For the past few months, it’s been pretty difficult to talk about the Pirates on social media without getting shouted down angrily.
Want to discuss whether Jameson Taillon should be the latest in a series of young players to get an extension through his 30s?
“It’ll never happen. [Chairman] Bob Nutting would rather buy a new ski lift for Seven Springs.”
Want to muse about the other young guys in the rotation around Taillon who showed some promise last year?
“They’re only there because they’re inexpensive. Management is too cheap to sign any real talent.”
And, if you dared entertain the idea that the intact core of a 98-win team from two years ago might be able to contend for something in 2018 before Gerrit Cole and Andrew McCutchen were jettisoned this past week?
“Shut up, apologist. They should just trade everyone because this team is a joke.”
There exists, in Pirates orbit, a class of perma-cynics who believe it’s their duty to browbeat anyone who’d rather talk some baseball than stew, endlessly, in ownership’s (legitimate) shortcomings. They never have and never will have anything constructive to add to the conversation.
It’s been particularly easy for them following a second consecutive losing season. And it’s that cynicism that management is cravenly indulging to justify this sell-off.
The Pirates were — contrary to the the cynics’ belief — a capable baseball team with Cole and McCutchen in the fold.
Yes, it would have been hard to imagine them steamrolling their way through the National League like they did in 2015, certainly. Too many players have regressed from career years during that campaign. But there was a reasonable case to be made that the Pirates could be a 90-win team with some bounce-back years from guys such as McCutchen, Cole and Starling Marte coupled with growth from younger players such as Taillon, Gregory Polanco, Trevor Williams and Josh Bell.
That was management’s tack the last two years, at the very least. Rather than talk about openly about the end of this core being near, Neal Huntington famously called 2016 a “bridge year” and pointed out, correctly, that 2017 was a season torpedoed primarily by the knuckleheaded decisions of important pieces such as Marte and Jung Ho Kang.
It seemed like he wanted to at least try to compete moving forward.
Now, he’s saying stuff like this.
Huntington: “The reality that in Gerrit’s situation, while he’s going to be a very effective major league pitcher for the next two years, it was only going to be two more years in Pittsburgh before he tested free agency.”
— Bill Brink (@BrinkPG) January 14, 2018
And Nutting is saying stuff like:
“In a perfect world, we would love to have [McCutchen] here,” Nutting said. “As a practical matter, we need to do the right thing for the franchise at this point to bring as much talent as we possibly can to get us back into playoff contention.”
Implicit in those statements is a concession that the Pirates weren’t going to be able to do anything meaningful in those next two years, and management knows that verbalizing it makes them look like enormous hypocrites to anyone who believed a word of what they’ve been selling for the past two seasons.
They also know the loudest voices in the conversation assign the worst of intentions to this franchise. And so the moves became self-fulfilling prophecy.
None of that is to say Huntington allows public opinion to unduly influence the path he chooses for this team. If he did, the Pirates probably never would have enjoyed their McCutchen-led resurgence from 2013-15 in the first place.
That said, it was certainly a lot easier for him to make these moves in an environment that was already extremely toxic. What, really, are the consequences when so many folks have seemingly made up their minds to tune out from this team on TV or stop buying tickets at the box office regardless of whether Cole and McCutchen are here?
It’s a cowardly move to start swimming with that tide, to be sure. Nutting, Huntington and president Frank Coonelly bear responsibility for giving up on this group, for choosing the empty platitudes of “young team” and “promising future” that we’re likely to start hearing soon over the hard work and high stakes of trying to win with McCutchen and Cole, one last time, before baseball’s uber-rich were set to get a shot at them through free agency.
It would be fair to hold that against this management group forever.
But moments like this don’t happen in a vacuum. They happen in context. For the Pirates, that context is a segment of fans who don’t deserve anything more, because they bathe in their cynicism and relentlessly choose not to expect it, even when they have a competitive team right under their noses.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.