CINCINNATI — For most of the season, the Pirates have beat up on worse teams. Their ability to come back late in games, particularly against those sub-.500 squads, seems to have been a calling card. The first game of their season, an extra-inning affair against the Detroit Tigers, set the tone, and ever since the Pirates have tried to make a habit of scratching their way back.

Yet division rivals have certain advantages, and on Wednesday, the situation was reversed for the Pirates — at least for a while. After taking a 4-1 lead into the eighth and giving the ball to their high-leverage relievers, the Cincinnati Reds forced extra innings. Yet the Pirates persisted, beating the Reds, 5-4, in 12 innings to end their four-game losing streak. With his family watching in the stands, Cincinnati native Josh Harrison hit a go-ahead, opposite-field triple in the 12th. Jordy Mercer scored from first base, making a nifty tag of home plate.

“It’s almost a perfect storm for him, isn’t it?” manager Clint Hurdle said of Harrison. “I mean, he’s playing at home, just come back off the DL, he’s got a lot of people in the stands. … I mean, it’s special. Big-time players make big-time plays. He’s shown the ability to do that.”

Harrison — who had a large contingent waiting for him after the four-hour, 21-minute game — once played an all-star game at Great American Ball Park as a student at Princeton High School.

Advertise with us

“Didn’t have a chance for a game-winning hit there,” Harrison said. “But I always knew given how I felt about myself, and confidence-wise, that there’d be a time that I’d be here in a big situation.”

Cincinnati native Josh Harrison discusses game-winning hit against Reds

Things initially unraveled for the Pirates (27-21) in the eighth. Michael Feliz allowed a leadoff single and then took a comebacker off his right buttocks. He was visited by his teammates and the training staff but remained in the game.

Things didn’t improve from there, and a sacrifice fly from Eugenio Suarez cut the Pirates’ lead to 4-2. Felipe Vazquez, who entered for the four-out save, didn’t get one, giving up two hits and leaving with the game tied at 4. Feliz was responsible for the three runs.

The performance erased the lead established during Chad Kuhl’s efficient outing. He pitched six-plus innings, allowing five hits and one run, a homer to series foe Scooter Gennett. Kuhl struck out six, walked one and threw just 78 pitches, 52 for strikes. After allowing a leadoff single in the seventh, he was pulled in favor of Edgar Santana.

“I feel like I got ahead of hitters a lot better than I had in my previous start, so [I was] able to locate that, and if I did fall behind being able to throw some off-speed pitches and then get back with the fastball,” Kuhl said.

Advertise with us

Kuhl also contributed with his bat, reaching first on an attempted bunt single. Austin Meadows scored from second on a heads-up send by third-base coach Joey Cora.

In the first inning, Francisco Cervelli, who has been hitting third with Starling Marte out of the lineup, hit a 381-foot, two-run home run, scoring Gregory Polanco. It was his seventh homer of the season, matching his career-high from 2015. Corey Dickerson added an RBI single, which scored Harrison, and had four hits on the night.

Cervelli later left the game with discomfort in the fourth finger on his right hand; he was hit on the hand while trying to block a pitch. After the game, he said he would be fine.

The Pirates chased Homer Bailey after five-plus innings, collecting 10 base hits and three walks against him. Yet for most of the game they couldn’t take advantage of other offensive opportunities. In the sixth, they had the bases loaded with no outs but couldn’t convert. They stranded a pair in the 10th and couldn’t bring home Dickerson from second base in the 11th. In total, the Pirates left 15 men on base and were two for 14 with runners in scoring position.

Steven Brault entered in the 10th and threw two scoreless innings. The Reds threatened in the bottom of the 12th, getting two hits and a walk to load the bases against Kyle Crick, who escaped the inning and earned his first big-league save.

Advertise with us

“[Elias] Diaz did a really good job of bringing me back to Earth, and he was just really good about keeping my tempo and my breath good and called a really good game,” Crick said.

Elizabeth Bloom: ebloom@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1750 and Twitter @BloomPG.