Welcome back, baseball fans. The Pirates dropped their series opener Monday at Wrigley Field, their 69th loss this season, and sit six games under .500. They face the Chicago Cubs’ Jake Arrieta and Jose Quintana the next two days. All questions are sic’d. If you have a question for next week’s mailbag, send it to snesbitt@post-gazette.com or to @stephenjnesbitt on Twitter.
Here we go.
Jake: Do you think we will ever see the “dream outfield” of Marte, Cutch, Polanco ever play 150+ games again similar to 2015?
Stephen: Good day to you, Jake, and good question. They may only have one more crack at it, if that, so the odds are not entirely in their favor. Two years ago, in the halcyon days of 2015, Andrew McCutchen played in 157 games while Starling Marte and Gregory Polanco appeared in 153 games apiece. McCutchen, now in his eighth full season in the majors, has hit the 150-game mark every year but 2014, when his only trip to the disabled list cut him to 146 games. He is on pace for 157 games played this season, but Marte and Polanco will fall well short. Marte (suspension) has appeared in 51 games this season; Polanco (hamstring) has appeared in 91.
The Pirates aren’t half bad when their outfield is together. That’s not to say a full season of Marte-McCutchen-Polanco is the difference between first place and fourth, but they clearly have been hurt by their inability to keep the band together in the outfield. With the season now 132 games old, McCutchen, Marte and Polanco have started together only 22 times. The Pirates are 13-9 in those games. Subtract the times when one of the outfielders was designated hitter and you’re left with 18 games (11-7 record) — eight games pre-suspension and 10 post-suspension.
Polanco’s health is a considerable concern. He’s been hamstrung by left hamstring strains this season, going to the disabled list in April, going back in July and going back again in August. Assuming Marte is not suspended for steroids again next season, and assuming McCutchen is not traded in the offseason, the 150-game “dream outfield” depends largely on Polanco in 2018.
Read More
McCutchen is unlikely to be in Pittsburgh beyond next season. He’ll play for $14.5 million in 2018 and walk into free agency and its riches. The Pirates schedule occasional off days for their players — McCutchen, however, rarely rests — and all it takes to drop a player below the 150-game mark is one DL-worthy injury. I reckon you won’t see 150-plus again from these three.
John: Since this year appears to be over (barring two series sweeps versus the Cubs), what is the rotation for next year? What will the Pirates do with all of those arms in AAA who likely won’t make the majors rotation? Is someone like Brault trade worthy?
Stephen: Gerrit Cole, Ivan Nova, Jameson Taillon, Tyler Glasnow and Trevor Williams/Chad Kuhl.
That’s my guess. The first three are rather obvious, unless Cole is traded, which would change the conversation. I wrote earlier this week about the decisions general manager Neal Huntington must make here regarding his starting-pitching depth. There was some blowback, readers pointing out that the Pirates starters are running up high ERAs and scoffing at depth, as it hasn’t helped. That wasn’t the point. Yes, the starters have taken steps backward. On the whole, they haven’t been good enough. But this discussion is about what to do with the next wave. There’s not room for them, and there’s little left for them to prove in the minors. At some point, the Pirates need to give Glasnow, Steven Brault and Nick Kingham long looks in the majors.
Glasnow, of course, had his look. He bombed. I pencil him into the opening-day rotation anyway because the Pirates will give him every chance to become the pitcher they believe he’ll be. He seems better-equipped now to defeat Major League hitters than he was earlier this season, adding zip to his fastball and easing his delivery. We’ll see in September whether that is the case. And where Glasnow projects best as a starter, either Williams or Kuhl could be a fit in the bullpen. Williams started the season there, taking over a rotation spot when Taillon went on the disabled list in May. Kuhl’s velocity surge this season makes you wonder how he’d look in the later innings, throwing energy-conservation to the wind as he pumps gas for one inning, not seven.
Brault shined this season at Class AAA Indianapolis, turning in a 1.94 ERA. Given the number of options the Pirates have should a starting spot open, for now Brault’s best chance to stick in the majors probably is as a lefty long reliever, taking over the role Wade LeBlanc played this season. He is trade-able, sure, but I’m not sure he’ll fetch much value before he makes a mark in the majors.
Kingham is out of options. The Pirates could trade him or try him in the bullpen. He still has promise, but it’s not likely he’d beat out Williams, Kuhl, Glasnow and Brault for a rotation spot.
