Welcome back, baseball fans. The Pirates salvaged the back half of a miserable road trip by winning the last two games in Arizona to split the four-game series. They are 16-22. Next, they begin a series against Washington (24-13). All questions are sic’d. If you have a question for next week’s mailbag, send it to snesbitt@post-gazette.com or to @stephenjnesbitt on Twitter.

Here we go.

James: think Hurdle job in jeopardy with current trend?

Stephen: The current trend forecasts a 68-win season, the sort — coming on the heels of 98 wins in 2015 and 78 in 2016 — that tend to put a manager’s job in jeopardy. From conversations with those in the front office as well as those in the Pirates clubhouse, the club’s current standing, in last place in the National League Central Division, is certain to change.

Advertise with us

Actually, whether Hurdle is on the hot seat is not the central question. The bigger issue is Hurdle and general manager Neal Huntington are still lame ducks, with the clock ticking in their final year under contract. Their current deals — three years apiece plus a 2018 club option — are up after this season, and the Pirates have not announced a contract extension or either option being guaranteed. When I asked owner Bob Nutting about this during spring training, he said contract extensions are “not something that’s top-of-mind for me. It’s not an issue at this point.”

Three months later, is the issue yet top-of-mind? When the Pirates last handed contract extensions to Huntington and Hurdle, they did both the same day, April 5, 2014. The sense I’ve gotten is the Pirates are highly unlikely to part ways with Huntington, who has overseen the organization’s player-acquisition and development operations since September 2007. But wouldn’t it be strange to announce a new agreement with Huntington without doing the same for Hurdle?

Hurdle and Huntington have said they are not concerned about being in their final guaranteed years under contract. When asked in March whether a contract extension was a back-burner item for him, too, Hurdle replied: “I don’t even have a burner. I’m taking care of today. I like where I’m at. I love the organization. I’m humbled to get the opportunity to do it. It’ll get figured out.”

It is not clear what conversations have been had behind closed doors — maybe it will be figured out — but there’s no question it’s a sticky situation for all sides, whether or not they admit it.

As for the Pirates’ current downward trend, a loss here or there can be blamed on Hurdle’s game management, but the primary problem, I think most would agree, is a roster high on turnover and low on hitting. The roster is the way it is for a number of reasons — injury, suspension, arrest, ineffectiveness, reliance on the minor league system and inability or unwillingness to spend top dollar in free agency. Most are not a manager’s fault. But if poor play erodes the clubhouse and strains the staff’s relationship with the front office, the losses tend to be lumped on the manager. If management doesn’t see a future with Hurdle, they could continue to play out the string until season’s end, or they could cut ties even earlier.

Advertise with us

It’s an odd conversation to have considering Hurdle steered the ship as the Pirates returned to relevance in the past five years. But he was less than two years removed from a trip to the World Series when the Colorado Rockies canned him in 2009. Now, two years after a 98-win season with the Pirates, Hurdle is a lame duck in charge of a shaky roster. It is a dicey position.

Chad: Is it safe to say that Daniel Hudson is the worst bullpen acquisition of the Huntington Era?

Stephen: How soon you forget Ernesto Frieri. The Pirates traded Jason Grilli to the Los Angeles Angels July 24, 2014 for Frieri, who allowed 12 runs in 10⅔ innings before being released in early September. Hudson, however, is making more money, owed $11 million over two years. His recent performance has been problematic, giving up nine earned runs in his past six innings. He said things need to improve. We will watch and see.

Jake: Why is John Jaso still a thing?

Stephen: He homered and doubled in pinch-hit opportunities in the past week and still can’t get some love? He’s batting .157 with a .553 OPS, but he’s worth attempting to resurrect because he’s making $4 million this season and because he’s been a productive hitter in the past. For more on what’s ailed him this season, read this story and this story from this past week.

Advertise with us

Mike: you can write all day why jaso isn't performing up to his usual standards but the main question is why are all the reserves the pirates brought in this year are so sick. not one of them is batting worth their weight. management has sunk to its lowest level for their picks. one of your readers said the pirates look like a minor league team. wrong. they look like a confused and disorganized little league team. even when the regulars now on the disabled list were playing, they didn't really look any good. the pirate brass has really let their fans down this time.

Stephen: This isn’t a question, but I’ll allow you to use this as a safe space to vent. By “all the reserves the pirates brought in this year,” I imagine you mean just Phil Gosselin, because no one else was brought in. The rest are returners Jaso, Chris Stewart and Adam Frazier and rookies from Class AAA Indianapolis, all internal options. I’ll agree the bench has struggled this season, and, as usual, lend the explanation that until spring training or so the Pirates expected their bench to be Jaso, Stewart, Frazier, David Freese and (most likely) Alen Hanson. It wasn’t as if the Pirates twiddled their thumbs through free agency knowing the bench May 8 would consist of Jaso, Stewart, Hanson, Jose Osuna, Gift Ngoepe, Max Moroff and Chris Bostick. It’s fine to gripe about the roster. It is your prerogative. But understand also how the Pirates got here.

Charles: I recall reading a couple of years ago that some organization that specialized in analyzing the talent in the Minor Leagues had ranked the Pirates as having one of the best minor league farm system prospects. That ranking didn't only rank the pitchers, but also position players. If that was true, why does it seem that the Pirates haven't been able to bring any position players up to the the Major League and have success? And, why does it seem that Huntington hasn't had any success in drafting position players who can make an impact quickly like e.g. the Cubs?

