Bill Brink: Good afternoon and welcome to this week's Pirates chat, from the heart of downtown Philly. Sorry for the delay, I took a wrong turn walking to a coffee shop. I know you all wanted to know that. Thanks for the questions and keep them coming. Here we go ...
Chuck: After a game earlier this season, David Freese mentioned that he thought Adam Frazier would one day win a batting title. At the time, Frazier was hitting north of .360 and Pirate broadcasters were calling him a hitting machine. Since that time, Frazier's average has been steadily falling and he is now hitting .268 after going hitless yesterday. What caused this decline? Did Freese jinx Frazier? Did pitchers learn how to pitch to Frazier? Did the batting coach try to tweak Frazier's swing? Is Frazier fatigued? How do you explain the steep decline in Frazier's batting average?
Bill Brink: That high average early was driven in part by a .341 batting average on balls in play in April and a .339 May mark. It since regressed to .272. His career mark is .321, so .339 and .341 were not that out of the question, but it was bound to come down somewhat. The strikeouts are up -- 14 in June after 16 in April and May combined.
Bill Brink: He's also seeing fewer fastballs this year than last, and I bet that picked up midway through May.
David in LA: Will the Pirates be a factor in the NL Central race with Marte coming back and Cutch putting up, for now, astronomical numbers? Three things to consider: They can't score any runs, their starting rotation is off and on, and Kang probably won't be back this season.
Bill Brink: Three excellent points. The questions that must be asked: Are the Brewers a legit contender? Maybe. Losing Chase Anderson hurt. Do the Cubs figure it out? You'd think so, but more than half the season is in the books. Can Williams and Kuhl continue to pitch solidly and Cole returns to form?
Read More
Bill Brink: You have to assume nothing from Kang. Marte should come back and play well and McCutchen, while he won't hit .400 from here on out, is showing no signs of slowing down. They can contend, but they need more to go right than has gone right so far.
Jimin VT: Is there any reason to consider it even remotely possible that this mgmt. team/ownership would consider negotiating an extensionw ith Cutch?
Bill Brink: No. He'll be 32 when he begins his next contract, and the Pirates won't want to pay for what likely will be his decline years. Recent contracts for outfielders (five and $90 mil for Hunter Pence, six and $85.5 for Adam Jones, seven and $153 for Jacoby Ellsbury) makes it likely that McCutchen will get much more than the Pirates will be comfortable offering elsewhere -- unless he takes a hometown discount and the Pirates break their own rules and make a "face of the franchise" overpay.
Bill: At what point does NH start to get some blame for the bullpen and bench? I know Marte/Kang issues hurt their depth but outside of Marinez and trying Santana at MLB level, he has done nothing to address the weakness of the bullpen. Middle relief help shouldnt cost a ton and may even have the answer in his own minor leagues (Schugel) or even try a guy like Kuhl in the pen. Just seems like keeping status quo on the pen and bench is the wrong option to me.
Bill Brink: The lack of a true fourth outfielder on the bench jumped out at me even before Marte's suspension (remember, he and Polanco have missed games here and there for back/knee/shoulder/hamstring dings and dents) and the suspension really exacerbated the issue. Hudson and Watson not performing to expectations hurt their plan, but once that was clear, you're right, something could have been done. I see the argument for Kuhl in the bullpen (let it eat at 98 with a wipeout slider for an inning or two) but I don't think they'll want to pull the plug on a starter who is making strides in the majors at age 24. They've got options internally, and maybe going to them sooner would have helped.
PhillyJake: Did you go to Pat's or Geno's?
Bill Brink: Been to both before so not making the trip this time. Another reporter told me to check out Amada for some tapas, so I might do that for lunch tomorrow.
PhillyJake: This is where you want to go, BTW: http://www.johnsroastpork.com/
Bill Brink: Many thanks!
Cutch: Why no BP yesterday on field?
Bill Brink: Day game after a night game, most likely. They do that from time to time.
Austin: What do you see the future of the pirates as? I understand they're still in contention but the team isn't what was expected. Things happen like the Marte suspension and Kang issue, but with cutchs contract expiring and the supposed interest in Cole do you see the team kicking the fan down the road and trade those guys for younger assets or do you think they are going to look to run this back next year maybe minus a couple players?
Bill Brink: There's a compelling argument to be made for contention next year -- if they keep Cole, which I think they do. Full year of Marte, full year of Taillon, progression from Bell, maybe Polanco gets it going, Cervelli and Diaz behind the plate, Rivero closing from Day 1. Cole, Nova, Taillon in the rotation followed by Kuhl/Williams/Brault/Glasnow/Kingham, and you figure two of those five can step forward. Even if they trade McCutchen, they have Austin Meadows on the way. If they trade Cole, though, I don't see it.
Bill Brink: What other questions do we have today?
szweed: when if ever do they cut ties with kang...
Bill Brink: I don't think they need to just yet. He's not costing them anything on the restricted list and he's not earning service time. They could do so to make a point, the "this organization doesn't tolerate this type of thing" reasoning, but it probably behooves them to at least try to get him in the country so they can assist with whatever help he needs regarding alcohol. It would show future free agents that the organization is committed to them in good times and bad.
Bill: How long do they roll with 3 catchers for and is Diaz ultimately ticketed back to Indy?
Bill Brink: Hurdle said they would re-evaluate at the break, maybe Friday if Cervelli makes it through this series OK. And yes, that's probably the case, even though he deserves to be in the majors. Think of it this way. Say they cut ties with Stewart. Then Cervelli gets hurt again. Now Diaz takes a foul ball off his throwing hand and he's out a month. Your starting catchers are Jacob Stallings and Jackson Williams. They'll want to preserve their depth.
