Pitcher Vance Worley was released by the Washington Nationals Wednesday, and with the Pirates still lukewarm about their internal options for a No. 5 starter, it’s easy to wonder whether general manager Neal Huntington might opt to bring the hurler back here, where he pitched fairly well in 2014 and 2015.

Don’t.

No, Worley didn’t leave the Pirates on bad terms when the team designated him for assignment in late July of 2015. That year, he posted a solid 4.02 ERA in 23 appearances, eight of them starts. The Pirates simply had better options both in the rotation and bullpen, so Worley was expendable.

And yes, there’s reason for concern now that Trevor Williams and Tyler Glasnow are the two remaining competitors for the No. 5 spot. Both are inexperienced, and neither has wowed Huntington, who said of the state of the competition Sunday: “It makes it a tougher decision for them because they’ve left it to us. You always want the players to make the decisions for you. You always want somebody to step up, grab hold of the job, take it and run with it.”

Advertise with us

They haven’t.

But Worley seems unlikely to fit into Huntington’s plans despite a 3.53 ERA in 35 games pitching mostly in relief for Baltimore in 2016. On the surface, he seems like he might be a steady hand for a rotation that could use one right now. There are some red flags hiding in his profile, though.

Many of Worley’s peripheral stats suffered last season despite his solid ERA. His strikeout rate went down to 5.82 per nine innings from a career rate of 6.76. His walks were up to 3.63 per nine against a career number of 2.87. And his home run to fly ball ratio jumped to 12.1 percent last season from 7.8 percent with the Pirates the year before.

All of this inflated his Fielding Independent Pitching, or FIP, to an ominous 4.82. (FIP is a stat that projects ERA based solely on outcomes a pitcher can control: walks, strikeouts, home runs and hit batters.)

He also may have been a little lucky on batted balls. His batting average on balls in play, or BABIP, was .281, about 20 points below the big-league average of .300 and his career rate of .303. A regression to those means this season would shoot his ERA north in a hurry.

Advertise with us

Throw in an ordinary spring in which Worley posted a 4.80 ERA with six walks and six strikeouts in 15 innings, and it’s fairly easy to see why the Pirates passed on him when they had a chance to sign him in the offseason.

Williams and Glasnow might be unproven, but Glasnow is one of the Pirates’ top prospects and Williams has shown promise in the minor leagues. There’s reason to believe both have a lot more upside than Worley, even if their path to it includes a bump or two.