Welcome back, baseball fans. Last night, the Pirates (55-57) pitching staff, led by Trevor Williams, delivered its first one-hitter win since 2013. With 50 games left, they remain 4½ games behind the first-place Chicago Cubs. All questions are sic’d. If you have a question for next week’s mailbag, send it to snesbitt@post-gazette.com or to @stephenjnesbitt on Twitter.

Here we go.

Joe: Are the Pirates going to exercise their McCutchen option in the offseason? If so, are they trading him?

Douglas: Do you feel the Pirates will pick up Cutch's option next year or will we see his exit through a trade? I would think I'm not the only pirate fan that would like to see him extended through the duration of his career. What would that cost the organization and in your opinion would that benefit the club long term?

Advertise with us

Stephen: If I accomplish only one thing today, Joe and Douglas, it will be to assuage your concerns about Andrew McCutchen’s option year. I won’t leave here without you feeling better. I expect you won’t either. So here it is, in plain English. The Pirates have not yet discussed with McCutchen’s agent whether they will exercise his $14.5 million club option for 2018. That is normal, as it is August. But rest assured there’s a million percent chance it’ll be picked up.

Honestly, it’s a little ludicrous anyone is worried about the matter. McCutchen has a .291/.385/.519 slash line, 22 home runs, 69 RBIs and a .904 OPS after 112 games. Since he sat for two games in Atlanta in late May and then moved to the six-spot in the batting order, McCutchen is batting .359 with a 1.104 OPS. He was awful through 49 games, unstoppable for the next 65.

So the question is not whether he’s worth the $14.5 million. He’s worth more. But McCutchen’s camp agreed to a contract in 2012 that guaranteed him $51.5 million and allowed the Pirates to decide whether to keep him for 2018. Players, almost without exception, discover whether their options will be picked up once the season has concluded. What does it benefit the Pirates to guarantee an option to McCutchen today and run the risk of being on the hook for the full salary even in the event he blows both knees and both elbows in a center-field collision in late September? That’s not how clubs operate. They’ll announce the option when they pick it up.

The other thing you shouldn’t be wondering is whether McCutchen is bothered by this. Unequivocally, no. Until local media started to poke around about whether they’d told him his option would be exercised, no one was talking about it, and with good reason. McCutchen wasn’t expecting an early promise. He knows how this works. He wants to get paid, and he will. He’s played out of his mind these past few months. He’ll get his $14.5 million next year.

Once the option dilemma is over — and there truly will be no drama in that discussion; it’s a slam-dunk decision — then, yes, we may be barreling toward another offseason of trade speculation. General manager Neal Huntington could nip it immediately by saying the Pirates don’t intend to move McCutchen, but that’s not his M.O. In all likelihood, he’ll say the realities of the market make it such that it is smart to be willing to listen to trade offers on any player. And he’s right. For the sake of making his and McCutchen’s lives easier, though, perhaps this time if Huntington is not expecting to trade the face of the franchise he will take an early stance to squash speculation.

Advertise with us

Trading McCutchen makes sense because he’ll command a high return that can reload the farm system while potentially keeping the Pirates competitive. Trading McCutchen doesn’t make sense because the 2018 roster already looks strong and there’s no one available who can replicate his current level of production. They may trade him. They may not. This far out from the winter meetings, I’ll hazard the educated opinion that McCutchen will not be traded this offseason. Maybe next July.

A trade, however, is a far more realistic outcome than a contract extension. You would be better off scratching that off your wish list. Shortly after the 2018 season ends, McCutchen will turn 32. He’ll rank among the best hitters in Pirates history. But their extension offers, if there are any, are unlikely to extend into the five- and six-year range. I have had four years and $80 million floated past me this season. That’s not going to cut it. With McCutchen close enough to free agency to start to sniff it, he understands his value on the open market. Someone will pay him far more and for far longer than will the Pirates. This is the reality of free agency. The Pirates were wise to extend McCutchen early in his career. He played his prime in black and gold. But if another extension was ever going to get done, which it wasn’t, it would have been two years ago.

Nick: What do your reporting instincts tell you about possibility Kang never plays for #pirates again now with Rodriguez back with the club?

Stephen: My sense is it is more likely than not that Jung Ho Kang will not play in the major leagues again. The Pirates have attempted multiple times to secure him a United States visa and failed. They will continue to try, but for what reason would a three-time DUI offender be denied entry into the country this year and then suddenly granted entry the next?

