MILWAUKEE — First, it was one pitch. Then, one inning. Not much went wrong for Gerrit Cole Tuesday night, but enough bad results in the wrong order made the difference.
Cole allowed five runs in six innings in a 5-2 loss against the Milwaukee Brewers at Miller Park. He also struck out 10, the second time this season he struck out 10 Brewers in a game. The damage came in the second inning, on Eric Thames’ solo home run, and in a four-run third.
Cole had alternated good and bad starts entering Tuesday. The final pitch he threw Aug . 21 against the Los Angeles Dodgers — a grand slam to Curtis Granderson — represented the majority of his final line, five runs and eight hits in 6⅓ innings. He then shut out the Cincinnati Reds for seven innings and hit a solo homer for a 1-0 victory.
Against those same Reds the following week, he allowed five runs, six hits and three walks in six innings. Then, Wednesday against the Chicago Cubs, he pitched eight scoreless innings, allowing two hits and striking out eight.
“For me, there’s been significant major league growth this year,” manager Clint Hurdle said of Cole. “It’s not just growth and getting innings, it’s been pitching quality games, going through lineups three times, sometimes four, getting big outs. That part of it’s been fun to watch.”
In none of his previous three outings did Cole allow a home run, which has been a problem for him this season. Only five National League starters had given up more than the 27 home runs Cole had allowed this season before Tuesday. Eight of them came in a three-start span in late May and early June, when every mistake left the playing field.
Read More
“He didn’t overcook it,” Hurdle said. “It wasn’t because of this, it wasn’t because of that. It was, you know what, I made some mistakes up in the zone, seemed to be in a spot where every time I make a mistake, somebody’s riding it out of the ballpark. Whether it’s launch angles, whether it’s the ball, who knows. We’ve seen it all over, all over the game.”
The streak ended in the second inning. Cole worked an 0-2 count on Thames, then threw the left-hander a fastball at the top of the zone and outside. Thames still managed to pull it over the right-field wall.
“Threw him an up-and-in fastball, got it by him,” Cole said. “Froze him on the second one in. Tried to go up and away, kind of expand the plate, and he just wasn’t going to get beat on it again. He put a good swing on it.”
The trouble Cole found himself in in the third was quieter, but more dangerous.
He allowed consecutive singles to Keon Broxton and Brett Phillips before walking Eric Sogard to load the bases with nobody out. An outside curveball floated close enough to the edge to earn a called strike three on Neil Walker. Ryan Braun grounded into a fielder’s choice that scored a run, but Cole had a chance to escape with only that run allowed.
Braun stole second, opening first base. Cole intentionally walked left-handed batter Travis Shaw, who has two home runs against Cole to his name, to pitch to right-handed-hitting Domingo Santana with the bases loaded. No matter for Milwaukee; Santana hit a two-run double, and Thames singled to bring home another run.
“I just wasn’t quite as sharp that inning as I was in the other innings,” Cole said. “They smelled blood in the water, and I just kind of maybe counting on my opponent I guess in that situation to try to get us a break, but it just didn’t happen.”
The Pirates scored twice against Brewers starter Brent Suter in his third and final inning. He had made one start since coming off the disabled list and hadn’t thrown more than 43 pitches in a month, so the Brewers bullpen completed the final six innings with six different pitchers. The bullpen allowed no runs and three hits and struck out eight.
“Johnny Wholestaff is pretty dirty,” Cole said. “Different looks every inning, that’s tough to deal with.”
Bill Brink: bbrink@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrinkPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.