Welcome back, baseball fans. The last week of the regular season is here. The Pirates (71-85) host the Baltimore Orioles for two games before traveling to Washington, D.C., for four games against the Washington Nationals. These questions are sic’d. If you have a question for next week’s mailbag, send it to snesbitt@post-gazette.com or to @stephenjnesbitt on Twitter.

Here we go.

Nick: Should Pirate fans be alarmed that their 1B of the future ranked amongst the bottom of NL 1B in WAR?

Stephen: Good question, Nick. There’s truth to it, but also some discrepancy to clarify. So let’s get a little inside baseball. There are several versions of WAR (Wins Above Replacement). Among the most common are bWAR (Baseball Reference), fWAR (Fangraphs) and WARP (Baseball Prospectus). They grade on slightly different scales and all feel a bit differently about Bell.

Advertise with us

All three are good resources. While trying to keep this interesting to the average reader, I’ll run the risk of oversimplifying and say bWAR, rooted in runs scored, is, in my opinion gathered from three years as a big-league baseball beat writer, the best indicator of what happened. fWAR, based on FIP (Fielding Independent Pitching) explains what could or should have happened.

Nick’s email included a link to the Fangraphs fWAR rankings for first basemen. You’ll find Josh Bell near the bottom (0.4 fWAR), only one spot ahead of teammate John Jaso (0.3 fWAR). If you watched the Pirates this season, you’re probably surprised to see those two so closely bunched.

If you trot over to bWAR rankings, there is a slightly different story. Bell (1.4 bWAR) is closer to the middle of the pack of National League first basemen, trailing veterans Joey Votto (7.0), Paul Goldschmidt (6.1), Anthony Rizzo (4.5), Freddie Freeman (4.4), Matt Carpenter (3.0), Brandon Belt (2.9), Wil Myers (2.1) and Philadelphia Phillies rookie phenom Rhys Hoskins (2.1). Those behind Bell include Eric Thames (1.2), Lucas Duda (1.0), Adam Lind (1.0) and Matt Adams (0.5).

Take from that what you will. In their first full seasons in the majors, Goldschmidt, Votto and Rizzo posted bWARS of 3.4, 3.3 and 2.8, respectively. Freeman had a 1.5 bWAR as a rookie, almost identical to Bell, but was 21 years old. Bell just turned 25. So he may not currently be on the same trajectory as that group, but I don’t think that necessarily means fans should be alarmed.

For five months this season, Bell was one of the Pirates’ only bright spots. Through Sept. 4, he had a .264/.343/.495 batting line with a .837 OPS — second on the team to Andrew McCutchen — 24 home runs and 82 RBIs. He also had 57 walks to 93 strikeouts, nowhere close to the more-walks-than-whiffs ratio he posted last season, but still a healthy boon for the OBP.

Advertise with us

But in the past three weeks, Bell went 8 for 58 (.138) with a double and an RBI, plus six walks to 18 strikeouts.

After an August in which Bell batted .323 with a .954 OPS with 11 extra-base hits, 21 RBIs and 15 walks to 10 strikeouts in 28 games, 25 starts, this isn’t the September he hoped for. With the team completely out of playoff contention and his offensive numbers cratering, Bell is searching for some answers with his swing. But at least the Pirates aren’t still searching for an answer at first base. As I wrote about earlier this week, the Pirates clearly haven’t had continuity at first base in the past decade, and Bell represents stability. In his first full season with the Pirates, he had ups and downs and, it seemed, little in between. But I don’t believe that is reason to panic. There are greater concerns with this ballclub. With his patience at the plate, Bell should be able to become a consistent offensive force, and his defense is fine. It needn’t be more than that.

David: Do you think that Glasnow will ever be able to develop into a number three or four starter in Pittsburgh? Or would a change of scenery be best for him?

Stephen: Tyler Glasnow’s future has become harder and harder to forecast. He *should* fit in the middle of a Major League rotation, and has upside for far more than that. But what he’s shown so far with the Pirates is an inability to keep things together. At first, command was an issue. Then he started finding the plate but was doing so with subpar stuff, a low-90s fastball with no movement and mediocre off-speed pitches. When he returned to the majors, the pitches popped again but his command is missing. In his last outing, he walked four of six batters.