Bill Brink: Two Marlins stand out -- Martin Prado and David Phelps. Prado is a great clubhouse guy who could work in at third with Freese, though the Marlins would have to pay down some of his salary. Phelps would help that bullpen. I'm not reporting this, mind you, just looking for fits.
szweed: who would you think would be a good pick up at the deadline
Bill Brink: Oops. That was the question.
Robert: What are the odds the pirates pick up a bullpen arm
Bill Brink: If they can put together a bit of a run and get closer to .500 and the Brewers, I'd say pretty good.
Barry: I am guilty of Hurdle-criticism often. Sunday, when we needed a win to avoid being swept by the Giants, your two best hair hitters, Cutch and Harrison, are not in the lineup. I understand everyone needs a break now and then, but not under those circumstances. And we hear how amazing a job Searage does with certain pitchers but not much above how he's not gotten many to succeed. The list is a long one.
Bill Brink: I usually understand the notion of resting guys to keep them as fresh as possible for the future. But here, if you lose that game, it might not matter how fresh players are in September. But, Hurdle often speaks of projecting the mentality he'd like to see in his players, so if he started McCutchen and Harrison on days he'd usually rest them, according to their protocol, players might think he was panicking. You can cut it both ways.
szweed: surprised that the supposedly tough centraldivision is ruled by the brewers and cubs and cards are behind
Bill Brink: Very. I figured the Cubs' pitching would take a step back (Hendricks was due for regression) but I didn't see this, nor did I see that lineup struggling as much as it has. I didn't have Orlando Arcia hitting .295 with a .773 OPS, or Travis Shaw raking, or Chase Anderson with a 2.89 ERA. And the Cardinals, they usually figure it out, so their performance is surprising on a number of levels.
Bill Brink: High-level analysis on the Cardinals there, I know. But that's a well-run organization so you usually don't see this much roster turnover and this many things going wrong this early.
Nate : With all the young arms in The MLB and AAA (William, Kuhl,Brault, Hutchinson, Kingham, Glasnow) what do you think their plan is with all of them? Do some get traded or moved to pen?
Bill Brink: They're all young enough that they don't need to worry about a logjam just yet (although Brault is pitching well enough to force them to think about him). The depth is desirable. They can trade one, or put one in relief, or just have more guys when one inevitably gets hurt, because all pitchers do.
Matt: Your gut as of today, July 5: is Cutch on the move or not?
Bill Brink: His performance and the team's record say yes, but without a lack of a clear landing spot and the fact that they can still trade him in the offseason, I'll say no. It's a tentative no.
szweed: bucs stay intact, less cutch, odds they contend in 2018
Bill Brink: I'd say pretty good odds.
David in LA: Do the Pirates have any players they can trade other than ML prospects and remain in contention? Also are you surprised that there are three divisions with only one team above 500?
Bill Brink: There aren't many pieces on the active roster who are both expendable and also valuable enough to trade. I'm not too surprised by the divisions. These years happen. Remember when the three best teams in the league were in the NL Central a few years ago?
Robert: Is it possible that meadows stays the year in the minors I'd think it would be better for him
Bill Brink: It's possible, if not probable, especially given his most recent injury.
Bill Brink: Lightning round. Go.
szweed: cutch goes to....??
Bill Brink: The Rangers would make sense, given their outfield and the need for help against left-handed pitching, but they're chasing the wild card with Houston running away with things so who knows if they'd want to do that.
Fish Monger: If Nutting unloads salary like most think he will, will you guys in the press finally call him out and call out Huntington and Coonelly for spinning?
Bill Brink: I can't speak for the rest of the press but I write about Nutting and payroll when it's appropriate. Like when the team included two prospects to dump salary last year, or when their payroll dropped several million dollars from 2016 this April.
Zack: If we trade Cutch, think we may look to pick up another OF?
Bill Brink: Good question. Maybe with Meadows hurt, they do, if they're in contention, but if they're in contention, do they trade McCutchen? It's a tough call.
JWBURGH: What should we expect from Marte rusty and struggles last 2 months or ignites offense and throws bucs into the sorry NL Central race?
Bill Brink: No reason to expect anything different than in the past (unless he was using Nandrolone previously without getting caught) and maybe with a clearer mind, and a suspension not hanging over his head, he can perform better than in April. There will be an adjustment as he faces major league pitching for the first time in three months, though, to be sure.
PhillyJake: Is the NL Central really that weak? Or are there enough strong teams that beat up on each other such that it keeps the division's teams records down?
Bill Brink: I think the Brewers are better than everybody thought, and the Cardinals, Cubs and Pirates weaker than expected. I wouldn't say it's a bunch of great teams going SEC West on each other.
Fish Monger: You think the Pirates' management regrets the Cervelli extension now? He hasn't lived up to anything we all thought. Pretty disappointing.
Bill Brink: Probably not because the organization is so thin at catcher in the upper levels. He may not be Sal Perez but he's serviceable when healthy.
David in LA: After all these years would you consider Polanco a bust and would you trade him?
Bill Brink: I wouldn
Bill Brink: Oops. I wouldn't consider him a bust or trade him yet. He's 25 still and has shown good things at times. Consistency is what's needed.
Fish Monger: Is JHay gonna be traded?
Bill Brink: Don't think so.
Bill Brink: That's it for today, thanks for all the great questions. We'll do this again next week.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.