Stephen: The reason the Pirates have been ranked so highly the past few years primarily is because of their bumper crop of starting pitching. Think through some of the top names the past five years: Gerrit Cole, Jameson Taillon, Nick Kingham, Tyler Glasnow, Clay Holmes, Chad Kuhl, Steven Brault, Mitch Keller. Some have arrived. Some have disappointed or departed. Some are yet to come.

Same goes for the hitters. Arrived: Starling Marte, Gregory Polanco, Josh Bell and Adam Frazier. Disappointed/departed: Tony Sanchez, Alen Hanson, Reese McGuire and Harold Ramirez. Yet to come: Austin Meadows, Kevin Newman and Cole Tucker.

Advertise with us

One reason the Pirates fielded only three players on the most recent Baseball America top-100 prospects ranking is players play their way past prospect status. Bell and Glasnow no longer qualify. Neither do Taillon or Kuhl. The majority of their top prospects now are a little further from the majors than the ones a year ago. Meadows and Newman aren’t ready to be called up. When they are, they should be stronger than the players currently being shuttled back and forth between Indianapolis and Pittsburgh.

As for Huntington’s drafts, it’s a fair criticism. Since 2008, the Pirates have drafted eight position players in the first round: Pedro Alvarez, Sanchez, McGuire, Meadows, Tucker, Hayes, Newman and Will Craig. Alvarez was a successful pick, in some ways, despite the fact he was taken just ahead of Eric Hosmer and Buster Posey. Sanchez was a whiff, and McGuire hasn’t yet panned out. Meadows, Tucker and Hayes were drafted out of high school, so they weren’t going to make an immediate impact in the majors. Newman and Craig were taken out of college, so their climb should be more swift, but they still were drafted only in the past two years.

Help should be on the way, but some still is way down the road.

Don: What is wrong with Polanco? He takes bad routes to fly balls, he's allergic to RBI's and clueless with his approach at hitting!!! Pirates seem to be able to draft and produce quality second baseman, which is great but why can't we get anyone who hits HR??? I looked at the top 100 prospects. We stink. We have Austin and Newman and Keller I believe. Watching the Dodgers with this group of young hard hitting players it's frustrating our lack of drafting quality HR hitting players!!!!!!! Also, I know this will sound stupid from a fan from Arkansas but has anyone tried to adjust McCutchen's swing??? Andreas Galarraga went through a lull in his career. He turned it around by opening his stance and putting both eyes on the ball. That adjustment alone he started seeing the ball better and it renewed his career.

Stephen: This is like the previous question, just more entertaining.

Advertise with us

Polanco has a plus arm, but probably will not be a Gold Glover because of his feet and GPS in right field. He’s heated up lately at the plate but needs to find more consistency with his swing.

McCutchen does not appear to have changed his swing. He’s not a tinkerer. The issues, as I see them, are pitch selection and patience when pitchers are staying off the plate away. He wants to think less: “When things are going well, you ain’t thinking about crap except hitting the ball — hitting the crap out of the ball,” he said. “That’s about it.”

Tom: [Frazier] ROTY contender?

Stephen: Not with the way Cody Bellinger is swinging. Ultimately, if healthy, Bell may be a better rookie of the year candidate, too, given the power he can provide. He currently has a .814 OPS with seven dingers, already four more than he had last season. The power has arrived.

Terry: what are the chances of Kang's return to the Pirates this summer? Better than 50 50 or worse?

Advertise with us

Stephen: Worse, probably. I do not know this as a fact, but there is little reason for optimism. Kang has an appeals hearing later this month. We may know more then. He apparently needs to hope for a lesser punishment and to convince the United States government to grant him a visa.

CH: How long will Polanco be out?

Stephen: We will have a better idea Wednesday when head athletic trainer Todd Tomczyk holds his weekly media session. Polanco was pulled from Sunday’s game with hamstring discomfort. He said he tweaked it while chasing a ball in the right-field corner. He remained in the game for his next at-bat, looked bad attempting to swing and was removed. His is listed as day-to-day.

Bryan: how is Jamison taillon doing ??

Stephen: We will have a better idea the day we speak with him. Tomczyk declined to offer any update on Taillon last week, referring only to the team’s statement.

Advertise with us

Will: Should the Pirates consider using LeBlanc in a Andrew Miller type role.

Stephen: Most days one can barely tell a difference between the two.

Andrew Miller, Cleveland Indians: 0.47 ERA, .147 BAA, 0.79 WHIP, 12.32 K/9, 26 K, 5 BB. Average fastball velocity of 94.3 mph.

Wade LeBlanc, Pittsburgh Pirates: 2.08 ERA, .188 BAA, 0.92 WHIP, 6.65 K/9, 16 K, 5 BB. Average fastball velocity of 86.8 mph.

Comparative jokes aside, LeBlanc has given the Pirates everything they could have asked from him. He’s been superb in a long-relief role, and I don’t imagine they’re going to ask him to do much more than that. He entered in a bases-loaded situation Sunday and walked in a run. Not his job, typically.

Stephen J. Nesbitt: snesbitt@post-gazette.com and Twitter @stephenjnesbitt.