Starter Jose Quintana has been traded, and not to the Pirates. That’s bummer enough for the many fans and observers who thought the now-former White Sox ace was a solid trade option regardless of the cost in prospects, what with an affordable long-term contract and consistently solid performance before this season.
That he went to the NL Central division foe Chicago Cubs in exchange for prospects Thursday, however, is perhaps the most deflating development of a season that feels like it’s slipping away before the Pirates have even started their post-All-Star break schedule.
The standings say the they’re still in contention in the division. With suspended outfielder Starling Marte set to rejoin the team soon, they’re seven games back of the surprise Milwaukee Brewers but just 1.5 behind a Cubs team most still see as the favorite despite a 43-45 start to their World Series title defense.
The Quintana deal says something else. It says the Cubs are more invested in winning the Central than are the Pirates, who’ve been linked to Quintana since the offseason. And that calls the Pirates’ direction into question.
It would be one thing if the Pirates were unwilling to pay the price to acquire Quintana. Prospects are valuable commodities for small-market teams, and one can make a reasonable value judgement that whatever the White Sox were seeking was worth more than what the Pirates would be acquiring. Better to let him end up with, say, an American League team than overpay.
It’s another matter entirely to be unwilling to pay the price to acquire him and keep him away from the Cubs, who now have Quintana locked up at a bargain price with team options through 2020. At that point, the disadvantage of missing out on him is compounded enormously because he’ll be competing against the Pirates directly.
Read More
To be fair, Quintana moves across town with his share of issues. His ERA ballooned to 4.49 this season from 3.20 a year ago with the White Sox in large part because he’s allowing a ton of walks — 3.5 per nine innings compared to a career rate of 2.4. Perhaps the Pirates didn’t want to risk moving major assets for a 28-year-old who may have already peaked.
At the same time, we’re talking about a Pirates team that has a track record of turning around older pitchers with less pedigree than the 28-year-old Quintana. One, Ivan Nova, is arguably the most valuable pitcher in the Pirates’ rotation. It’s hard to imagine Quintana would have struggled for long under the tutelage of pitching coach Ray Searage.
Imagining is all anyone’s going to do now, though, as attention turns to the July 31 trading deadline and the Pirates’ strategy with starter Gerrit Cole.
The White Sox acquired a boatload of talent in exchange for Quintana. The haul included Eloy Jimenez, an outfield prospect ranked No. 8 in all of baseball by MLB.com.
If that’s the market for veteran starting pitching, and the Pirates believe the Quintana deal hurts their chances not only this year but through the remainder of Cole’s two years of arbitration eligibility, it’s fair to wonder whether they’ll move him. Cole, a Scott Boras client, is likely to get a big payday to leave the Pirates in free agency, so better to get something for him now than keep him end up with nothing. Or so the thinking goes.
Sure, it would make the Pirates less competitive for the next two years in which the figure to have the core of a decent team intact, but so does letting Quintana end up with the Cubs. We’re already a ways down that road. At this point, perhaps there’s more value in stocking the minors with elite talent with an eye toward competing in 2020 and beyond.
The two weeks and change before July 31 probably will go a long way toward shaping that strategy. If the Pirates pass the Cubs and/or make up serious ground on the Brewers before then, they may opt to give Cole and outfielder Andrew McCutchen another lap in black and gold in hopes of winning the division. This year, 85 wins may be enough.
If not, the unwillingness to trade for Quintana suggests anything is possible — that this team’s direction is more uncertain now than it’s been since they were building toward their three-year playoff run from 2013-15 that ended a streak of 20 consecutive losing seasons.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter, @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.