I don’t think the Sean Rodriguez trade was a nail in the coffin. I think that was already there.

Advertise with us

Lee He Ho: Thought they should have signed a rod instead of freeze last year...what about you? You are the best sports writer in pgh.

Stephen: Your kindness and comedy warm my heart, good Lee He Ho. Alex Rodriguez claims to have retired from baseball. The Freeze would be an upgrade in the base-running department.

(I’m not sure Sean Rodriguez would have agreed to the two-year, $11 million deal David Freese did last fall because he was looking to go somewhere, like Atlanta, where he might play every day. He also wanted to know what a big offensive season would fetch him in free agency. The answer, in the end, was two years and $11.5 million and, eventually, another stay on the Pirates bench.)

Douglas: Is Pirates management about putting the best team on the field to win now or do they just win enough games to just be average? Seems like keeping Diaz down in AAA after showing that he is solid behind the dish and also coming up with some key ABs at the plate, optioning the kid from Lithuania after several good appearances, not recalling Glasnow after he seems like he has put it back together and not giving Meadows a shot in the outfield even though we have played with 2 almost all year shows (in my opinion) that they really don't want to win with the guys they have in the system. Please enlighten me on this.

Stephen: I must throw cold water on this prospect worship, Douglas. Elias Diaz is in the minors because he’s not better than Francisco Cervelli and Chris Stewart is a better backup — not at the plate, perhaps, but he’s solid behind the dish and has history with the pitching staff. Diaz will stick in the majors once Stewart’s contract ends. But let’s also try to reframe our first impressions here. After Diaz batted .382 through 14 games this season, he hit .178 with a .396 OPS for almost a full month before he was sent down. He’s a .259 career hitter in the minors. He is no savior for the ball club this season. Dovydas Neverauskas should be in the bullpen next year. He also is raw and will get knocked around from time to time. Tyler Glasnow was an absolute disaster at times earlier this season. He will get another chance, but please do not pretend the insane Class AAA numbers are entirely indicative of how he’ll fare in the majors. We’ve gone over this before. Austin Meadows has an OPS starting with a six at Class AAA Indianapolis this season and suffered a hamstring injury for the second year in a row. Not only was he not ready to contribute, he was not able to. I pray you have been enlightened.

Advertise with us


Josh Bell and Ivan Nova douse Sean Rodriguez. (Matt Freed / Post-Gazette)

Cameron: Did the @Pirates purposely use Powerade coolers in order to keep the Gatorade coolers safe? #GatoradeCoolersMatter

Pens Fan-E: They retired the Gatorade cooler?

Stephen: They signed Powerade as a sponsor, thus the blue coolers.

HEB_from_tampa: Thanks for responding Mr. Nesbitt, I really enjoy your mailbag. I have a question/suggestion for our favorite baseball team. 45-50 years ago when Bob Prince was the broadcaster he had what he called "the green weenie". He would wave it at appropriate times during a game and the fans would really get involved, a lot like the terrible towel. I was kid then and really liked it and back then I swore it worked and I think we could use something like that again to get the fans into the game or to start a rally. Your thoughs?

Advertise with us

Stephen: Absolutely. If Greg Brown and Steve Blass aren’t holding weenies or towels or rally animals by the end of the road trip this week, color me disappointed. There’s nothing better than silly superstitions.

Tim: Your comment about not seeing a left handed thrower on the left side of the infield since T-ball reminded me of a time 7-8 years ago when I was managing my sons team in a 14-15 year olds’ league and we played a team whose entire infield other than the first baseman threw left handed. But that’s not a question. This is. If the Pirates bring McCutchen back next year and Polanco and Marte are both around, what becomes of Meadows? Does he stay in the minors to get at bats or become a bench guy on Pittsburgh? Trading him appears out of the question, right?

Stephen: McCutchen will only be back for one season, so the plan probably will be to keep grooming Meadows at Class AAA to be ready to take over after the 2018 trade deadline, if McCutchen is moved, or in 2019 should McCutchen depart in free agency. Trading Meadows now makes little sense since he’s at a low point in his value. Why sell so low? He’s still only 22 years old, so the day when he shifts lanes and becomes a bench player is well down the road.

JimmyV: Who woulda thunk Trevor Williams would turn out to be THE stud prospect in the rotation???

Stephen: Who indeed.

Advertise with us

Stephen J. Nesbitt: snesbitt@post-gazette.com and Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.