The Pirates just haven’t used their starting depth this year. In 2015, they used seven starters — the only Class AAA call-up was Casey Sadler, who made an early-season spot start when Francisco Liriano was on paternity leave. In 2016, the Pirates used 14 starting pitchers. In 2017, no team has used fewer starters than the Pirates (six). They are on track for a club record in that category. They used seven starting pitchers in 1902, 1972 and 1997.
Because starters are so valuable, teams aren’t quick to shift prospects to the bullpen. But there comes a time when that’s the only way to fit them in the majors. Perhaps the Pirates are there.

Pete: As much as I want the Pirates to sign Cutch for the remainder of his career, I realize that it’s almost certain that they’re not going to do that, and I understand why. He’s having a great year now, but he’ll start declining soon and then they’ll be paying a sub-par player a boat load of money. So Austin Meadows is going to be the next guy up, right? Some time next year probably. Do the Pirates have any concern about his ability to stay healthy and provide an every day impact? If they don’t, should they? He’s had two relatively significant hamstring injuries, and just missed a couple of games from an oblique thing. Am I looking into this too much, or is there a chance he’s the next Jose Tabata?
Stephen: There surely is concern about Meadows’ health. No doubt. Meadows, for all his potential, has played 87 and 81 games, respectively, the past two seasons. The only year he put together a full workload was 2015, when he appeared in 143 games between Class A, Class AA and the Arizona Fall League. The Pirates are discussing with Meadows the possibility of playing winter ball to help make up for the games he missed this season. He’s only 22. He won’t be 23 until May. He still could become a solid and suitable replacement for McCutchen, but for now he has to show he’s not constantly at risk of injury. He has yet to do so.
Tom: This hamstring epidemic, do you wear a protective mask when interviewing Bucs players,do you sanitize?pulled hammy could goof up a #wedding
Stephen: Good looking out, Tom. I think the air in the clubhouse is clean, but I’ve started stretching my quads and hammies before I step into that danger zone. So far, so good.
Patricia: Why do we still have “ball girls?” These women can play the game just like any man. Why not “ball people” and let men do it?
Stephen: I’m not sure why it’s limited to women, Patricia, but they sure can pick it when baseballs come barreling down the line. Talk about a position where every error stands out. Here, by the way, is the lineup for the “Pirates Ball Girls”. They are experienced, a group consisting of “14 local college student-athletes who excel in the knowledge of the game of baseball and have the personality to be ambassadors to our fans,” according to that page.
Pirates Breakdown did a cool story last fall about Suzie Cool.
And you may remember Olivia making a highlight snag last year.
#THIS. Glove optional.https://t.co/2dyJNFOIiw
— MLB (@MLB) June 21, 2016
This 2016 application page lists prior baseball or softball experience as a requirement. It does not list a specific gender as a requirement. It includes an equal-opportunity-employment statement which states any qualified applicant will be considered “without regard to race, color, religion, gender, national origin, disability status, protected veteran status or any other characteristic protected by law,” so I suppose anyone 18 or older may apply to be a Ball Girl.
Eric: Greetings from San Diego. Love your work! You’ve likely answered this before (apologies if I missed it) but does this season count as one with respect to Kangs 4-year deal? In other words, does he have 2 or 3 years left?
Stephen: Greetings from Pittsburgh, Eric. Yes, this counts as one year of his contract. A wasted year in every respect. Should Jung Ho Kang gain entry into the United States before next season, he will make $3 million in 2018 and have a $5.5 million club option remaining for 2019, per the agreement signed in 2015. If he doesn’t get visa approval, however, he won’t receive a cent.
Jason: Is there any real hope that next year will be better than 2016 and 2017?
Stephen: This is baseball. Hope springs eternal each spring.
The Pirates aren’t set to lose much in free agency this fall — John Jaso, Juan Nicasio, Joaquin Benoit — so if no one were traded away and no one were acquired, you’re looking at this opening-day alignment:
C - Francisco Cervelli
1B - Josh Bell
2B - Josh Harrison
SS - Jordy Mercer
3B - Jung Ho Kang/David Freese
LF - Starling Marte
CF - Andrew McCutchen
RF - Gregory Polanco
Bench: Adam Frazier, Sean Rodriguez, Jose Osuna, Chris Stewart/Elias Diaz, TBD.
Looks ... familiar.
The rotation keeps its pieces. The bullpen will have some turnover. You’re basically looking at the same team, though, just a year older. You may hope these players will simply stay healthier and improve. You may also hope the front office adds in the offseason to strengthen the club. Either way, come spring training, the Pirates, like 29 other teams, will like their chances.
Stephen J. Nesbitt: snesbitt@post-gazette.com and Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.