The signs were there for about a week. Then, the Pirates pulled the plug.
The team on Sunday optioned outfielder Austin Meadows to Class AAA Indianapolis. To take Meadows’ spot on the roster, they recalled right-hander Tanner Anderson for his second big-league stint.
Meadows, who started the season as the Pirates’ top position player prospect, was first promoted in May when Starling Marte went on the disabled list. He played his way onto the club after an incredibly hot start: a .409 average, four home runs and a 1.221 OPS in his first 13 games, good enough for National League rookie of the month honors in May.
In his last 35 games, including 23 starts, Meadows has batted .252 with one homer and a .641 OPS. In total, he is hitting .298 with five homers and an .810 OPS.
“I’m really excited about what he did, especially that first week,” general manager Neal Huntington said. “The last month hasn’t been as productive, and it’s tough to ask a young player to not play. It’s in his best interests and our best interests to let him grow and develop.”
Meadows has not started a game since last Sunday, and it seemed inevitable that the Pirates, who intended to play him seven out of 10 games when they set up their four-man outfield in late May, would eventually send him down to the minors, especially now that Marte and Gregory Polanco have heated up. Because their four-man outfield was designed with the idea of having benefits for each player, Marte’s and Polanco’s recent success made Meadows the odd-man out.
Read More
“Austin wasn’t a fourth outfielder,” Huntington said. “It was not in his best interest or our best interests to serve as a fourth outfielder. So, once the rotation stopped, because those three starters were really producing again, it became time to try to get him out.”
Huntington said he learned from Polanco’s early successes in 2014, followed by a long slump, during which Polanco remained with the big-league club.
“You could easily argue that had I taken him off the club and let him go play regularly for a month instead of being a role-player behind Travis Snider, we might have seen Gregory Polanco turn the corner quicker,” Huntington said.
Another sign that seemed to indicate Meadows would be sent down was Jordan Luplow’s July 6 promotion from Class AAA Indianapolis. Luplow has started three games since his call-up, all against left-handed starters.
“The best and easiest answer to that is we’re in a win-now mode,” Huntington said. “We’re fighting for our playoff lives. And I support the staff in putting out the lineup every night that they feel gives us the best chance to win that game. Jordan Luplow’s done a real nice job against left-handed pitching. I actually kicked myself that we didn’t bring Jordan up the time when we faced three or four or five left-handers in a two-week stretch.”
The move took place two or three days later than it normally would have, Huntington said, because of Saturday’s doubleheader.
“Once he stopped playing regularly would have been the best time to get him out,” Huntington said. “But we needed to leave ourselves some flexibility to get through the doubleheader yesterday. The move was made today because we needed another arm in the bullpen and a chance to get Austin out.”
As a result of Sunday’s move, Meadows may not receive Super 2 status in a couple of years. If that is the case, the Pirates would avoid paying Meadows a fourth year of salary negotiated through the arbitration process.
Generally speaking, in his first big-league season, a player must spend around 65 days of the MLB season in the minors to avoid Super 2 status, according to FanGraphs. By that measurement, Meadows, who did not join the club until May 18, would have to spend slightly more than two weeks in the minors not to acquire Super 2 status. If he is not a Super 2 candidate, Meadows will go through arbitration for the first time after the 2021 season, rather than after the 2020 season.
Huntington said avoiding Super 2 eligibility did not factor into the decision to option Meadows, and it is not known exactly how much service time Meadows will need in the future in order to acquire Super 2 status.
“We brought him up because we felt he was our best player at that point in time,” Huntington said. “We’ve sent him out because it doesn’t make any sense to put a young prospect and leave him on the bench to play once or twice a week.”
Anderson appeared in one game for the Pirates this season. He pitched two innings and allowed five earned runs against the Los Angeles Dodgers.
Elizabeth Bloom: ebloom@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BloomPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.