terrible) … 10-16 in June (yeesh). But from May 17, when they were in first place, to July 7, the day before Huntington declared the coming week a make-or-break time span, they went 14-31 and were eight games under .500.

“We’re like, seven games out of the wild card,” Nova said [six, as of Thursday]. “And if you say, maybe out of that month that we lost 20 out of [expletive] 30, we win 17 out of those, you won’t be that bad.”

Advertise with us

They answered Huntington’s call, winning seven out of eight before the break and carrying an 11-game winning streak into Cleveland in July. Then Corey Dickerson got hurt, life got hard again and they went 10-17 in August.

“On the road trip when we won [11] in a row; that tells you that we can do it,” Nova said. “There’s something that is missing, something that is not clicking. We just got to find the way to click, because we went to Cleveland, we played tremendous in Cleveland, a team that won the division. We were playing great in Chicago, against Milwaukee. I think it’s just one little thing. What it is?” Nova shrugged.

Let’s look for culprits.

The offensive production puts the Pirates in the middle of the pack in most areas save two: strikeout percentage, in which they were tied for the best in the league, and home runs. Only the San Francisco Giants and Miami Marlins hit fewer homers through Thursday than the Pirates’ 145. The corner infielders, Moran and Josh Bell, combined for 20. Bell hit 26 last year.

“It’s just a matter of getting [Bell] to understand what made him successful a year ago, getting back to that, and we’re certainly seeing signs of that there,” Huntington said. “No doubt, the almost 30 homers that he hit a year ago versus the 10 or 11 that he’s hit this year, you add those 20-something home runs and ideally a few more, it changes the complexity of our offense, to have that consistent four-hole hitter that we believed we were having develop in front of our eyes. To have that threat in the middle of the lineup, there’s no doubt about it, get some home runs from Colin at third base if he’s our guy again next year, you get some more production from our corners, it is important.”

Advertise with us

Moran and Bell also struggled defensively. Moran allowed eight more runs than the average third baseman with his defense, according to Baseball Info Solutions’ calculation of Defensive Runs Saved, and Bell allowed nine more. According to Ultimate Zone Rating, the Pirates ranked 30th in first-base defense, 23rd at third base.

Moran reads Fangraphs. He’s seen the metrics.

“Not great, obviously,” he said. “I think criticism of me is pretty fair. It’s something I’m going to work the whole offseason to get better at.”

It wasn’t just the corner guys. Polanco disappeared at the plate for months on end. Dickerson ran hot and cold. Josh Harrison had a substandard year. George Kontos and Michael Feliz were ineffective early and Felipe Vazquez had a terrible stretch in late May. Francisco Cervelli had a career year at the plate but concussion issues kept him off the field at times.

Coming from the outside, Chris Archer sees potential.

Advertise with us

“First of all, our pitching staff, the rotation and the bullpen, is so deep,” he said. “We’re going to be able to compete just from that alone. The excitement that the young guys, the young position players, are bringing is really nice. Josh Bell’s bat’s really coming around. Starling Marte is Starling Marte. He’s capable of contending for the MVP, in my opinion, every year. Corey’s doing this thing. It’s really fun to watch, it’s fun to be a part of.”

One more telling stat: The Pirates are 37-55 against teams with records of .500 or better. Success against those teams is not a prerequisite for making the playoffs — Oakland is 31-39 against them, Cleveland 21-30 — but 18 games below .500 won’t do. That’s not a very nuanced evaluation — the Pirates didn’t play as well against good teams as they did against bad ones — but like Nova said, flip that just a bit, say, 45-47, and the playoffs become reachable.

This offseason, the Pirates will need to figure out how to build and maintain a team that can match up with the best (they’ll have to beat playoff teams in the regular season if they want to beat them in the playoffs), a team that can hit for more power or find another way to make up for the lack of it, and a team that can get the most out of the sum of its parts.

“As a group here, everything is perfect,” Nova said. “I’m not going to say that it’s fighting here, or guys throwing things against each other, because it’s not happening. The front office is great with us, the coaching staff is great with us, so it’s something that somebody has to figure out.”

Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrinkPG.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh sports news in my inbox? Yes, please.

Get the PG Sports Feed newsletter each weekday here.