It was nearing midnight March 31 in Montreal, and the team bus was idling outside the clubhouse at Olympic Stadium when manager Clint Hurdle, who already had whittled pitchers Steven Brault and Drew Hutchison from the candidates for the Pirates’ fifth-starter spot, called the remaining contenders into his office and informed them of his decision:

Tyler Glasnow had won the job. Trevor Williams would pitch in relief.

Call this take two.

On June 10, with Jameson Taillon set to return from the disabled list, the Pirates sent Glasnow to Class AAA Indianapolis. Like a choose-your-own-adventure book, they retreated to a step they had skipped earlier, selecting Williams instead of Glasnow for the all-right-handed rotation alongside the other four starters from the opening-day rotation. This time, they anticipate a better result.

Advertise with us

Truth is, it wasn’t only Glasnow who pushed the Pirates toward trying Rotation 2.0. The starting pitchers had endured a truly terrible stretch with Taillon on the mend and were 26-35 when Glasnow was demoted, nine games under .500 for the first time in more than five years.

In April, the rotation emerged with a 3.63 ERA — 3.15 if one removed Glasnow from the equation — and were backed by National League pitcher of the month Ivan Nova, who in five starts had a 1.50 ERA, two complete games and 22 strikeouts to only one walk.

After a rough start in Cincinnati May 3, Taillon was placed on the disabled list and then underwent surgery for testicular cancer. In the five weeks Taillon was away, the rotation owned an inflated 5.87 ERA and allowed 2.28 home runs per nine innings, a sharp spike from their National League-leading 0.74 homer average in April.

In 31 games without Taillon, the rotation also averaged 5⅓ innings per start. If not for Nova, the number would be below a five-inning average.

An inability to consistently eat innings has been an issue for the rotation this season. A league-average length for a start in 2017 was, as of Thursday, 5.57 innings. The Pirates’ starters average start, in decimal form, looks like this: Nova 6.89 innings, Gerrit Cole 5.95, Taillon 5.76, Williams 5.09, Glasnow 4.53, Chad Kuhl 4.56. So three of six options have offered below-average distance.

Advertise with us

On June 10, a few hours before Williams tossed four innings of five-run baseball, Glasnow was officially optioned to the minors and right-handers A.J. Schugel and Edgar Santana joined a taxed bullpen. Glasnow had allowed seven runs, six earned, in four innings the previous night. Hurdle said short starts stacked together can really hurt the roster.

“There’s collateral damage that comes with a lack of innings picked up by your starters,” he said. “I think that’s one of the pieces of the puzzle that young pitchers start to figure out even more so along the way at this level. When you look at traffic in the clubhouse. When you look at having to add and subtract people to pitch innings. I think it gives them the best awareness they’ve ever had of the accountability and awareness that comes with a rotational spot.

“Not that it’s ever OK, but there is a price to pay when it’s not OK. Sometimes it’s not just you that’s paying a price. Sometimes it’s the team that has to take on the collateral damage. Sometimes other individuals as well. We’ll see how it plays out.”

There are a lot of ways to splice the numbers from the first 70 games or so of the season. Some of the most concerning concern Kuhl, who had a 4.20 ERA in 14 starts as a rookie last season. After 13 starts in 2017, he had a 5.61 ERA and had not pitched beyond the fifth inning in 10 consecutive appearances. His velocity has climbed a couple ticks across the board, his heater now averaging 95.3 mph, per PITCHf/x.

“We’re trying to help him simplify some things,” Hurdle said before Kuhl’s start Wednesday. “We saw a pitcher last year — 90 to 93 [mph] two-seamer, ground-ball guy — and then we’ve seen a guy the last six weeks ramp up velocity, in the last two starts take to a curveball like nobody I’ve seen in 43 years of the game, to throw a curveball [in the bullpen] a few times and take it out and use it in a game the way he’s used it against major league hitters.

Advertise with us

“We’re encouraging him to go out and pitch with his heartbeat. Don’t think about trying to be the guy you were last year. What you’re feeling right now, go use it to your advantage. It’s velocity. He’s shown the ability to maintain it for 90 pitches.”

Clearly, the Pirates aren’t entirely sure where Kuhl will go from here. He showed progress Wednesday but was lifted after five innings for a pinch-hitter, which has happened a few times recently. The curveball wasn’t effective against the Colorado Rockies. Hurdle said he hasn’t seen someone do that before, adopt a pitch he rarely, if ever, had used previously, and use it immediately and often.

“I don’t want him out there being two different guys,” Hurdle said. “We’ve just encouraged him that the guy who’s gone out there the last couple times, with velocity that has been real. I think we just need to let that guy go pitch.”

Kuhl’s evolution continues. The rotation, meanwhile, needs stability. Their overall ERA this season was 4.60 as of Thursday, which ranked 10th in the National League. It has followed a downward trajectory, however, from 3.63 ERA in April to 5.09 in May and 5.37 this month.

The starts since Taillon’s return have shown promise, however. If those flashes turn to sustained success, this rotation could carry the Pirates places and cause their deficit in the division to vanish in relatively short order.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: snesbitt@post-gazette.com and Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.