Alen Hanson is not an elite prospect, but the fringe major-league utilityman certainly has a name many Pirates fans know. He made brief appearances with the big club before making the opening day roster this year and has been in that next tier of “good” prospects for years — he was ranked as a top-10 second-base prospect as recently as last January.
Now he’s on his way out of the organization, officially designated for assignment Friday, yet again leaving a bit of egg on general manager Neal Huntington’s face with regard to how he handles his minor league assets.
Without the necessary contract options to send Hanson back to the minors amid a rough start to his season thus far spent on the big league bench, the Pirates lacked any leverage to trade him. Other teams that might want to acquire him weren’t going to give up anything of value when they knew the Pirates’ only choices were to keep the struggling player on the roster or designate him for assignment in hopes he’d slip through waivers. (He probably won’t.)
Bigger than the blunder of somehow burning the options on a player of good pedigree who never meaningfully contributed in the big leagues is the fact that, not long ago, the Pirates could have had much more for Hanson than they’re going to get. In fact, he probably could have been the headline prospect in a trade for a productive big leaguer. His name wasn’t floated quite as often as those of Tyler Glasnow, Austin Meadows and Josh Bell are now in rumored trade talks. But he was frequently mentioned as a coveted piece, and the Pirates never pulled the trigger.
This follows an Aug. 1 trade of Francisco Liriano with “good” prospects Reese McGuire and Harold Ramirez to the Blue Jays in what amounted to a salary dump. It’s not an apples-to-apples comparison because of the big money on Liriano’s contract involved, but it was another case of the Pirates giving up valuable commodities they’d cultivated in exchange for much less than they could have had.
This is the danger of hoarding prospects the way the Pirates do. Sometimes they pan out. Sometimes they don’t. And sometimes you miss the opportunity to use them to improve your team through trades.
This is not to say the Pirates should definitely jettison prospects for, say, Jose Quintana, the Chicago White Sox ace starter who, despite a bad start to the season, remains available in a trade. Glasnow and Bell are already here and making modest progress. Meadows is heating up at Class AAA Indianapolis, and there’s a good argument to be made that they can collectively make a bigger impact for the Pirates than Quintana would.
At the same time, it’s hard not to wonder what this team or past playoff runs would have looked like if Huntington and Co. had been more willing to part with the guys he ended up tightly clutching for no reason.
Some Pirates fans have a tendency to diminish the value of prospects to a small-market team like the Pirates because they’re inconvenient. There’s rarely an immediate reward with them the way there is in the NFL or, sometimes, the NHL, so it’s easy to value shiny veterans more when trade rumors pop up.
This is flawed thinking, as the Pirates’ farm system has done a great job supplying the talent that’s made the team relevant over the past few years.
When three fairly big names leave the organization in the unceremonious way Hanson, Ramirez and McGuire have, though, fans have a right to question management’s reluctance to use them as chips to make the team better.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter, @fugimaster24.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.