Life as a baseball fan in the age of commissioner Rob Manfred means intermittently having to discuss his office’s bad ideas for rule changes. So strap in, because this one’s a doozy.
On his show Wednesday, radio host Rich Eisen said he was told by an MLB executive that his cohort is considering eliminating the batting order in the ninth inning so that managers can send up the best hitters with the game on the line. The goal would be to inject more drama into the late stages of games.
One #MLB executive told @richeisen about an idea to improve excitement in the game by allowing managers to put anyone up to bat in the 9th inning if trailing. Good idea or crazy? pic.twitter.com/IgM6Zrofer
— Rich Eisen Show (@RichEisenShow) February 20, 2018
“Best argument is that no other sport has the best players sitting on the bench in the final minutes of a game,” Eisen quoted the anonymous executive as saying. “Imagine LeBron [James] or Tom Brady or Sidney Crosby or Ronaldo watching on the sideline.”
Eisen was quick to note that he didn’t know how far the proposal had progressed. And the change would not apply to any other innings than the ninth. None of those stipulations, however, change the fact that the proposal is bad.
The executive is correct that baseball is unique in the way its best players can often be irrelevant late in games. We’ve all been to Pirates games when the last, best hopes were the dregs of the lineups. More often than not, we’ve probably shuffled to the exits on those occasions.
It’s also true that no other sport can replicate the anticipation of, say, a cleanup guy hitting with runners on at any point in a game. Because you know he may not come up in the ninth inning, that seventh inning strikeout with the bases loaded hurts that much more. Because you know the opposing starter is tough, that early three-run homer by the five-hole hitter is a big deal.
Baseball thrives on its situational nature, and this proposed rule change would diminish that significantly. It would open baseball up to the cliche criticism of basketball that nothing in a tight game really matters until the end.
It would also rob us of moments like this.
Catcher Rod Barajas had done pretty much jack for the Pirates all season in 2012. He was (and still is) a punchline. Then, out of nowhere, he won a game against Washington with a laser to left.
Baseball also thrives on those unlikely moments. Doing away with them would cheapen the game, especially when you consider even the best hitters fail to get on base around 70 percent of the time anyway.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.