Still, it also feels absurd to stand here today and say a 24-year-old, 6-foot-8 right-hander with near-triple-digits velocity, supreme athleticism and a remarkable track record in the minors will never figure it out and seal a spot in the rotation. In the majors, he seems shaken on the mound. It appears there are mental hurdles he needs to work out. But what? And when? And how long?

Advertise with us

So, David, I think the odds are Glasnow will develop into a No. 3 or 4 starter one day. But we’ve seen this year why he may not. I don’t expect the Pirates will bail on him anytime soon. He’s inexpensive and his ceiling is above the clouds. If general manager Neal Huntington sold low on Glasnow this offseason, say, and he panned out somewhere else …

Oh boy.

NG-USA: Signing Neil Walker fixes 3 positions (2B, 3B, RF?). Any chance he even gets a look?

Stephen: I do not expect the Pirates will seriously pursue Walker, but they may take a look. Walker, who accepted a qualifying offer for $17.2 million last offseason, has had a nice season, posting a .806 OPS with 14 homers and 49 RBIs between New York and Milwaukee. He’ll be a free agent this fall and certainly won’t find that salary again, but he’ll still be paid well. Unless the Pirates trade Josh Harrison and/or Andrew McCutchen, they don’t have many open spots. Even if Jung Ho Kang does not return, whomever the Pirates pick to share time at third base with David Freese will probably be an internal option or a cheaper one than Walker.

Baseball1727: What is the Pirates record sense Huntington and Hurdle contract extension announced? Apoears to have energized the club.

Advertise with us

Stephen: Since Sept. 5, the Pirates are 5-13.

Stephen: So I'm watching the 79 pirates dvd and I notice that many of pirates hitters did 2 things, 1- they choked up on their bats (Foli especially) 2- they batted somewhat hunched over. Any idea as to why, and why nobody does this anymore? They had 10 hits or more in all 7 games, 5 players had 10 or more hits and 1 more had 9. Many of the pirates problems are related to the fact that we cant hit very well. Just curious on your take.

Stephen: Baseball looks very different than it did even a few decades ago. You’re right, of course, old footage shows pitchers with funky deliveries and batters with even funkier stances. As for why batters now don’t hunch over, they’re simply not taught that way any more. I’m not sure why they used to stand that way — it doesn’t seem altogether comfortable — but they apparently saw the ball all right. Hitters now are asked to take a relaxed stance where they can see the pitch well out of the pitcher’s hand, plant their front foot and take a rip. But nobody really hunches over. Maybe one day I’ll dig down and find out why and when that stopped (or started). As for the second observation, manager Clint Hurdle discussed earlier this season how hitters no longer choke up on the bat. Among the only players you can see doing so regularly are Votto and Rizzo. Any coincidence they’re among the best first basemen in baseball? Hurdle thinks players are too focused on home runs and are still selling out, even with two strikes, rather than adopting a two-strike approach in which they choke up and focus on putting the ball in play.

Patricia: Should I even bother getting attached to players or will we always lose them because we refuse to pay them fairly?

Stephen: As a fan of the beautiful game of baseball, I highly recommend getting attached to ballplayers. The game is no fun otherwise. Growing up in Michigan, I followed the Detroit Tigers and had favorites. The team was awful. But being a fan was always a fun feeling. Even if you dislike the ownership, you can usually find a few guys who you can tell desperately want to win.

Advertise with us

Tom: Hey Stephen, any chance the Pirates have voted in regards to a "stance" regarding the National Anthem? Just #inquiring

Stephen: As far as I know, there has been no such vote among the players. I reached out to a Pirates spokesperson Sunday asking for a comment from owner Bob Nutting or president Frank Coonelly regarding whether the Pirates would back their players should one or more choose to protest during the national anthem. The reply, in the form of a statement from Coonelly, was, “The Pittsburgh Pirates respect and appreciate the individual opinions of our players. As an organization, we respect the American sacrifice and national unity that are routinely displayed at our games. We stand just as strongly for the fundamental principles of equality, diversity and inclusion.”

Bob: If you can't afford the team, sell it!!!

Stephen: In no way can I afford it.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: snesbitt@post-gazette.com and Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.