The first thing you have to acknowledge in any fair evaluation of Pirates general manager Neal Huntington is this: He shows up for work every day wearing financial handcuffs.

But even then, rating his job performance can be tricky.

Seems every time you want to laud Huntington as a baseball savior who should be signed for life, the Pirates fall flat on their face. And every time you want to kick him out the door, the Pirates unexpectedly show up in first place on May 17.

In his 11th full season as GM, Huntington continues to confound. He continues to enrage the masses (or least the Tweeters and talk-show callers) and defy conventional assessment.

Advertise with us

Is he the right man to lead the Pirates to a championship?

Is anybody, given the club’s largely self-imposed financial constraints?

I’ve mostly been a Huntington defender, though my enthusiasm dips from time to time. Sometimes precipitously.

On one hand, he resuscitated a dying franchise. That is inarguable. On the other, his teams have never won a division title or a playoff series.

On one hand, Huntington continues to find players in all kinds of places, whether it be Corey Dickerson (jettisoned by Tampa Bay) or Richard Rodriguez (minor-league free agent).

Advertise with us

On the other, he struggles to produce impact players from the one area where he and everyone else in baseball have long insisted the “small-market” Pirates must find them: the draft.

ESPN’s David Schoenfield wrote the following on March 2: “According to thebaseballgauge.com, the Pirates produced the least amount of talent in the major leagues in 2017: Just 12.3 WAR (a measurement that rates all-around play) came from players originally signed or drafted by the Pirates.”

That is staggering. Schoenfield went on to say, “Huntington has presided over 10 drafts. He and his lieutenants simply haven’t drafted well.” He then recounted the ugly truth in the form of picks such as Tony Sanchez (fourth overall in 2009) and Reese McGuire (14th overall in 2013).

On the other hand, the verdict with several picks is pending. Jameson Taillon and Josh Bell, for example, profile as potential long-term impact players. But we have to see it happen before we pronounce them as such. Chad Kuhl has gone through fits and starts as he attempts to establish himself as a legit piece of the puzzle. He remains intriguing.

The likes of Nick Kingham, Austin Meadows and Tyler Glasnow also remain intriguing, though Meadows — who was once regarded as Andrew McCutchen’s sure successor and is will be promoted Friday — was off to an iffy start in Triple-A with just one home run and a .733 OPS through 32 games (he went 3 for 5 Thursday).

Advertise with us

In other words, unanswered questions abound regarding Huntington’s drafts.

On the other hand, one can make up for draft deficiencies by procuring young talent other ways. Dickerson is one example. Colin Moran, acquired in the Gerrit Cole trade, has shown positive signs (yes, I know Cole has turned into Roger Clemens; I’m just not sure it would have happened here, but that's a column for another day).

Huntington made brilliant trades for young pitchers when he acquired Trevor Williams and Felipe Vazquez. He got Williams in exchange for a pitching coach, for goodness sake. He made a smart and lopsided trade for a young player named Josh Harrison several years ago, and who knows what he might have in Joe Musgrove?

On the other hand, the Pirates speak often of how well they’ve established themselves in Latin America, but as Schoenfield put it, “Gregory Polanco, who had a terrible 2017 (0.0 WAR), is the only significant Latin player to come up since Starling Marte in 2012.”

Huntington confounds on the PR front, as well. He can be lawyerly and vague and downright infuriating by pounding home the same message points no one wants to hear. On the other hand, he can be refreshingly blunt and eminently sensible.

Advertise with us

During Cutch-a-Palooza this past weekend, he was asked if he’d been in touch with McCutchen.

“I’m probably the last person he wants to talk to,” Huntington said.

Of the team’s failures to build on the 98-win team of 2015 — notably the J.A. Mis-Happ — he recently said: “I’ll take all the blame.”

Does he get credit, then, for what has transpired so far this season? Huntington refused to use the term “rebuild” in spring training. He insisted his formula was workable.

“The game is becoming about depth, about (having) a number of guys,” he said. “Rather than a ‘carrier’ or two, you need to be able to plug guys in at different times … and that’s where we believe this club has that depth.”

Advertise with us

It's a long year. The Steelers will have played four games by the time this death march of a regular season ends. But I’m back on the Huntington bandwagon for now. He has done far more good than harm.

I’m not sure if he’s the right guy to lead this team to a championship, but I must ask: How many guys win a championship in handcuffs?

Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1. Joe Starkey can be heard on the “Starkey and Mueller” show weekdays from 2-6 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.

Clarification, posted May 17, 2018: This story has been updated to reflect news of Austin Meadows’ promotion and his latest stats.