A few years ago, analysts and writers nominated the Pirates and Miami Marlins as the teams with the best outfields in baseball. The Pirates had Starling Marte, Andrew McCutchen and Gregory Polanco; the Marlins, Christian Yelich, Marcell Ozuna and Giancarlo Stanton.
Now McCutchen is gone, traded to the San Francisco Giants, but two other figures in that debate found their way into the division. The Milwaukee Brewers acquired Yelich, and the St. Louis Cardinals snagged Ozuna.
The Chicago Cubs have too many outfielders as it is. Kyle Schwarber, Albert Almora Jr. and Jason Heyward will man the outfield, but for how long? Issues on defense (Schwarber) and offense (Heyward) might cut into their playing time, and Ian Happ and Ben Zobrist have to play somewhere.
The Brewers' outfield is now crowded enough, after the Yelich trade and the signing of Lorenzo Cain, that Ryan Braun is learning first base. The Pirates filled their outfield hole with Corey Dickerson, the biggest move they made that did not involve trading McCutchen or Gerrit Cole.
The Cubs entered last year's All-Star break two games worse than .500 with an even run differential — 399 for, 399 against. In the second half they went 49-25 with a plus-127 run differential. Their firepower, plus the signing of Yu Darvish, should put them atop the division again. The Brewers will challenge, just like last year, but like the Cardinals, questions about their rotation could hinder them.
The Pirates front office says the club is not rebuilding and could surprise people by contending this year. It'll take more than just production from their new outfield — Marte, Polanco and Dickerson — to get there.
Read More
1. Chicago Cubs • 2017 W-L: 92-70 • 1st
Manager: Joe Maddon (fourth season, 292-193)
Key additions: Yu Darvish, Brandon Morrow, Tyler Chatwood, Steve Cishek, Drew Smyly. Key losses: Jake Arrieta, Wade Davis, John Lackey, Alex Avila, Hector Rondon, Koji Uehara.
The number: 5.07. That's how many runs per game the Cubs scored last season. Among National League teams, only the Colorado Rockies scored more.
The player: Ian Happ. In 115 games during his rookie season, Happ, 23, hit .253/.328/.514 with 24 home runs. Happ played all three outfield positions, second base and third base. This year, the Mt. Lebanon High graduate might lead off.
The prospect: Adbert Alzolay. The 23-year-old right-hander had a 2.99 ERA in 22 starts between high-A Myrtle Beach and Class AA Tennessee last season, with a 1.10 WHIP and 8 HRs allowed in 1141/3 innings. This year is on the early side for when he could reach the majors, but he's not far off.
The skinny: Out with one ace, in with another. The Cubs decided against bringing back Arrieta, whose strikeout rate, innings pitched and velocity declined since his 2015 Cy Young season, while his ERA increased, and spent $126 million over six years on Darvish. Adding Darvish and Chatwood, who should improve after departing Coors Field, to a rotation with Jon Lester, Kyle Hendricks and Jose Quintana should nicely replace Arrieta and Lackey. They still have the souvenir entrepreneurs, Kris Bryant and Anthony Rizzo, on the corners and a talented young catcher in Willson Contreras. The questions: Can Jason Heyward and Addison Russell bounce back from down years?
2. Milwaukee Brewers • 2017 W-L: 86-76 • 2nd
Manager: Craig Counsell (fourth season, 220-241)
Key additions: Matt Albers, Lorenzo Cain, Jhoulys Chacin, Yovani Gallardo, Boone Logan, Christian Yelich. Key losses: Lewis Brinson, Matt Garza, Taylor Jungmann, Anthony Swarzak, Neil Walker.
The number: 224. That's how many home runs the Brewers hit last season, tied with the New York Mets for most in the NL.
The player: Domingo Santana. The 25-year-old right fielder had a breakout year, hitting 30 home runs to go with a .278/.371/.505 line.
The prospect: Brandon Woodruff. He made eight starts for the Brewers last season, and though the results were mediocre — 4.81 ERA in 43 innings, 6.7 K/9 — the 25-year-old righty led the minor leagues with 173 Ks in 2016. He was competing for a rotation spot this spring.
The skinny: After the Brewers finished one game out of the wild card last year, general manager David Stearns decided it was time to add. He traded Brinson, a top prospect, for Yelich and spent $80 million over five years on Cain. The duo will join Santana to form a formidable outfield. That means Ryan Braun has to play somewhere, so the plan is to work him in with Eric Thames at first base. But the upgrades did not extend to the rotation, which won't have Jimmy Nelson until at least June because of shoulder surgery. The Brewers might have to hit another 224 homers to have a shot.
