The two most valuable trade pieces the Pirates possess leading up to the July 31 trade deadline trace divergent paths. The circumstances surrounding one, Andrew McCutchen, are conducive to a trade, but there are few clear-cut suitors. The Pirates have no need or desire to move the other, Gerrit Cole, but his high value and some logical destinations generate the conversation.

The possible move of McCutchen has been discussed — not just by reporters and analysts, but scouts and executives — since at least last July. But while an eventual trade of Cole would make sense — Scott Boras clients generally hit free agency and the Pirates, under owner Bob Nutting and general manager Neal Huntington, have not paid the $20 million and up per year that the best starting pitchers command on the open market — the Pirates’ record, Cole’s performance and other teams’ circumstances conspire to make the notion — if not likely — at least worth considering.

“This is coming up on my fifth deadline here,” Cole said. “I’m not really surprised by anything. We don't know what goes on. No player knows what goes on in those conversations in terms of where the organization is going to go and what offers they have on the table and what’s best, what’s in the best interest of the organization.”

McCutchen and Cole’s recent performance increased their trade value, but it could also push the Pirates to hold onto them. They entered the weekend five games worse than .500, at 37-42, hardly the record of a team in contention, let alone looking to hold assets or add — and yet there they were, in contention, four games out of first in the quagmire that is the 2017 NL Central. Adding to the argument to stand pat, or add: Doing so could net them a division title and a guaranteed NLDS appearance, not a roll of the dice in the wild-card game.

Advertise with us

Cole is 26 and is under team control for two more years, at salaries determined by arbitration after this season. A four-start stretch during which almost every mistake turned into a home run increased his season ERA to 4.11; prior to that he had a 2.84 ERA, and in three starts since then he has allowed three runs and 11 hits in 20 innings.

“I've been really consistent in terms of the things I can control and really consistent, if not the most consistent, with my process,” Cole said. “I’ve just really been pleased with how I’ve gone about my business this year so far. I think it’s been the best of my career.”

With two and a half seasons of control left, Huntington doesn’t need to trade Cole and has not expressed a desire to do so, yet Cole’s name continues to surface in published reports about teams needing starting pitchers, along with Sonny Gray and Jose Quintana. Why? It is possible a rival GM forces Huntington’s hand by bringing the house in an offer. Let’s say that happens. Where could he go?

The Houston Astros are running away with the AL West (53-26 and 12½ games ahead of the second-place Los Angeles Angels entering Thursday) but Dallas Keuchel, Lance McCullers and Charlie Morton have all spent time on the disabled list this year, and Collin McHugh has yet to pitch because of an elbow impingement. Adding Cole to Keuchel and McCullers would create a strong trio of starters for the postseason.

The situation goes beyond matchmaking: Multiple reports say the Astros have interest.

Advertise with us

Adding Cole to the New York Yankees rotation would help compensate for the inconsistency of Masahiro Tanaka. Plus, the Yankees have liked Cole since 2008, when they drafted him in the first round out of high school; he instead attended UCLA. Jon Paul Morosi of MLB.com reported this week that the Los Angeles Dodgers have discussed Cole, a southern California native, among possible starter acquisitions.

One rival evaluator pointed to the Texas Rangers, who were 2½ games back in the wild-card standings. They have Martin Perez and A.J. Griffin on the disabled list (they’re starting Nick Martinez and Austin Bibens-Dirkx these days) and Cole Hamels has a 4.38 ERA.

As much as the mere idea of trading Cole has to do with his value, which might never be higher, it also hinges upon the front office’s view of their chance to contend next year. A full year of Starling Marte and Jameson Taillon, and the (potential) return of Jung Ho Kang, could portend better days ahead. It is hard to imagine contention without Cole.

McCutchen has a $14.5 million club option for 2018 before hitting free agency, at which point he’ll be 32. Given what other outfielders signed for in recent years (Jacoby Ellsbury at seven years and $153 million, Adam Jones at six and $85.5 million, Hunter Pence at five and $90 million) it is unlikely the Pirates will pay market value for what are usually the decline years of a player’s career. They showed by trading Neil Walker a year before free agency that fan backlash won’t deter what they see as the best move for the club.

They could, of course, hang onto McCutchen and trade him in the offseason, or at next year’s deadline. His recent surge, spurred by two days out of the lineup and a month-long stint in the No. 6 spot, has him looking and playing like his old self, which will help the Pirates make a run at the division as much as it would help them move him.

Advertise with us

“I was able to kind of relax a little bit to see what the pitcher, his command, see what he was doing, and it helped me relax a tad,” McCutchen said. “But prior to all that stuff it was more just working and getting myself ready and honestly I feel, three hole or six, I would be where I’m at now.”

But where would he go? Most contenders either have set outfields, other holes or both.

Back to Texas again. McCutchen could either replace Delino DeShields in left field or move Carlos Gomez there and take over center. The Rangers’ .221 average against lefties is second-to-last in baseball (and right behind the Pirates); McCutchen would help there too. Manager Jeff Banister knows McCutchen as well as anyone — he scouted a teenaged McCutchen who pitched and played shortstop for Fort Meade (Fla.) High when he worked in the Pirates organization. But would the Rangers give up top prospects Yohander Mendez or Leody Taveras, as one evaluator suggested such a move would take, for a chance at a one-game wild-card against Chris Sale in Fenway Park?

McCutchen has dealt with the reports for almost a year. They are newer to Cole. He said the players generally mute MLB Network when it comes on one of the clubhouse’s eight televisions, and he doesn’t have a Twitter account to apprise him of the latest reports.