The Pirates are at a payroll disadvantage to big-market teams like the Los Angeles Dodgers. Duh.

For years, they’ve countered by bolstering their focus on analytics to find undervalued players and strategies. That paid off with three consecutive playoff berths from 2013 to ’15.

Small-market teams like them don’t own that lane anymore, though. Big markets are increasingly bringing in analytically focused management to press their resource advantages in that area, too. It’s something Pirates reliever Tony Watson told the Orange County Register he’s noticed since being dealt from Pittsburgh to Los Angeles at the trading deadline back in July.

“Just the sheer numbers as far as the bodies, the staff that is analytically-driven,” says Dodgers reliever Tony Watson who spent 6½ seasons with the analytically-open Pittsburgh Pirates before joining the Dodgers this summer. “Then I later found out it’s the largest R & D in baseball. … Coming from Pittsburgh, it’s definitely bigger. That’s the focus. And it works. The numbers don’t lie.”

The Dodgers have become the gold standard of wealthy teams that also use smarts. In 2014, they hired executive Andrew Friedman away from the Tampa Bay Rays, the team he’d built into a playoff regular despite a modest budget. Now, the president of baseball operations has Los Angeles is in its first World Series since 1988.

Advertise with us

All of which puts the Pirates’ future in some degree of doubt. Is a deficit of analytics staffing just one more obstacle they’ll have to overcome moving forward?

Maybe.

To be clear, this Dodgers team is certainly a triumph of the modern analytics movement. Yes, there are expensive stars, but guys like Kike Hernandez and Charlie Culberson are just a couple of previously anonymous players who’ve made big impacts in this postseason. That’s a tribute to the depth the Dodgers have cultivated by finding players other teams didn’t want and giving them roles in which they can succeed.

But they’ve also wasted a ton of money.

Scott Kazmir, Brandon McCarthy, Sergio Romo and Hector Olivera are just a few of the names this front office acquired for big money, only for them to play little to no role in the team’s ultimate success. Olivera never even played for the Dodgers. And many other big-market teams continue to make these big-money mistakes while enjoying far less success.

Advertise with us

On one hand, it’s quite the luxury to have tens of millions of dollars in dead money on a payroll and continue to win. On the other, it’s illustrative of the compulsion big-budget teams will always have to spend rather than innovate their way to success.

The Pirates, by their nature, still have more incentive to take risks and test theories. In the past, this has included making heavy use of shifts and finding pitchers who induce a lot of ground balls. Moving forward, it may be some other experiment that thrives in part because it’s taking place in the right environment, one that’s not overgrown with pricey veterans but instead leaves room in the lineup or pitching staff for a rehabilitation project or two.

In short, the Pirates remain a good laboratory, and they have no shortage of smart people practicing the science of baseball. Dan Fox, the man who’s been at the center of the team’s analytics plays in the past decade, remains in place as director of baseball informatics. And pitching coach Ray Searage remains one of the most respected men in his field.

This is no guarantee the Pirates will return to the playoffs anytime soon. And it’s still probably a net negative that they’re seeing increasingly well-financed competitors join them in the analytics space.

But the fact remains that if resources alone were enough to get big-market teams where they want to go, they never would have felt compelled to turn to analytics in the first place.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter, @fugimaster24.