3. St. Louis Cardinals • 2017 W-L: 83-79 • 3rd
Manager: Mike Matheny (seventh season, 544-428)
Key additions: Luke Gregerson, Dominic Leone, Miles Mikolas, Marcell Ozuna. Key losses: Aledmys Diaz, Zach Duke, Randal Grichuk, Lance Lynn, Juan Nicasio, Seung Hwan Oh, Stephen Piscotty, Trevor Rosenthal.
The number: 2. That's where the Cardinals ranked among NL teams in walks issued and Defensive Runs Saved. The Los Angeles Dodgers led both categories.
The player: Jose Martinez. Matheny will need to find places to play the big Venezuelan, who hit .309/.379/.518 last year in his first extended major league experience, at age 28. If Matt Carpenter can handle some time at second and third base, Martinez could see the field more often at first base.
The prospect: Alex Reyes. He dominated out of the bullpen as a rookie in 2016 and was supposed to join the rotation last season before requiring Tommy John ligament replacement surgery. Reyes could return to the Cardinals' bullpen by May.
The skinny: Despite seven key players posting an OPS+ of 109 or better last season, the Cardinals were near the league average in runs per game (4.70, league average 4.58) and tied with the league average for home runs hit with 196. That will work with solid run prevention, but who knows if that'll be the case with their rotation? Behind No. 1 Carlos Martinez, the Cardinals have Michael Wacha (4.13 ERA) and Adam Wainwright, who declined for the second consecutive year. Joining the rotation are Miles Mikolas, who returns to the majors after three productive years in Japan, and Luke Weaver, who made 10 starts and struck out 10.7 batters per nine last year. Upside and potential, but also a wide range of outcomes.
4. Pittsburgh Pirates • 2017 W-L: 75-87 • 4th
Manager: Clint Hurdle (eighth season, 584-549)
Key additions: Colin Moran, Joe Musgrove, Michael Feliz, Corey Dickerson, Kyle Crick. Key losses: Andrew McCutchen, Gerrit Cole.
The number: .386. That was the Pirates' slugging percentage last season, better than only the San Francisco Giants among the 15 NL teams.
The player: Moran. A freak facial fracture means we'll have to wait to see if the third baseman's performance in Class AAA will translate to the majors.
The prospect: Mitch Keller. The 21-year-old righty reached Class AA Altoona last season in time to help the Curve to an Eastern League title before turning in one of the best performances in the Arizona Fall League. A September callup isn't out of the question, though 2019 is more realistic.
The skinny: Team president Frank Coonelly recently borrowed from Gloucester to describe the offseason as "our winter of discontent." The Pirates traded McCutchen, a franchise icon, and Cole, then went the whole offseason without signing a major league free agent. Josh Harrison requested a trade. David Freese decried the clubhouse culture. More than 60,000 people signed a petition asking MLB to force Bob Nutting to sell, a fruitless endeavor on its face but a sign of the town's ... discontent. The roster has upside, but so much needs to go right.
5. Cincinnati Reds • 2017 W-L: 68-94 • 5th
Manager: Bryan Price (fifth season, 276-372)
Key additions: Jared Hughes, David Hernandez. Key losses: Zack Cozart, Scott Feldman, Drew Storen.
The number: 1.56. That's how many home runs per nine innings Reds pitchers allowed in 2017, the highest rate in Major League Baseball.
The player: Selecting Joey Votto is a cop-out. It's also the only choice. While playing every game last year, he hit .320/.454/.578 with 36 homers and lost the MVP to Giancarlo Stanton, 302 points to 300.
The prospect: Nick Senzel. One evaluator called Senzel, 22, the best minor leaguer he scouted last season. In 507 plate appearances between high-A and Class AA, Senzel hit .321/.391/.514 with 14 homers.
The skinny: The Reds can hit just fine. They have an above-average player at every position but shortstop, a perennial MVP candidate in Votto and a Gold Glove caliber center fielder who can steal 50 bags in Billy Hamilton. But will they ever assemble a pitching staff? Their 5.17 ERA ranked 29th out of 30 teams last year. Anthony DeSclafani will already miss opening day because of an oblique injury and Brandon Finnegan's biceps strain might keep him out as well. The projected rotation of Homer Bailey, Luis Castillo and some combination of Sal Romano, Tyler Mahle, Amir Garrett, Cody Reed, Michael Lorenzen and Robert Stephenson provides no certainty.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.