Andrew McCutchen was benched Wednesday — and Thursday — in Atlanta after an 0-for-5 performance Tuesday dropped his batting average to .200 for the season. It was the latest indignity in a career that had suffered few before last season.
For that reason, it’s tempting to think of his downturn as sudden. McCutchen’s production was excellent as recently as 2015, and so it’s reasonable to think he can regain some semblance of that form with a few adjustments. Or so the optimist hopes.
The reality is probably darker than that. While it’s true that McCutchen’s bottom-line numbers have only been unsatisfactory since 2016, clear trends in his peripheral statistical profile suggest his stock has been pointed south for much longer than most people think.
Let’s start with isolated power, a stat that gives a hitter’s extra bases per at-bat by subtracting batting average from slugging percentage. It’s a good measure because it boils the two stats used to calculate it into one that “isolates” how often a hitter gets past first base.
McCutchen’s has dropped every season since 2014, when he posted a career-high .228 ISO. That figure dipped to .196 in 2015, .174 last year and stands at .159 this season. That last number stands in stark contrast to his career ISO of .194 and tells a different story than his relatively stable home run total that has remained between 23 and 25 in each of the last three seasons before this one.
According to Fangraphs, a good ISO is about .200. An average one is about .140. So McCutchen’s numbers paint the picture of a player who has slowly — not all of a sudden — regressed from an elite power hitter to one who’s only slightly above average despite his respectable home run total of six this season.
Read More
McCutchen’s batting average on balls in play has also been in a nosedive for some time. This is a good statistic to watch because it can often tell us a lot about luck. The league average is usually around .300, so big departures from the average one way or the other are usually likely to regress or progress closer to the mean at some point.
McCutchen optimists would note with some hope that his BABIP this season is a ghastly .214 compared to a career number of .327 and a career low of .297 set last year. Some progression seems inevitable.
But even a 50 point swing won’t change the fact that this number has declined significantly over the last handful of years, too. McCutchen’s BABIP was at .355 in 2014 and has fallen off noticeably in every year since.
Both of these declines track almost perfectly with a prolonged dip in hard contact rate, which is a useful stat because it removes results, and thus ballpark factors, from consideration. It just focuses on how hard a hitter is striking the ball on average.
McCutchen’s career rate of hard contact is 36.9 percent, and his career high is 40.5 set in — you guessed it — 2014. It has also declined in every season since to 31.4 percent this year, just a hair better than his career low of 30.5 set in his rookie year in 2009.
Consider these three trends together, and they don’t add up to anything good.
It’s easy to explain away a bad month, a bad start, even a bad season as a result of a correctable problem, with a swing or an approach, for example. It’s harder to make that case about something that’s been unfolding for four years. More likely, we’re looking at a player whose skills have slowly but surely diminished, one who’s not hitting the ball hard — for power or average — because he simply can’t.
McCutchen had the benefit for a while of falling from a tall perch. His numbers may have gotten worse than they’d been, but they weren’t concerning until last summer. Perhaps that’s why the headlines about his struggles see his demise as alarmingly fast.
Make no mistake, though. McCutchen’s struggles run deeper than the last year and change. If he’s going to overcome them, it seems more likely at this point that it’ll be through reinvention, not rediscovery of the player he once was.
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter, @fugimaster24.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.