It’s hard to blame the Pirates for wanting to give Gregory Polanco more chances. Look at him. His 6-foot-5, 235-pound frame and physical gifts are everything you’d expect a future All-Star to possess. Unless he really lets himself go, it will probably always feel like he has the potential to break out with the right combination of adjustments.
Still, the reality is that he’s 26 and has 551 games of big-league experience. His body of work is large and underwhelming enough that it fits a pretty consistent profile — journeyman rather than future MVP candidate — when compared to past players.
We’ve talked about the Sports Reference network’s similarity scores here before in trying to put Ben Roethlisberger’s future in historical context. But if you’re just tuning in, the important thing to know is that they follow a formula designed to create lists of comparable players based on production. (As opposed to style. This is an important distinction to make.)
Gregory Polanco’s comparables aren’t great.
Through age 25, his career best matches up with those of Ken Henderson, Willie Montanez, Gary Geiger, Junior Felix, Jose Guillen, Gary Thomasson, Oddibe McDowell, Willie Crawfod, Charlie Spikes and Jeremy Hermida.
If you’re asking yourself, “Who?” right now, there’s a good reason for that.
Of those 10 players, only Montanez appeared in an All-Star Game. And only Henderson received MVP votes — he finished 19th in the voting in 1974.
Beyond them, it’s a whole lot of mediocrity. A few guys received votes for rookie of the year. A few others posted some fat numbers for a season or two before reverting to form. But none of them did anything that would make you feel good about Polanco’s ability to become a cornerstone for the Pirates.
They also did not tend to stick with their original teams. Henderson played for five clubs after he left San Francisco at age 26. Montanez played for nine teams, including the Pirates. Guillen led the group by playing for 10 teams. And all 10 players wore the uniforms of at least three different teams.
None of this is to say that Polanco can’t live up to the hype that followed him through the Pirates’ minor-league system and become a fixture for the franchise. The comparisons are for this point in the players’ careers, not their entire careers.
Some players are late bloomers who take off and make names for themselves before turning 30, the age when players typically begin to exit their primes. Think of Jose Bautista, who struggled with the Pirates before becoming a star in Toronto. He made the first of his six All-Star appearances at age 29 and has left Pirates fans feeling like they missed out ever since.
The data, however, suggests it would be presumptuous to lump Polanco in with the latter group rather than the former one because it’s very consistent. There aren’t many truly awful players on the list, nor are there big names who kicked it into gear eventually. Rather, the group includes 10 players who put up decent numbers over long but largely unremarkable careers.
That kind of unanimity tends to narrow the cone of uncertainty, to use a weather analogy. If his numbers are mediocre now, history suggests they’ll stay that way for most of his career. He could turn out to be an outlier like Bautista, but he’d be just that. He wouldn’t be tracking with how a lot of players of similar production through his age did.
Perhaps that’s not enough for the Pirates to drop him from their controversial rotation of four outfielders quite yet. But it will likely weigh in their decisions more and more if he fails to turn things around and Austin Meadows, Corey Dickerson and Starling Marte continue to rake the way they have in the early months of 2018.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.