This week, the Cubs and Yankees acquired Cole Hamels and J.A. Happ. Those are two pitchers the Pirates should have pursued, especially given how little Chicago and New York paid to get them.

If the Pirates didn’t, and there is no indication they did, fans should question whether the front office is serious about making the playoffs.

The postseason should be the Pirates’ goal, and to get there they need to at least add one veteran starting pitcher. This not a new concept, actually, as I wrote something similar in April and in May. The rotation is too young and inconsistent to sustain enough success for a run to the playoffs.

An extra reliever wouldn’t hurt, but a starter is a must, and that’s why it was disappointing to see Hamels and Happ go to teams already in playoff position. Given the price to acquire them, the Pirates should have had no issues making a deal.

Advertise with us

And spare me the “those two large market teams can take those kinds of chances, and the poor little Pirates cannot” nonsense. This had nothing to do with market size and everything to do with the fact that both front offices understood they needed to improve their teams.

Both pitchers are on expiring contracts, so there is no long-term risk involved. Happ is owed $4 million; the Yankees gave up a struggling infielder and a Class AAA outfielder to get him. Hamels is owed $8 million for the rest of this season and has a $6 million buyout on his club option for 2019. He cost the Cubs several low-level minor-leaguers.

Those two deals are well within what the Pirates are capable of doing. They didn’t require a haul of top prospects or, relatively speaking, a lot of money. Happ and Hamels are also both left-handers, which, given the dimensions of PNC Park, should have made them even more attractive. The park is built for lefties, and the Pirates currently have none in their rotation.

Hamels’ numbers this year aren’t great (5-9, 4.72 ERA), but as Buster Olney pointed out, he was a much different pitcher on the road (2.93 ERA) than at home (6.43 ERA) in a hitter-friendly ballpark. The Cubs are banking on getting the road version of Hamels, seeing as he won’t have to pitch in Arlington again this season.

Earlier this month, I was in the “sell and get ready for 2019” camp because this looked like a dead team walking. Things have changed significantly, though, thanks to an 11-game winning streak and a 14-8 record in July.They have cut their deficit in the NL Central Division race from 12 1/2 games to eight and their wild-card deficit from 10 1/2 games to 3 1/2.

Advertise with us

The front office, which continually scoffs at the perception that they aren’t interested in winning, can no longer sit on their hands and hope that this magical ride continues. I’m not saying the Pirates should sell the farm and go “all-in,” but they need to at least add to their staff There aren’t a lot of starting pitchers on the market, either, and that’s why missing out on Hamels and Happ is disappointing.

Some fans and media members seem annoyed that a large portion of the fan base isn’t buying what the team is selling — but those fans aren’t ready to “enjoy the ride” because the ride won’t end in the postseason. This team, as constituted, is not good enough to make it. Why get excited about a team that finishes with 83 wins and misses the playoffs by a few games? That is no different than winning 78 games (or 70, for that matter). This town should be beyond celebrating the Pirates finishing with a winning record.

A playoff run is what will get people interested in this team and trusting it again, not a few weeks of winning. If the front office wants people to jump on their bandwagon, management needs to show they are committed to trying to get to the playoffs. The Pirates are closer to that than they were three weeks ago. It’s up to the front office to try and push them over the top.