I liked the Pirates’ acquisitions of Chris Archer and Keone Kela at the trade deadline — who didn’t? — but those weren’t the most significant developments of the past few months.
The biggest development was seeing the club’s young core players turn their seasons around and thus offer real hope for the near future.
Jameson Taillon, Josh Bell and Gregory Polanco are the building blocks around here. They need to be, anyway, and for a while they seemingly were vying for the club’s “Most Disappointing Player” award this season.
By early July, the present and near future looked equally bleak.
Then everything changed.
It could change again, of course, because baseball is cruel that way. Only the test of time will reveal a player’s true pedigree.
Read More
For now, though, it appears as if Taillon, 26, is on track to become the staff ace while Bell, 25, and Polanco, 26, join old man Starling Marte (he’s only 29 — and not an ancient Andrew McCutchen-like 29, either) as the key hitters in the lineup.
That’s not all. Elias Diaz, 27, has the look of an everyday catcher, and several other young pitchers — Joe Musgrove, 25, Trevor Williams, 26, Kela, 25, and reliever Kyle Crick, 25, come to mind — have delivered encouraging results.
But let’s start with Taillon, because everything starts with the rotation. That remains a baseball truth despite the proliferation of stocked and talented bullpens. The top five teams in starters’ earned-run average almost always make the playoffs.
Here’s proof: Over the past five seasons (2013-17), if you take the top five National League teams in starters’ ERA every year, 22 of 25 have made the playoffs. When the Pirates qualified three years in a row, their starters’ ERA ranked fourth, seventh and fifth. These past three years, they have dropped to 11th, seventh and, this year, 10th.
Taillon, after an uneven two months, has settled into an unprecedented groove, buoyed by increased use of his slider. Since a blowup start May 22 at Cincinnati, he has made 13 starts and gone 7-4 with a 3.08 ERA (which would rank seventh in the NL over the full season), 71 strikeouts and 19 walks in 82⅔ innings.
That is the kind of pitcher the Pirates desperately need, the kind who’ll put a foot down the way Taillon did Tuesday in Colorado. His complete game didn’t just secure victory that night but assisted in one the next day on account of a rested bullpen.
The idea of Taillon, Archer, Musgrove — who has pitched at least seven innings in each of his past four starts — and Williams taking turns in next year’s rotation seems fairly enticing (and yes, I’d still love to see the Pirates part with recent tradition and spend big money on a high-end starter).
Polanco had people asking, legitimately, in May if he should be sent to the minor leagues. But like Taillon he made an adjustment that changed his season. He moved farther off the plate and has been mostly wrecking pitchers ever since. He produced in July and August, the best back-to-back months of his career, and has risen to eighth among NL outfielders in OPS, to say nothing of his rocket arm in right field.
Bell had the second-best month of his young career in July, before he was injured. He has been hot and cold all season, not uncommon for a young player, and has yet to rediscover the home run power from his rookie year. But he has improved defensively and still strikes me as the definite long-term answer at first base.
Meanwhile, a ready-made middle infield awaits in the form of shortstop Kevin Newman and second baseman Kevin Kramer, both of whom are hitting above .300 in Class AAA. That could happen as soon as next season.
All of those players — Bell, Taillon, Newman, Kramer and others — can do a lot to change the evaluation of Neal Huntington’s draft record.
At one time, not long ago, that draft record looked awful, but it’s looking better every day. Kind of like the Pirates’ near future.
Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Starkey and Mueller” show weekdays from 2-6 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.